3 ms·
> But, nobody was actually harmed That's ends-justifies the means. I'm not arguing someone was hurt, I'm arguing they put people in a situation with a higher t
by MBCook 11y ago
> But, nobody was actually harmed
That's ends-justifies the means. I'm not arguing someone was hurt, I'm arguing they put people in a situation with a higher than necessary risk.
> I commuted into Houston on that same day and counted half a dozen disabled vehicles on my route, and two police officers trying to catch speeders; both of which add at least the same magnitude of risk to other motorists.
You can't control what other drivers around you do to cause road hazards, but in this case that's exactly what the hackers did. By cutting the transmission they caused a possibly dangerous situation.
They could have done this test safely in numbers ways. On a rig designed for testing horsepower, an abandoned parking lot, a private track, or asked some police to close a section of road.
Instead they did it in about the most dangerous way possible: live on uncontrolled roads with other traffic.
> "They" the two that did the risky road demo, or "they" the ones who waited 9 months to mitigate the safety defect in thousands of cars?
The 'researchers'/hackers. They directly put people's lives at risk to have a stunt to prove their point.
FCA screwed up big, and deserve some sort of penalty from the government. This shouldn't have been possible in the first place. But they didn't modify a running vehicle at 70mph surrounded by unsuspecting motorists.
If the hackers had done this reasonably safely, I'd have no issue at all. But they don't deserve the title 'researcher' after behaving like that.
- gtremper 11y agoThe "ends justifying the means" is not a fallacy, unless you think Consequentialism is completely wrong[1]. In this case, it seems a lot of people do think the ends justify the means. In other words, the risk was morally justified given the results. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequentialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequentialism
- MBCook 11y agoI don't think it its a good argument in this cases since they had much safer options.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>That's ends-justifies the means. I don't like it either, but it's a common philosophy that we experience in our daily lives, whether we want it to be that way or not. >Instead they did it in about the most dangerous way possible: live on uncontrolled roads with other traffic. There are a number of ways they could have made it worse. >The 'researchers'/hackers. They directly put people's lives at risk to have a stunt to prove their point. We tolerate the same kinds of risks daily by allowing police to conduct traffic stops on busy roadways. We do so ostensibly because safety, but the reality is that it is mostly for some pretty dubious financial reasons. That's ends justify the means, and in this case ends are traffic fines collected, and the means are lives of police officers and motorists and man-decades of time lost in traffic every day. >FCA screwed up big, and deserve some sort of penalty from the government. But not jail, like for the evil hackers-not-researchers? >This shouldn't have been possible in the first place. Another uncomfortable reality for you. Software verification is a huge challenge which nobody has gotten right yet. There will be more of these vulnerabilities. We have to get this disclosure/update process right. The best thing that automakers can do to prevent disclosure stunts like this is to fix vulnerabilities ASAP when they're discovered. >But they didn't modify a running vehicle at 70mph surrounded by unsuspecting motorists. What they did/do (months worth of nothing) is far worse, and endangers far more lives. Imagine if someone/somegroup/somegov't had managed to bundle this vuln with a popular cell-phone app, or mobile website, and decided to activate it one day at rush hour. >If the hackers had done this reasonably safely, I'd have no issue at all. But they don't deserve the title 'researcher' after behaving like that. That's just petty, and nobody really cares what you call them. It does nothing to move the discussion in a fruitful direction; but it does make you appear a bit shallow in your reasoning.
- MBCook 11y ago> We tolerate the same kinds of risks daily by allowing police to conduct traffic stops on busy roadways. We've chosen to accept that risk, and have control over it though government. People could choose to make it illegal. Also note that when the police do it they take precautions such as having bright multi-colored lights on the car to draw attention. It also bothers me that the Wired guy didn't know what was going to happen, so he couldn't prepare as well. Even that would have helped (though I still think the stunt was dangerous enough for someone to go to jail). > But not jail, like for the evil hackers-not-researchers? We can't put a company in jail and we don't usually do it with the CEO for much bigger crimes. I doubt the CEO had any idea this could happen. I imagine this is one of those things where dozens of people in different departments (and even companies due to auto parts suppliers) all made small but not terrible bad decisions that added up to a huge problem. I doubt there is a smoking gun email someone where a manager says 'I know someone could disable the car on the freeway but it will save us millions!' And while this is happening to FCA there are other cars with cell connected systems (VW, BMW, Audi, others). I imagine if we had enoug time we'd find at least 2 or 3 other companies with vulnerable systems in other car brands's 2015 models. I just don't see how we could jail anyone in FCA. That's why I didn't call for it. On the other hand the hackers seems like a pretty cut and try case. > That's just petty, and nobody really cares what you call them. The words you use to describe something matter. Having taken such a stupid risk I don't see why they should ask to be acknowledged on the same level as security professionals who don't put people in danger for headlines. Frankly the number of people in these threads defending the overly dangerous demo scares me, as does the number of people who seem to tacitly encourage such behavior.