4 ms·
Please please stop disabling zoom. I beg of you, I have to abandon sooo many sites because they are unreadable because I can't zoom. >I am a formally trained d
by epistasis 11y ago
Please please stop disabling zoom. I beg of you, I have to abandon sooo many sites because they are unreadable because I can't zoom.
>I am a formally trained designer and I design UI properly for the devices and hardware my projects are intended to be accessed with.
If designers were actually licensed, I think that disabling zoom should be an offense that results in a 2-year revocation of design license. It's so user hostile that it's unacceptable. That you are trotting out your "formal training" in response to user pleas shows that you really don't have many legs to stand on.
- wlesieutre 11y agoResponsive design (noun): a design methodology to ensure that a website is equally terrible on all devices
- err4nt 11y agoThese aren't my user pleas, and these users haven't even seen my sites. We do listen to our users, and there absolutely IS such thing as licensing in this industry: http://www.rgd.ca/ http://www.rgd.ca/
- DanBC 11y ago> http://www.rgd.ca/ http://www.rgd.ca/ Does it change your mind at all that you linked to a zoomable site? EDIT: and an organisation that produced accessibility guides that tell you not to disable zoom? http://rgd-accessibledesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/RGD_AccessAbility_Handbook1.pdf http://rgd-accessibledesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/R... > any low-vision users have software-based screen magnifiers. Sometimes they augment the magnifier with text-to-speech software when reading longer passages of text. [...] > to be truly accessible, a website must allow individual preferences in colour, size and typeface to override the author’s suggested design. The website you provide to support your position tells you not to do what you're doing. (Ironically, the accessibility guidelines are in an unaccessible PDF).
- err4nt 11y ago>Does it change your mind at all that you linked to a zoomable site? No, I said I decide based on the needs of the project and which devices will be supported which META tag makes the most sense. Not 100% of my projects disable zooming, and I don't believe 100% of sites should disable zooming. Zooming is a useful feature added to mobile browser that does serve a purpose: to allow the user to navigate a site that was designed without their device/hardware in mind. It's good at what it does, but it's not better than a properly designed site (whatever that means). My job is to figure out for each project what a properly designed site means, and for the big web-app type projects that make the most money, having zooming disabled allows me to deliver a better experience I couldn't with zooming enabled. But I didn't link to the RGD.ca site to help prove my case, my learning comes from actually doing web development, not what an organization says is best practice. Mine comes from hundreds of hours of specializing in making sites that dont support mobile convert more users. People hire me because I help them reach more mobile customers, and I make a fraction of the money I make for my clients by supporting mobile better. I posted the link to the Registered Graphic Designers site because the commenter above me said: > If designers were actually licensed, I think that disabling zoom should be an offense that results in a 2-year revocation of design license. Here where I live if you're RGD you get letters after your name like a dentist or reverend. So a little education before speaking can help keep the conversation on a contructive path. I listen to my users and none have complained about zooming where zooming has been disabled. There are voices here offering opinions and I do actually care about their reasons. Please, tell me the reasons why zooming on a legible, usable design is necessary. Explain your side of things, downvotes and ad hominems aren't constructive, and there is value in this conversation being had. Why is this conversation being treated like spam? Here's your chance to tell the guy who makes mobile sites the way they are how you wish they were different and all you want to do is stop others from seeing that I'm listening here on HN? I'd appreciate any constructive input on the pain points of using mobile sites. Today's work includes taking a credit card form designes in 2009 and making it work on mobile. Seriously, if there's valuable insight you have that I can use to make this easier for you I'm all ears.
- DanBC 11y agoI have no idea why you would add css that diasbles zoom. Do everything you currently do, but don't add "user-scalable=0" to the css. Doing so provides no benefit to anyone, but does make your pages harder to use for a large section of users. You still haven't listed the benefits of disabling zoom.
- marcosdumay 11y agoWell, you shouldn't expect people that can not use your site to use your site...