2 ms·
All of the above is purely syntactic, meaning it has to do with rules that govern how symbols are written on the paper, and there's no need for any interpretati
by joe_the_user 17y ago
All of the above is purely syntactic, meaning it has to do with rules that govern how symbols are written on the paper, and there's no need for any interpretation of what the symbols mean.
At least this much was shown in original post; All proofs Goedel's theorem rely on the ability of a very particular language to be self-describing. Thus you cannot have "any system" but rather must a particular system, one "at least a powerful as arithmetic", one which is self-describing.
And this is where Anatoly's false distinction between "syntactic" and "semanitc" proofs breaks down. The proof of Goedel's theorem relies on these mechanics (one's ability to create Goedel numbering or the equivalent), these semantics of arithmetic. There is no Goedel's theoreom for Tarrot Cards because Tarrot Card don't have a set of rules which allow them to be self-describing.