3 ms·
And what is even more worrying is that the examples of abuse of surveillance laws have been frequent. President Mitterrand was spying on anyone who could expos
by cm2187 11y ago
And what is even more worrying is that the examples of abuse of surveillance laws have been frequent.
President Mitterrand was spying on anyone who could expose his lies (bigamy, fake medical certificates). President Hollande was spying on the discussion between former President Sarkozy and his attorney.
Even in the US, president Obama was using his own surveillance powers to expose the sources of political journalists.
It doesn't take a lot of imagination to consider how badly these laws can be abused.
- tptacek 11y agoIs it just as valid to say that Obama's administration was using its surveillance powers to investigate journalism sources that had straightforwardly broken the law by leaking classified information? James Risen is the most famous of these cases, and his indicted source leaked counterproliferation secrets. I agree that surveillance authority should be tightly restricted, far more than it is today. I'm just on false-equivalence watch. The investigation of Jeffrey Alexander Sterling does not sound equivalent to a sitting head of state snooping directly on his political rival and their lawyer.
- jkkbjinnknr 11y agoNo its not as valid, and your contribution is derailing the travesty that is state sanctioned mass surveillance, no amount of evidence of wrong doing will change your mind because you support what is happening, you're very likely being paid to accept what is happening You're concern troll who argues for the status quo, a bootlicking fascist.
- cm2187 11y agoI don't think that in any of the cases I mentioned the president himself was literally listening to some tapes. And the protection of the sources that journalists enjoy is precisely because people leaking information to journalists are breaking laws and internal policies and would fear reprisals otherwise. This is an important counter-power.
- tptacek 11y agoOur law has for the most part never recognized any kind of privilege for journalists and their sources. Protection of sources is more like a code of conduct among journalists, not a part of the broader social contract. To me, this makes sense. Literally anyone can be a journalist. Nobody elects them, and nothing but the market has any voice in what they do. I think it's better that way, too: you can see how fraught government involvement with even the most reputable state-sponsored media outlets can be.
- loup-vaillant 11y agoI agree with your main point, but: > nothing but the market has any voice in what [journalists] do. That "market" is pretty specific, and has a strong voice, though. Most media are owned by a few big corporations, and basically say what those corporations will allow them to say. Those who don't quickly find it much harder to sell ad space, their main source of income. Corporation-sponsored media are structurally just as bad as state-sponsored ones. For practical purposes, they might even be a bit worse. One way or another, independent journalism needs independent income.
- punee 11y agoIndependent from what? I hear that rhetoric a lot in France from people who read Mediapart, an "independently funded" newspaper and website. Their slogan is something along the lines of "Only our readers can buy us." I always found it quite ironic that their readership seems to feel like that guarantees impartiality. On the subject of media bias, I suggest reading Matthew Gentzkow's work or even just a survey like this one: http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/shleifer/files/shleifer_corrected_proofs_1.pdf http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/shleifer/files/shleifer_cor... TL;DR: Nope, ownership isn't the main factor in media bias. "As important, Gentzkow and Shapiro [6] show that, after controlling for a newspaper’s audience, the identity of its owner does not affect its slant.1 Two newspapers with the same owner look no more similar in their slant than newspapers with different owners. Ownership regulation in the US and elsewhere is based on the premise a news outlet’s owner determines how it spins the news. Gentzkow and Shapiro produced the first large-scale test of this hypothesis, which showed that, contrary to the conventional wisdom and regulatory stance, demand is much more influential in shaping content than supply as proxied by ownership."
- api 11y agoOne thing a lot of people don't think about is the potential for abuse for financial reasons. Imagine insider trading with access to CEOs e-mail, industrial espionage, etc.