5 ms·
The original 'researcher' (because they did something so horrendously unsafe on public roads) mentioned that there are at least 2 car manufacturers who have dev
by MBCook 11y ago
The original 'researcher' (because they did something so horrendously unsafe on public roads) mentioned that there are at least 2 car manufacturers who have devices on the CAN bus to watch traffic and detect when a device is issuing commands that it shouldn't be so the tampering can be detected (and assumedly shut the infotainment system off).
- fineman 11y agoOh give it up. That's just ridiculous SJW nonsense and you sound like anti-vaxers who say "If there's even a one in a billion chance of that vaccine hurting a child, you're a murderer!" Cars stall all the time on the highway. Lanes merge and traffic continues. It's not like they caused the car to swerve, or accelerate - it slowed in a controllable manner.
- biot 11y agoAnd a stalled/wrecked/slowed vehicle on a highway sometimes results in death: http://i.imgur.com/dgHm3E9.gifv http://i.imgur.com/dgHm3E9.gifv [redundant warning: death] http://i.imgur.com/V6aySGy.gifv http://i.imgur.com/V6aySGy.gifv You can't control for other bad drivers' reactions to your vehicle becoming an obstacle on the highway. Swerve and change lanes? Sure, in an ideal world that always happens. In the real world, accidents can happen instead.
- fineman 11y agoYes, it could. A vaccine could kill a child. A meteor could crush the HN server as I post this. But is it even remotely likely? No. Of course not. Discussing it is pointless and counterproductive. It's not like you've been down the list of likely harms-sorted-by-danger and reached this one.
- Retric 11y agoLet's say there is a low chance of death from doing this: 1:10:000. Arguably that's about the same as sending someone to jail for 1:10,000th their life. Which is about 2 and 1/2 days which is not ‘horrific’. Still, I would hope sending a random person to prison for a few days to stage a story seems unacceptable. On the other hand vaccinations are both lower risks and a higher benefit so it’s not really comparable.
- fineman 11y agoIt's not like they slammed on the brakes - they cut engine power. Totally different. The car gently glided to a stop. Add four or five more zeros and you'll be in the ballpark. And if you're serious about saving lives, consider that this is a trivial fix (unplug the sim card) and the car company has known about this for months since these researchers told them about it. These a non-zero chance that this attack could be broadly deployed at any time, causing a sizable portion of the 500,000 vulnerable vehicles (those in traffic) to almost certainly crash - probably into other vehicles, etc. The researchers caused some non-zero but incredibly minor amount of risk for some people to save a vastly larger group from a vastly greater risk. This is why you sounds like anti-vaxxers. Even discussing this at all is a total failure of proportion. Yes - the 'risk' of vaccination might be non-zero but it's less than the risk of Polio by many orders of magnitude.
- kbenson 11y agoYou are unqualified to determine the level of risk that was imposed on the other drivers. You have no idea how many zeros to add or remove to how likely an accident was to result from this. I'm not sure there exists a person that could give an accurate representation beyond generalities, so please don't present yourself as this person. The point, the only point, really, that people have with their actions is that they endangered other people on purpose and without their consent. I wouldn't defend someone weaving between cars in traffic and leaving inches between bumpers doing so (I'm sure many of us have seen this) for the exact same reason. There are far too many variables to accurately account for, so they are raising the risk to all the people around them. Even an expert driver can't claim to know how every other driver on the road will react. That the researchers did this for what I'm sure most of us believe is a good reason is irrelevant, given there were alternatives. They made a judgement call, and now we are all upset at their poor judgement.
- fineman 11y ago> They made a judgement call, and now we are all upset at their poor judgement. Yeah, unreasonably so. But, I get that you're upset. > You are unqualified to determine the level of risk that was imposed on the other drivers. I think anyone who has driven is at least somewhat qualified to determine the level of risk in common scenarios. The Jeep didn't even apply its brakes. > You have no idea how many zeros to add or remove to how likely an accident was to result from this. It was a rough guess, but I did try to check it. 1:10,000 common interactions becoming fatal accidents would depopulate the earth rapidly. > I'm not sure there exists a person that could give an accurate representation beyond generalities, so please don't present yourself as this person. Oh I see, and when you'd told everyone else that they weren't experts you got around to me. Okay, well, sure. In that case.
- macintux 11y agoGiven some of the edge case interactions in any complex system, they did not and could not know that the only impact would be slowing the car down. You should listen to the QuviQ guys talk about finding software bugs in automotive control systems.
- fineman 11y agoThey sent known commands to a known vehicle, they weren't live-fuzzing an unknown system. The experiment seems less dangerous than not following decent tire-rotation policy, etc. It's not that there's finite extra risk, it's what it is in relation to the baseline risk. Without that these comments are just useless scaremongering.
- MBCook 11y agoThe problem isn't what they did to the vehicle. The problem is there were other drivers around who may not have been expecting the situation. Further, since they weren't in the vehicle, if something happened ahead of it and the Wired journalist NEEDED to make a sudden maneuver to avoid an accident he might not have been able to. Asking them over the radio to turn X back on could have taken too long causing a serious accident when without their intervention one could have been easily avoided. It's not scaremongering. There is a reason you don't interfere with a driver on a public road at high speed. It was extremely irresponsible. There were plenty of ways they could have done the test in controlled circumstances (ask the cops for help, race track, auto test facility, large empty parking lot, etc.). They took unnecessary risks with possibly fatal consequences. It was irresponsible.
- fineman 11y agoBut the unnecessary risk is so close to 0 that it's obviously just manufactured outrage. If you read about this and came here to comment and that's all you can talk about you might as well be trolling. It's harmful. You're going to make some politician think that's where they should spend their time instead of figuring out why the car company sat on this for so long. Our whole society will lose.
- dang 11y agoPlease follow the HN guidelines when commenting on this site. This comment would be fine without the first paragraph. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html