4 ms·
I finally, after many years, found Taxi service in NYC to be very, very good. Then Uber popped up and the city is absolutely filled with car services. There's
by busterarm 11y ago
I finally, after many years, found Taxi service in NYC to be very, very good.
Then Uber popped up and the city is absolutely filled with car services. There's a million black cars on the road and yellow cab companies from New Jersey here. As dangerous as taxi drivers were, I've found these (as a pedestrian) to be much worse.
Then my experiences using Uber have been pretty bad -- from new drivers not knowing how the app works to people not knowing their way around Manhattan/Brooklyn and either _not following_ their GPS or blindly following their GPS. On one ride the driver tried to drive in a circle 3 times and then chose to take the battery tunnel (and pass along the toll) when we were next to the Williamsburg Bridge. I had one experience last week where I hailed an Uber and a drunk woman waiting for a cab jumped in and tried to get him to take her home. I explained to the driver that I was his fare and then he acted totally disinterested in the fact that she was in the car and had me deal with telling her to get out.
And now when I get in a normal taxi, my experience is much worse.
Uber is really great for two things: cost effective rides from NYC into New Jersey and the ability to summon a ride to your location. Probably the outer boroughs and Long Island are good too but I don't have experience with that. Other services are summonable and there's no reason that normal taxis couldn't be as well.
Honestly, as a midtown resident, I hate Uber in New York City. They drive dangerously on the road here and now it seems like everyone else is too (especially the tour bus companies and private sanitation services). It's lawless here in part because of them.
- busterarm 11y agoSeeing as my post is already unpopular, I'll get right to the point. Over 2000 for-hire car services are being added to the streets every month in NYC. This is causing an unbelievable amount of congestion in an already crowded city. Within two years, the number of these will be double the number of yellow cabs we already have on the road. The average speed of traffic this year was the slowest recorded - 8.5 miles per hour - and will slow further as we add more of these cars.
- UK-AL 11y agoSurely if taxis are not available, people drive? Increasing congestion.
- busterarm 11y agoAlmost nobody who lives in Manhattan drives. There's nowhere to park (under $400/mo).
- paulmd 11y agoActually taxis and personal automobiles do not create an equivalent amount of congestion. Personal automobiles tend to go point to point during several peak periods, after which they park and are off the roads. Commercial vehicles like taxis, on the other hand, are in service all day. Taxicabs, in particular, produce a lot of congestion since they're always stopping to pick up/drop off fares. The money shot on this is that a single taxi produces congestion equivalent to about 40 personal vehicles, and a 15% increase in taxicabs reduces all traffic speeds by about 12% [1]. A certain level of taxis is a good thing, but they don't solve the need for an effective mass transit system. [1] http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/01/20/more-taxis-mean-more-traffic/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/01/20/more-taxis-...
- seunosewa 11y agoA single taxi replaces several cars, so its unremarkable that a taxi "causes congestion equivalent to" many cars. You said a 15% increase in taxi cabs reduces traffic speeds by 12% but you didnt compare it with a similar increase in private cars.
- paulmd 11y agoThe article did address that - the simulated "15% increase in traffic volume" results from adding either an additional 2,000 taxis OR the equivalent 80,000 private cars. You may think that it's more socially optimal to have the taxi instead of the equivalent 40 private vehicles, of course. This is just speaking strictly in terms of congestion.
- idiot900 11y agoI live in Manhattan and use both Uber and regular taxis regularly. Never had any similar problem personally with either. The streets are always crowded. Instead of having no hope of catching a cab in a timely manner at peak times and places, now I have a shot at an Uber.
- colinbartlett 11y agoSince we're all pitching in anecdotes, I also live in Manhattan have very few problems with either. I can get a taxi almost any time I need one. The times I can't, it's late on Friday or Saturday night and I just use Uber or Lyft. I also use Uber to JFK simply because I get tired of hearing taxi drivers complain about going to JFK, demanding huge tips, or bitching about paying with cards. Taxi drivers usually give me no trouble, but to JFK, there is some issue at least 65% of the time. Never a complaint and always a smile with Uber or Lyft.
- amelius 11y ago> As dangerous as taxi drivers were, I've found these (as a pedestrian) to be much worse. Yes. When being a pedestrian, you just know that taxi drivers will not be polite, and you just let the taxi drivers pass before you cross the street, just to not end up in a life-threatening situation. However, with Uber, you can't tell whether it is a taxi cab, so the situation is a lot more dangerous.
- busterarm 11y agoAt least Ubers here have to have TLC plates. If you're looking at license plates, they're much more identifiable...but if you can read their plate it's too close to matter anyway.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAre you astroturfing for Bill deBlasio? 1.4 million new yorkers own a car, and that ignores the people who drive in from Jersey or Westchester. http://www.nycedc.com/blog-entry/new-yorkers-and-cars http://www.nycedc.com/blog-entry/new-yorkers-and-cars It's exceedingly unlikely that any ordinary person could possibly notice the small number of additional Uber drivers, unless of course they are being paid by the yellow cabs (like DeBlasio).
- busterarm 11y agoNo, I am not. The places where New Yorkers own cars are also not the places that are congested with non-personal vehicles (except densely populated parts of Queens).
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIf congestion were the real issue, people would be talking about imposing congestion pricing rather than limiting Uber. It's a far more direct solution.
- busterarm 11y agoThey have been. There was a talk from the city council about making EZPass and a toll a requirement to drive below 60th street in Manhattan but that's political suicide so it didn't go anywhere.