3 ms·
Can you elaborate on the oil deals that existed, what the terms were, who made what investments and who discovered what oil, and on what legal basis Iran claime
by adventured 11y ago
Can you elaborate on the oil deals that existed, what the terms were, who made what investments and who discovered what oil, and on what legal basis Iran claimed the right to nationalize those deals?
- danbruc 11y agoInitially they only wanted to audit the books and renegotiate terms, only after they resisted that effort they considered nationalizing.
- adventured 11y agoSome of the questions I'm curious about are: - Did the Iranians pay market-rate compensation for the nationalization? - Whose technology and investments made it possible to find and extract the oil to begin with? - What were the terms of the deal, and in what way were those terms violated (or not) by the foreign oil companies? Is it an 'Iran says so' situation, or is there tangible proof of impropriety regarding the deals?
- the_af 11y agoI see those questions as somewhat irrelevant. Suppose for a minute what you're hinting at is the truth: Iran ripped off British oil companies (hah!) in a strange case of reverse-colonialism, and it was totally unfair, and this even affected British civilians. This still is in no way justification for toppling a democratically elected government and supporting a dictatorship. No matter what, commercial interests do not trump a country's rights. Even if Iran's oil nationalization had been completely unfair, Britain and the US would still be directly responsible for installing a dictatorship and indirectly responsible for Iran's "fall out with the West".
- hangonhn 11y agoI would highly recommend Daniel Yergin's "The Prize" if you want to know more about this and other nationalization attempts. IIRC, it was the British who discovered and worked to extract the oil before oil became such a force in industrialization. When this first happened, oil wasn't that valuable and I believe the usual term was a flat fee per barrel extracted. The agreement was reach before Iran had any form of democratic government. As oil became more valuable in the period before, during, and after WWII, most governments who signed these deals renegotiated these deals once they realized how valuable the oil is. I believe they wanted to be paid based on market price per barrel. "Legal basis" is a funny term to use when you're dealing with national governments. In truth, there is very little legal foundation for resolving these dispute until recently and even now it's pretty shaky. I mean, who's legal system do you use? It would seem since all this is happening in Iran, it should be Iranian laws. If that's the case, then the nationalization attempt was legal. What actually happens, however, is that national governments get involved and other forms of leverage is used. I once talked to a lawyer for a major oil company involved with a dispute with Venezuela. The State Department was involved to some extend but at the end of the day, their leverage was their ability to extract the oil. So "legal basis" is usually not something involved in these sorts of disputes because usually the country with the oil has the upper hand in that case.
- adventured 11y agoIsn't it true though, that in the case of Venezuela, international assets became an excellent leverage point? For example, Exxon getting court orders to try to have $12 billion in Venezuelan assets frozen in 2008. If I recall, Exxon in its case only received 10% of what it asked for in compensation though.