8 ms·
The Gluglug – GNU/Linux laptop with libreboot firmware
- weinzierl 11y agoIn contrast to the Purism machines the Gluglug has free firmware. As far as I know this is the only commercially available solution with free firmware. It's also the laptop Richard Stallman uses.
- foodstances 11y agoIn contrast to the Purism machines the Gluglug uses second-hand, 7-year old hardware.
- davexunit 11y agoBecause newer hardware is even more difficult to liberate.
- ekianjo 11y agoSo what? Specs are not everything that counts.
- madez 11y agoI think it is a fair criticism. It correctly portraits the two options we have to spend our money on a new device: a) Very modern device and supporting the status quo or b) A slightly outdated device and supporting the market for devices that are more free
- userbinator 11y agoI'll add "supporting reuse and reduction of e-waste" to the second option.
- keithpeter 11y agoI'm typing this on an (unliberated) X60 which I use as a sort of netbook and which steadfastly refuses to go wrong! I'll keep it out of landfill as long as possible I think.
- Sanddancer 11y agoI'd argue that this is far from slightly outdated. Starting with RAM, four gigabytes of RAM may work for a barebones programmer machine, but once you want to start doing any sort of media work, like editing photos, video, etc, you start running into that wall real quickly. Even software development work is going to cause you to run into limitations. As the processor doesn't have an IOMMU, any vms you want to run will be limited to slower, virtualized, graphics, and that expresscard slot on the side becomes a security concern (hello, evil maid). Additionally, it only supports outputting to vga, limiting your options in monitors, and making sharing content on a friend's tv a lot harder. So in short, its constraints in various areas really do shackle you in a lot of ways. Media creation, software creation, sharing, all suffer from the weaknesses of this machine.
- rosser 11y agoNot everyone needs to do all of those things. In fact, I'd argue that very few people need to do all of them. So, yeah, it's a fraction of the machine the (not maxed out) 13" rMBP I'm typing at right now is. So? If "freedom" (as the term is used by the FSF and folks of similar ideologies) is your priority, you make some compromises. If not, some would argue, that's a compromise you're making, right there. The x200 also unofficially supports 8GB of system RAM. Since the machine is under no warranty coverage whatsoever, running an unsupported configuration will, at worst, cost you the price of a couple of 4GB SO-DIMMs or return shipping on an RMA. Please don't judge a thing that doesn't satisfy your priorities as being somehow objectively "bad" or "wrong". It just doesn't meet your needs. Go find a machine that does, then, and let the people whose needs and priorities are met by a Gluglug x200 satisfy theirs with this.
- Sanddancer 11y agoSo I'm not allowed to discuss what these people are giving up in the name of "freedom"? That the fact that this is a refurbished machine from seven years ago shouldn't be brought up? That functionality was removed in order to, through some bizarre twist of logic, make the machine "more free"? Given that this is a machine that is built in the name of ideology, I would argue that questioning aspects of that ideology, and what is demanded to acheive their idea of purity, is more than fair game.
- tracker1 11y agoI would think that power vs battery life would be pretty high on the list of priorities for technically inclined users. I current-gen core i3 (like the 5010U) packs quite a bit of performance vs. the power it requires. For me, first and foremost are the parts that I interact with... namely the screen, keyboard and mouse. TBH, I have yet to try a laptop keyboard I like... I use a model-m style keyboard from Unicomp (103-key US), and all laptops and most other keyboards feel like sponges. I've yet to use a touchpad that's nearly as good as a macbook pro's, and their keyboard is better than most. The rMBP screen is pretty nice too. That said, there's certainly a price tag attached. As to the software, I could care less mostly. I survive in windows, linux and osx on a daily basis, if I have a command prompt (bash) and most of the same tooling available (thankful for git extensions for windows bringing all the gfw/git/bash/ssh tools with it), I'm pretty happy. I have also started using an natural scrolling everywhere. All of that said, it's nice to see open options that start under $1k in price, even if slightly older hardware. I'm not sure how good/easy Trisquel is to use, I know it's based with dpkg, but without apt/aptitude on top of it, may be difficult for most people to use in practice (I couldn't find reference to this, just a cursory look).
- madez 11y agoI know [Trisquel]'s based with dpkg, but without apt/aptitude on top of it Trisquel is virtually a deblobbed and cleaned Ubuntu, so it does use apt/aptitude.
- tracker1 11y agoThanks... I looked through bits of their FAQ, and a few other places. The wikipedia article referenced only dpkg, not apt/aptitude. Though, pragmatically I load some not entirely free software on my machines (chrome proper, flash, and a few other things namely). I still think it's cool to have open options... I've tended towards buying routers/phones that I can replace the software, even if I don't start off that route because I like having supported, updateable options past the production date. I've been less concerned on the desktop/laptop front, but am actually getting more so.. given the lock-down methods that have been in the pipeline, I don't want to be stuck with the MFG OS... I've been looking into getting a couple C2D macbooks, so I can load linux on them to play around with... I'm relatively happy with my current rMBP, but the changes apple has made to the OS irk me more with each release.
- technomancy 11y agoI've been using my X200 since I got it. Not only has it survived multiple falls from a 1.8m standing desk, it's still perfectly serviceable for everything I've needed it for. Most Thinkpads released since then are markedly worse, plagued with low-resolution or glossy screens. They've also removed the LED indicator that tells you whether the AC adapter is plugged in and when the battery level is critical. tl;dr: sure there are newer machines with better specs, but nothing better in ways that actually matter to me.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI am thinking of buying a Gluglug, mostly as a political statement. Is it easy to replace the battery, memory, disk, etc. on the X200? BTW, I appreciate the work you did in the Clojure community!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- acid__ 11y agoI don't know about the X200 specifically but older ThinkPads tend to be really good with that. I have an X220 and it is easily the most serviceable laptop I have ever owned. It was super easy to upgrade the memory and add an extra disk. The battery is replaceable without opening the machine up and so it's easy to swap batteries if you use your machine for very extended periods of time.
- technomancy 11y agoYes, that's another reason I've avoided upgrading--I really appreciate the ability to swap the battery out in the middle of a long flight without a screwdriver. Basically everything in the X200 is user-serviceable; you can even replace the keyboard without taking it in, provided you can find the parts you need. The only thing I'd be worried about is being able to find new batteries for it; worth looking into before you pull the trigger.
- nextos 11y agoApparently the first Core2Duo MacBooks (MacBook 2,1) can also run free firmware: http://www.libreboot.org/docs/hcl/index.html http://www.libreboot.org/docs/hcl/index.html
- userbinator 11y agoIt's the Intel "Calistoga" platform, which is very similar to the X60 in that it uses the same chipset (945) and Apple probably followed the Intel reference design closely since it was their entry into the x86 world. IBM/Lenovo tends to follow the reference designs more than the other companies, which helps with Coreboot porting.
- verusfossa 11y agoI've been using a C720 Chromebook with custom SeaBios firmware and running Linux. While not a beast, a Haswell i3 with 4GB isn't bad at the ~$300 price point. Throw in a 128GB ssd and it's good to go. It's been my daily driver as I'm unfortunately content with 'open enough' given the market. http://www.amazon.com/Acer-C720-3404-11-6-Inch-Chromebook-Granite/dp/B00KOUIZBC http://www.amazon.com/Acer-C720-3404-11-6-Inch-Chromebook-Gr... https://johnlewis.ie/custom-chromebook-firmware/faq/ https://johnlewis.ie/custom-chromebook-firmware/faq/
- voltagex_ 11y agoDo you have any idea whether there's a model with more RAM? I'm sick of my X1 Carbon but 4GB of RAM hasn't been enough. Edit: The Chromebook Pixel might do but it's not particularly Free.
- verusfossa 11y agoLooks like 4GB is it unless you want to shell out for a Pixel. http://prodct.info/chromebooks/#f& http://prodct.info/chromebooks/#f& Edit: Chart seems somewhat up to date at least, best I could find.
- fierarul 11y agoThe original Acer C7 (now back-called C710 I guess) supports up to 16GB: http://normcf.net/~john/chromebook/Acer/acerC7ChromebookUpgrade.html http://normcf.net/~john/chromebook/Acer/acerC7ChromebookUpgr... You could even put Coreboot on it. People praise the C720 a lot but it has no upgradeable RAM which makes it a regression in my book.
- riek42 11y agoMy wifes old netbook is about to die. Unfortunately I only upgraded it with a 2.5" SSD less than a year ago. I was thinking about buying a chromebook for her but was hesitant, because I'd really like to reuse that SSD. Does the C720 come with standard 2.5" SATA SSD or is it mSATA/m.2?
- 11y ago
- Buge 11y agoIt appears to be down.
- jszymborski 11y agoSeems like it's back up, but here's an archived version in case it goes down again https://archive.is/jNX4A https://archive.is/jNX4A
- ubercow13 11y ago>no proprietary software of any kind Does this include the CPU microcode?
- belorn 11y agoDoes the laptop CPU have a writable control store?
- ubercow13 11y agoI assume so, you can update Intel microcode https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Microcode https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Microcode
- Sanddancer 11y agoOn a stock kernel you can update it. On the kernel this machine ships with, they removed that, along with most other facilities to upload binary firmware, for things like wifi cards, video cards, etc.
- dfox 11y agoThe CPU certainly does have at least patchable control store. Even ignoring that, there are certainly at least two significant binary blobs still remaining: EC firmware and microcode for e1000. First probably has no major security implications, second is slightly weird as there were security-significant erratas in e1000 that were fixed by microcode update, but on the other hand it's probably more of "random undocumented configuration options" than "executable code" (for some reason Intel tends to call any random binary blob "microcode").
- Sanddancer 11y agoMost of these types of systems will patch out any sort of microcode updating interfaces to keep you from performing such actions. Can't have the user decide to flash the firmware, now can we?
- LukeShu 11y agoGood question! I believe that CPU microcode is still unavailable (though I could, and would love to be, wrong. I'll check with Francis). The FSF's RYF certification (which Gluglug machines have) makes an exception for "software delivered inside auxiliary and low-level processors and FPGAs, within which software installation is not intended after the user obtains the product. This can include, for instance, microcode inside a processor,"[0] Additionally, I known that the firmware on the SSD (if you chose that option) is proprietary--it is covered under the exception as well (as an "auxiliary processor"). However, the criteria goes on to say that if a Free firmware for any exempted components becomes available, the product must "adopt it within a reasonable period of time." (or have their certification withdrawn). [0]: https://www.fsf.org/resources/hw/endorsement/criteria https://www.fsf.org/resources/hw/endorsement/criteria
- jszymborski 11y agoVery neat, but it's specs are a little lack-lustre: Core 2 Duo P8400 2.26GHz processor or higher Graphics: Intel GMA 4500MHD Screen: 12.1" 1280×800 TFT LCD Gigabit ethernet as standard Ports: 1x VGA, 3x USB 2.0, 5-in-1 card reader, 1x Headphone, 1x Microphone, 1x Gigabit Ethernet, 1x ExpressCard/54 Size: 11.6 x 9.2 x 0.8 inches Weight: 1.7 Kg Upgraded with an 802.11n wireless card (Atheros AR5B95, AR9285 chipset), ensuring full compatibility with free drivers in Trisquel GNU/Linux-libre.
- ThatGeoGuy 11y agoFor what it's worth, I couldn't find any information on the battery in these things. I understand these are second hand, but is the old battery replaced? For that matter, what is the quality of second-hand X200's anyways? I would wonder whether or not the keyboard is worn down, or if the screens are still in good condition. Has anyone bought one of these that can discuss this?
- joshuapants 11y ago> Very neat, but it's specs are a little lack-lustre It's kind of the nature of the beast. It's one of the only (or is it the only?) laptops they can do this with, so if you're committed to a FSF-approved machine you're stuck with old hardware.
- tinco 11y agoWhy is that? From the site I see that it's just a modified X200, wouldn't they for example be able to modify a more modern model? Does Intel have special measures to prevent that? Or is it simply reverse engineering that hasn't been achieved yet?
- rosser 11y agoAIUI, it's primarily a matter of the machines for which libreboot support exists. So, for example, the X60 and its tablet version are supported, but the X61(t) (of which I have two in a box somewhere) aren't. This is a terrible bummer for me, because that's still one of my favorite machines I've ever owned.
- GutenYe 11y agoReally, They should use a Chinese supplier to do the production.
- frenchies 11y agoThe percentage of laptops which are already made in China and Taiwan is nearly 100. As of a few years ago, Taiwan alone was well over 90.
- GutenYe 11y agoReally, They should use a Chinese supplier to do the production.
- alfiedotwtf 11y agoI want something like this, but for a phone. The Freerunner was the closest thing to an open phone, but the call quality made it unusable (speaker hissing and other noises).
- madez 11y agoMay I suggest cosidering Replicant[1]? https://www.replicant.us/ https://www.replicant.us/
- alfiedotwtf 11y agoI've looked at Replicant too, however I'm really not an Android fan. I long for a Debian phone... the Ubuntu phone does looks interesting too. But FWIW - stock Debian or die.
- federico3 11y agoFreedom and security on mobile devices is arguably more important than workstations, given the amount of information they manage. I'm amazed there aren't large organizations interested in funding a Debian-on-free-hardware phone.
- rosser 11y agoThe Neo900 project is the successor to the Freerunner/OpenMoko, and might be worth checking out. They're still in development, but it has a few pretty compelling features (including and particularly, firewalling the baseband from the rest of the system). https://neo900.org/ https://neo900.org/
- alfiedotwtf 11y agoYeah, It's definitely on my radar. I had an N900 and it was awesome. The only reason why I ditched it was that it didn't work on all the spectrums I needed. The Neo900 looks awesome, and has the upgraded radio. It really does tick all boxes, except the one that says "in stock" :)
- sneak 11y agoLooks like a case design from the 90s. Do people really think laptop industrial design peaked then?
- LukeShu 11y agoIt's a refurbished Lenovo ThinkPad X200 (2008, I believe). So yeah, it looks kinda dated. And yeah, ThinkPads tend to look blocky; I don't think that's news to anyone.
- davexunit 11y agoIt's a Thinkpad. I wish laptops (even newer Thinkpads) still had this rugged, function over style design.
- shmerl 11y agoI wish more common laptops would have replaceable firmware, like Lenovo and the like. Having all those blobs with who knows what is very annoying. Especially when that firmware starts behaving as if it owns your computer, and refuses to boot because "WiFi card is not authorized" or some other such idiocy.
- brobinson 11y agoYes! I bought a Lenovo laptop in 2008 and tried to replace the wifi card with an Atheros-based one (better driver support on Linux at the time), and it refused to boot afterwards. Never buying a Lenovo laptop again.
- shmerl 11y agoI got one recently, and it came with 802.11n Intel card. I bought 802.11ac Intel one (it has a pretty good support on Linux). And who knew that some FRU part code wasn't from the "authorized" whitelist and that nasty firmware would refuse to boot with it. I had to return the card, and figure out what the compatible FRU part number is. The card is really exactly the same, just some internal code is different. This is beyond dumb and annoying.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 11y agoYea, I don't like Intel Boot Guard for that reason, and I think this is more important than being "100% FOSS" or the like. I once suggested allowing it to be disabled using a jumper or the like.
- na85 11y agoPhysical write jumpers would solve 99% of firmware security issues and significantly reduce the attack surface of modern computers. APTs can't really manifest unless they come pre-installed. Then again, NSA and other state actors wouldn't be able to implant malware into those areas without physical access. I wonder why we don't have physical jumpers.
- pionar 11y agoThe HTTPS connection uses a self-signed cert?
- josteink 11y agoIf you want to advocate true freedom and true trust, why not? The CA model is certainly broken and can be hijacked/intercepted by NSA and friends. I think it makes sense.
- pionar 11y agoSo, I'm supposed to trust someone I've never heard of, and just take their word for it? The fact that the site allows one to enter credit card details over plain HTTP would be my first clue not to trust this cert.
- witty_username 11y agoAnybody could intercept the connection with an unsigned connection. At least they could have used HSTS so that only the first visit is vulnerable. If you have a signed cert the NSA has to work harder; there are more logs and it's more riskier for them.
- yitchelle 11y agoAm I being too cynical when I say that the laptop you and I use will never be a 100% totally free. There will always be a blob on some sort in there. The most obvious one is the processor. With my naive knowledge of processor implementation, it's functionality is implemented in code more primitive than microcode. Is the source for this available for inspection? There will be plenty of other devices in the laptop where its implementation domain is blurred. Having said that, the Gluglug is a shuffle in the right direction.
- leni536 11y agoI always thought that it would be nice to handle your essential private keys (PGP master key, large bitcoin wallet) on a fully free hardware. Of course free software still can be compromised but at least you could be certain to a degree that your hardware doesn't come compromised out of the box (sure, you have to trust your "fully free hardware supplier" here).
- avarsheny 11y agoNow I know why HURD will release in 2050
- fixermark 11y agoThis looks good, but it's a bit pricey for my tastes and that hardware is an unreliable brick of a machine. I'd love to see someone hit the market with a working Linux-ready netbook. I used to have an Acer One cobbled into that state, but the lack of direct support from the vendor meant that things like power management and sleep-on-lid-close never quite worked right. It's the little things you miss when you go off the vendor's book on operating system choice. On the other hand, the stock Vista on that machine was dog-slow. Being able to strip down the crap from the UI and run much faster was a Godsend for hacking around on projects while away from the desk.