4 ms·
As some one who managed to succeed in the academic rat race (tenured professor) and who quit to do more productive things, my feeling is academia is more like c
by danieltillett 11y ago
As some one who managed to succeed in the academic rat race (tenured professor) and who quit to do more productive things, my feeling is academia is more like cult. When inside it you believe you are doing important things, and on occasion you actual do (i.e. teaching and research), but the important activities are basically a hobby you fit around your full-time job of administration and politics. Once outside you realise you were wasting your life on trivia of the most meaningless kind. While I miss some parts I have to say I am glad to be out.
- timrpeterson 11y agoHaving tenure affords opportunity. Can't get the golden parachute unless you play the game long enough (i.e., waste prime years).
- danieltillett 11y agoI certainly missed the golden parachute. Even if I hung around until I was deadwood I would not have made anything financially. No academic in Australia gets rich just out of being an academic. I don’t regret my time as an academic other than my last two years. I should have left earlier, but the security the job afforded my family kept me there longer than I really should have stayed. This is a mistake many people make when in a secure job when they have kids so I am not too angry at myself. It is an experience few people get to have so I am grateful to have had it.
- daleroberts 11y agoI beg to differ. You can make a significant amount of money as an academic in Australia if you are in the right discipline to get a market loading and be able to do consulting on the side. AU$200-300K a year is easy to achieve for these academics some are even pulling in $500K+ by the end of their career. Plus the 17% superannuation means you'll retire with a nice big pot of retirement money at the end. Very hard to find a comparable position in industry...
- 1stop 11y agoWhich discipline are you speaking of? That kind of money I've only heard of in finance land (for academics)... and that kind of dried up after 2008.
- daleroberts 11y agoYes, Finance is the biggest and the money still flows. Look at all the recent hires in Finance at UNSW and UMelb who have been appointed at the Senior Lecturer level straight after PhD. Market loadings are paid in Medecine too. Probably Law as well... I've also heard that Statistics and doing Machine Learning consulting on side is good too. What surprised me the most is all the arts/sociology academics doing big consulting contracts connected to "foreign aid" work.
- sillygeese 11y agoAh yes, fat salaries on other people's money, and a fat pension on other people's money! Sweet deal!
- 1stop 11y ago... That describes every job... ever. Unless you are the one stealing the resources directly from the land... in which case: Fat salaries on other peoples' property. But hey, hate on the academics, they are the WORST! right?
- loup-vaillant 11y ago> That describes every job... ever Wait, what? Most jobs give you a salary, sure, but you nearly always end up producing far more value than you are paid back. The thieves are the shareholders of the company you serve. (As for the land… not every piece of land is someone's property —and that's good.)
- saalweachter 11y agoIf you are producing more value than you are being paid for, why are you working there?
- i000 11y agoA well established principal investigator said this to his lab during a crisis "we are out of money" meeting: "We are all in the same boat, but only I have a parachute"
- rhodri 11y agoI can't imagine a parachute is that useful on a sinking ship
- danieltillett 11y agoThe rope would be very useful to strangle the PI who said this.
- danieltillett 11y agoI can’t imagine ever saying something like this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jschwartzi 11y agoIf somebody said this to me at my current job I'd start using up all the paid vacation time I have to look for another job.
- robotresearcher 11y ago> No academic in Australia gets rich just out of being an academic. Nobody ever expected to, in any country. Did they?
- ild 11y agoIn the USSR of 60s - 70s senior scientists/profs were upper middle class, and had high social status.
- tdumitrescu 11y agoMy experience was very similar. While I was in the land of postdoc fellowships and part-time teaching, it was a great job where I gladly accepted low pay in return for freedom to work on my own projects and structure my time independently. By the time I was a few years into a tenured post (at a European university), the amount of administrative drudgery, committees, useless meetings and other BS entirely unrelated to my skillset as an academic had grown tremendously - enough to make it quite easy to quit when I saw opportunities in the software industry. When I look back at it now, I still bristle a little at how much worse it got over the years, almost feels like a bait-and-switch. I have several other friends who've since left their tenured positions while still young, all of us with this feeling that we were stuck in a type of work we really hadn't signed up for.
- johnchristopher 11y agoOut of curiosity, how old were you when you left ?
- tdumitrescu 11y ago34. other profs i've known who quit academia were in their late 30s/early 40s. (and of course a ton of grad students and undergrads who stopped much earlier, and people who never got jobs and eventually worked outside academia, but that's much more common)
- bitwize 11y agoWhat do you get when you combine the economic mechanism of a drug gang with the mind control technology of a cult, used to keep people in the system? A multi-level marketing scheme.
- cafebeen 11y agoI think a multi-level marketing scheme includes a benefit for recruiting new people, in the form of some sort of "downline" compensation. As far as academia goes, this doesn't really exist, otherwise there'd be teaching/research assistant assistants, and so on
- Ivanov 11y ago> Once outside you realise you were wasting your life on trivia of the most meaningless kind. I think it depends. From the outside, industry looks to be churning out nothing, but trivial stuff for sale.
- fsloth 11y ago"From the outside, industry looks to be churning out nothing, but trivial stuff for sale." I suppose what one chooses to focus on. The stuff I do in industry helps people design houses and infrastructure.
- andrepd 11y agoConcrete mixing companies help people build houses and infrastructure, if you want to put it that way. Still, it's the epitome of churning out trivial stuff.