17 ms·
It's worth remembering why the GPL was invented. Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. He couldn
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
It's worth remembering why the GPL was invented.
Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. He couldn't. He created the GPL so that, in future, people wouldn't have this problem.
Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom.
- angersock 11y agoOur users are shittier than his users. I'm not sure their freedom is really worth caring about, after we've spent so long trying to help them. Our freedom, sure! The freedom of fellow hackers, sure! The freedom of people who give my email address to linkedin? Who tag me in photos on Facebook? Who use Google Voice and Amazon Echo around me? Who tweet photos of me without asking and thus put my likeness along with EXIF data of my position? Might as well monetize them.
- liviu- 11y agoIf this is of any consolation to you, I'm pretty sure Twitter strips EXIF data on upload.
- angersock 11y agoWhy would they do a silly thing like that? That data has got to be worth a lot--imagine, for example, doing accurate brand spread analysis by searching for brand logos in photos and looking at where they're being displayed via that data. It'd be stupid not to hang onto that data.
- mwcampbell 11y agoThe users you disparage are mostly good people who just aren't obsessed with technology, or its implications on privacy, as we are. They just don't know any better than to do what they do on LinkedIn and Facebook. I daresay you need to get out more; then you'll see these users as real people, and not one-dimensional subhuman things to be monetized.
- angersock 11y agoAt this point, they're willfully ignorant and incurious. The only thing they're good for (in a software relationship) is being mined for revenue. Do they pay enough for their no/low cost apps and software to be treated otherwise? No. Do they vote for smarter politicians to have a better regulatory climate for our business and their privacy? No. Do they do anything other than lap up the bullshit gawker and buzzfeed ads, the simple pandering of Apple ads extolling faux-quality, the lazy hero worhsip of Musk? No. We've got numbers--hell, millions and billions of dollars of business built around the numbers--proving the users are saps whose only interest is getting sold to.
- mwcampbell 11y agoI don't think they're willfully ignorant. They just have lives outside of the narrow set of interests that are so important to us. And if they don't vote for smarter politicians, it's probably because they've been duped or distracted. If you're talking generally about non-tech-savvy people who like Facebook and other popular apps and websites, then that would include most of my family and some of my friends. It's easy to paint a whole category of people with a broad brush and hold them all in contempt when you don't know any of them personally.
- marrs 11y agoI don't think they're wilfully ignorant either, but they are woefully ignorant, and actually software is tightly woven into their lives so they need to be educated. It's more serious than you might realise. People have found themselves charged with serious felons either because they or their prosecutors didn't understand what they were doing. And then there's the issue of state surveillance being used as a weapon against activists and campaigners who might embarrass those in positions of power.
- anon3_ 11y ago> user freedom. He was an academic. Did he anticipate user demand, market forces or that a corporation (Google, Microsoft, Hashcorp) could drive a permissive licensed open source project in the open? It turns out the Firefox and Chromium, both liberally licensed projects, usurped Internet Explorer's monopoly on browsers. Both ultimately are backed financially by corporations with huge troths of patents and proprietary code.
- icebraining 11y agoChromium certainly didn't usurp anything. Chrome, the proprietary browser, did. As for Firefox, the Mozilla Public License is actually a (weak) copyleft license, since if you modify any file, you must distribute your changes - it's closer to the LGPL than to MIT/BSD. And the other licenses under which Firefox is distributed (it's tri-licensed) are GPL and LGPL.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoYes, the MPL is like a non-viral copyleft. It lets you keep user freedom mostly intact without being unable to link to code under certain licenses.
- anon3_ 11y agoExactly, this supports my view. Chromium is permissively licensed, and Chrome integrates proprietary components. Strengthening the product with features and giving it marketing. I see the point on MPL. As for bundling more restrictive licenses - as a developer - you have to judge by the most permissive to see how free it really is.
- comex 11y agoYou're nitpicking. Chrome has always been very close to Chromium. Even if some crap like the recent voice activation thing, DRM, and in the past the PDF reader (but that was open sourced) has remained proprietary, the vast majority of the code is permissively licensed and open to external contributions.
- dalke 11y ago
- epistasis 11y agoAnd that's a great thing to care about, and a great reason to create a license. The secondary question is: which license is best at perpetuating user freedom? This is a separate question than that of whether users should have freedom to mess with code. IMHO, the GPL is not the best license for perpetuating the most user freedom. Many people disagree with me on this, but their disagreement usually comes down to "the GPL is best for user freedom because it was created for user freedom and RMS is talking about user freedom." I'm not yet convinced that MIT-like, BSD-like, and Apache-like are any worse at perpetuating user freedom, and may in fact be far better at perpetuating user freedom due to their greater acceptance.
- liviu- 11y ago>Many people disagree with me on this, but their disagreement usually comes down to "the GPL is best for user freedom because it was created for user freedom and RMS is talking about user freedom." I don't think there's a need to create weak straw arguments, when an obvious argument is that GPL forces companies creating new products based on GPL-licenced software to open-source these products, thus aggressively perpetuating "user freedom". This may or may not be efficient in the long term, but I don't think the answer is very clear cut with the current knowledge base.
- epistasis 11y agoI didn't mean to create a straw man, and I kind of intended exactly what you say there (if I'm understanding you): being "aggressive" means that it does the most for user freedom. I like your terminology better though and will use it in the future.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y ago> I don't think there's a need to create weak straw arguments, when an obvious argument is that GPL forces companies creating new products based on GPL-licenced software to open-source these products. The obvious argument is that several people disagree with you on this (see the comment about linux being GPL or using GPL software at a bank.), so the GPL is not serving its purpose because people don't understand its purpose.
- wedowhatwedo 11y agoBut on the other hand, VLC was packaged for the iphone at one point to let users of that platform use it. Source was made available to everyone. It was decided that GPL version 3 wouldn't allow GPL software on the iphone so users were not free to use GPL software on their platform. It is available now for iphone so I'm not sure what changed. I thought it was very odd that GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThat is a very specific case. But since you bring up the iphone. You know that the iphone is fundamentally based open permissive licensed software? I can't think of a more user freedom hostile platform than the iphone...
- davexunit 11y ago>I thought it was very odd that GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case. You have it backwards. Apple limits user freedom with their licensing restrictions on iOS. Copyleft isn't welcome on iOS, and we shouldn't blame free software advocates for that.
- pbreit 11y agoI don't think the advocates should fully exonerated either. The problem is clear so it's just a difference of opinion.
- dublinben 11y agoThe problem there is not the GPL, it is the restrictive Terms of Service that Apple has created for their App Store. In order to publish on their closed platform, you must use DRM, which is in violation of the GPL. Apple has it within their power to change their ToS to be compliant with the GPL, and allow more Free Software in the App Store. For obvious reasons, they do not.
- bruo 11y agoI think GPL is forbidden from the AppStore. That's Apple's rules to enforcing it. And yet, the whole iOS environment uses several permissive licensed software. This is a very good example how they damage user freedom, thank you.
- minot 11y agoThis is so important that it is worth repeating. > Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom. > Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom. As GPL has evolved, the focus on user freedom has gotten clearer. It is not that GPL is against freedom for developers or software vendors. However, the way I understand it the consequences in this area are more side effects than guiding principles. It is not like the focus suddenly changed at some point. It has alwasy been this way. Let us look at how FSF defines free software: > A program is free software if the program's users have the four essential freedoms: > The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose (freedom 0). > The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish (freedom 1). Access to the source code is a precondition for this. > The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor (freedom 2). > The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others (freedom 3). By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this. Without even reading the four points, we already see that what defines a software as free software is whether or not the "program's users" have certain freedoms. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html (I am not a lawyer. This is just my personal interpretation.)
- epistasis 11y agoThis also bears repeating: >Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. >Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. This is a "freedom 1" activity, which is a freedom that is only useful for developers. The user and the developer can not be fully separated when it comes to freedom here. Modification of software, and redistribution of that modification is fundamentally a developer activity. Non-developer users can hire developers to do what they want, but ultimately there's a developer involved in this, otherwise what's the point of source code?
- richardjs 11y agoAny user can become a developer if he or she chooses. The user may decide it requires too much work to learn to code in order to implement a given change, but the option is there nonetheless.
- istvan__ 11y ago"Stallman created the GPL because he cared about user freedom." vs. "The GPL attempts to force people and businesses to release their source code. There is nothing wrong with that, except I don't think it qualifies as "free software". I want anybody to be able to do anything they want with my programs and/or its source code."[1] And I agree pretty much with the latter. 1. http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/5935 http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/5935
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThis entails giving your users freedom, yet they can take it away from theirs.
- istvan__ 11y agofree·dom ˈfrēdəm/Submit noun the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint. I don't think that restraining what the users can do or have to do while using your "free" software can hold up against the definition of freedom. I think what you are talking about is the moral superiority here, you are thinking that you are in a better position to define freedom for users that is different from the definition in the dictionary. This is pretty common patter in the society nowadays. Anyways, I am sticking to the original definition. :)
- pessimizer 11y agoAs your interpretation of freedom requires the freedom to enslave others, it's not something I would support as a social good.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoDoes true freedom include being bound to a duty to protect that freedom? With GPL, it works within the existing legal system to ensure that you have full freedom with GPL software as long as you continue to give such freedom to those who use your own versions of GPL. It reminds me of the issue with a democracy. Does a true democracy allow the voters to replace the democracy with another form of government (say a theocracy) or does a true democracy uphold that the one choice they cannot make is to remove democracy (individually they can stop voting, but they cannot take the vote away from anyone else). Or take the question of a free market. Given a free market, no man is bound as a slave by default. But does a fully free market allow for a man to sell himself into slavery (and to what degree, as taking on debt might be considered a really light form of indentured servitude, college debt which cannot be discharged could be considered a stronger form, and child support where one can be sentenced to jail could be considered full indentured servitude)? All of these seem to share a core underlying question, perhaps even an underlying paradox. I'm still not sure what it is, though it does remind me a bit of Russel's paradox in an absolutely rigorless way.
- Mithaldu 11y agoSheer curiosity: Do we have any printer with libre drivers now?
- yellowapple 11y agoHP's and Brother's printers have entirely-FOSS drivers, IIRC. At least the former's printers will work on my GNU/Linux systems without installing drivers (as opposed to other vendors - like Canon or Epson - that require separate driver installation in most cases).
- TD-Linux 11y agoI've plugged in a few friends' Epson printers and it just worked. I don't think I have yet to run across a printer that didn't work in the last 5 years or so (maybe it's just because my printer usage is declining)
- vetrom 11y agoMFPs can be a bit hard to deal with, but my Epson 7890 runs entirely from CUPS/GhostScript. Now, the printer itself, runs what's definitely a proprietary OS. Most of the printing problems in that line go into the printer itself. Blobs all the way down!
- yellowapple 11y agoInteresting; maybe Epson's turning around a bit. Last I checked, I still need a proprietary driver for the Epson WorkForce printer my grandparents use for color printing (alongside the HP Laserjet 1320n I gave them for greyscale). Then again, some vendors will be hit-and-miss when it comes to out-of-the-box driver support (my Konica-Minolta color laser is one such example), and I guess Epsons are in that category.
- jewbacca 11y agoFree as in Freedom: Richard Stallman's Crusade for Free Software Chapter 1 For Want of a Printer http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch01.html http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch01.html
- amelius 11y agoBut it is also worth noting that any software released under a restrictive license (e.g. GPL) will eventually be replaced by software with a more liberal license (e.g. MIT).
- phkahler 11y ago>> But it is also worth considering that any software released under a restrictive license (e.g. GPL) will eventually be replaced by software with a more liberal license (e.g. MIT). Which can then be relicensed under GPL ;-) Also consider the OpenOffice fork over to LibreOffice, where the GPL version won out after they relicensed it. Most FreeSoftware is trying to replace commercial code, so the reverse of what you say is also true. Also worth noting is that if you like commercial software, why not just use commercial software instead of rolling your own under a permissive license? It seems those developers are not as pro-commercial as they sometimes indicate.
- amelius 11y ago> Which can then be relicensed under GPL ;-) Doesn't matter, it is a different project. All your blood, toil, tears and sweat have been put into that original GPL project that is now replaced by something forked off of an MIT licensed project.
- davidgerard 11y agoe.g., Linux.
- kazinator 11y agoThe problem that Stallman faced could be solved with a law that prohibits software from being distributed in compiled form only. All executable images delivered to users should be accompanied by buildable source code corresponding to the image, if at all the image can be upgraded. Moreover, it should be lawful for licensed users of a program to share source code modifications with each other. This is not a copyright issue at all; the rule would apply equally to freeware as well as to programs which are not freely redistributable. The whole problem is that software can be machine translated from an easily understandable and modifiable from to a cryptic form that is vastly more difficult to understand and modify. This source-to-image translation paradigm gives rise to abuses and problems which were not imagined by the people who invented copyright. For instance, if you and I both buy copies of the same novel written in the English language, all of its sentences are plainly understandable. You and I can discuss, say, alternative endings for the novel, and even write them up in our mutual correspondence. We could do the analogous thing with software: all that stops us is that we received it in a gobbledygook compiled form. (Plus some idiotic EULA clauses about "reverse engineering").
- nickpsecurity 11y agoGood point. I made a similar one referencing the fact that Burroughs mainframes used to come with source to let customers do exactly that. So, it's a proven model. Plus, there's all the dual-licensed code out there proving you can make it charging reasonable rates for commercial use, let free use be free, and give source to both.
- kazinator 11y agoIndeed. Higher level languages (and that includes symbolic assembly languages) were invented by some smart and kind people in order to make computers easier to program, allowing more kinds of people to be programmers. The idea that you can hold users hostage with compiled code came later; it is an accidental by-product of the model of compiling richly annotated, symbolic, high level code into a bit pattern for the machine. There is a slight analogy in music. A symbolic musical score is "compiled" into a recording. If someone wants to change the music, they have to either obtain the score or "reverse engineer" it by ear. However, recordings do not have algorithmic behaviors; a "bug" in a recording has only an esthetic consequence. Nobody is the victim of a security bug or malware due to a flaw in a music recording. Performances are also art in their own right. They exhibit nuance and style.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoDoesn't need a GPL: just an irrevocable license to paying customers to be able to obtain and modify the source for their own uses. GPL is clearly superior in freedom but open-source, flexible, and proprietary model solves that with ROI for company. There's been companies, going back to Burrough's MCP OS in 60's, that did that for paying customers. We could push for more companies to do this, especially putting it in writing, to eliminate a lot of our problems. Device drivers and firmware will still be tricky due to trade secrets involved. I'd say encourage such companies to keep a team around for paid audits and extensions of their product. That's happened with embedded and fabless semiconductor companies for quite a while. We've recently seen AMD and Intel start doing something similar for purposes of customization. Many potential solutions that don't require convincing a company to go all free and annihilate their existence outside support contracts' race-to-the-bottom profits.
- legulere 11y agoTypical users aren't programmers. For them there isn't a difference. GPL or BSD usually mean for the user to get Software for free. Where free licences really matter is for developers. The question is wether they have to give back their work that is based on other software. A really important point in this discussion is the question if something is still the same thing when you change it. In my opinion this isn't true for software. The orignal will still be preserved and still be free.
- microtherion 11y agoStallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. So how did that work out? As far as I know, there are pretty much no printer manufacturers who open source their drivers.
- marrs 11y agoEvery printer I've ever owned has worked out of the box with Linux, so pretty well it would seem.