5 ms·
The patent system: End it, don't mend it
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- chrischen 17y agoIt seems intellectual rights for something like music makes more sense, since one can work just as hard on another song and achieve almost equal success. But in technology there is usually a limited amount of ways to do something most efficiently. Each longstanding patent makes alternative efficient methodologies harder to come by. It impedes the process of evolution since there's a definite best way.
- nroach 17y ago"Ideas kept under lock and key are much less useful than those that are freely available." That's precisely the point of the patent system. It is supposed to encourage disclosure so that after the protected period the knowledge is made fully available to society. The alternative is trade secret protection whereby inventors remain secretive about their work product, never disclosing to the public at large how the device works and not allowing follow-ons to build upon their knowledge. The two problems with the current system are 1) protection terms are too long and 2) the enablement requirements aren't enforced well enough. Let's say that the protection term is reduced to one year. And assume that the USPTO requires patents with sufficient detail to fully enable readers to replicate and practice the invention. Under that scenario, I think that the patent system would be seen as an asset to society. In exchange for a year's worth of protection the inventor has to tell society explicitly how to do exactly what he or she is doing. I don't think most people would have a problem with that system. If you go back to the Constitutional basis for the patent system, it was "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." As long as "limited time" is a reasonable period, I don't know that abolition is required.
- apowell 17y agoI'd add two more problems: 3) Too expensive. 4) Takes too long. Getting a patent attorney to prepare and file a patent is very expensive. It takes $10k just to get started. The patent system is so byzantine that you can't reasonably expect to do it yourself and be successful. The cost is a drop in the bucket to a large corporation, but it's a major barrier for individual inventors. Not only that, but it takes way, way to long to actually receive a patent. I applied for a patent about two and a half years ago, and I'm still waiting. As an individual without infinite resources, I'm hesitant to built a business around my concept unless I can be confident that it'll be protected. If I'm not granted the patent, then it would be trivial for an organization with deeper pockets replicate what I would have created. I know that patents typically don't make a business defensible, but in my case I decided to pursue a different business opportunity. If I'm granted my patent, then I suppose I'll figure it what to do with it then. On the other hand, what good is a patent on a technology conceived three years ago, except to make life difficult for others?
- nym 17y agoI read today a factoid that said innovation was down because patents were being filed less (2 percent iirc). Interesting that someone would think that the number of patents was a direct way one could measure innovation. My interpretation was that possibly less irresponsible patent grabbing was taking place because due to the recession there was less incentive to spend money patenting, and more incentive to keep businesses alive through real innovation. Of course, I could be completely wrong.
- vicaya 17y agoThe problem is that despite the patent system, "trade secrets" remain and increasingly so in SaaS. Patents are mainly used as a weapon to impede the progress of competitors. Abolish software patents, now!
- padmanabhan01 17y agoWhat is wrong with trade secrets anyway? It's not like someone who discovered something is obligated to reveal it to the world. If he chooses to do so out of his good will, fine. But if trade secrets remain despite patent system, that can only mean patent system is not fully enforceable yet.
- hristov 17y agoI have to strongly disagree. First of all, all his statements about how the patent system does not promote innovation are merely conclusory and do not show any evidence or reasoning behind them. (Other than a couple of cherry picked individual cases). This is an interesting question, but it is unfortunately really hard to show scientific proof either way. Economics is just too uncertain of a science to prove something as complex as this. One thing that is known is that most countries whose economies rely on IP creation usually end up with a relatively strong IP protection system. Now, as I have said here before, I agree that some patents may hinder innovation. Patenting things that are not new or obvious or issuing patents that are too broad can just create a lot of harmful rent seeking which only hurts innovation. But this is something that should be fixed by modifying the patent system not scrapping it. This is too big of a discussion to have here, but I should point that a big mistake people make when considering the cost of the patent system is to assume that if patents did not exist things would be just the way they are now, but without the patents. This is simply not true. I really doubt those Africans would have any AIDS drugs if the patent system did not exist, because nobody would commit the resources of developing and testing an AIDS drug without patent protection. Furthermore, if there is no patent system, the only way to protect your inventions would be by keeping them secret and companies that do innovate would go through very costly measures of making sure their inventions are secret. These measures probably cost much more to society than the patent system. Also, keeping inventions secret often resulted in the inventions being lost forever. Thus, if there is no patent system one may argue that the ideas would still be kept under lock, in fact they would be more severely locked down than before. If you study the history of innovations, you can see a lot of interesting inventions being completely lost merely because their practitioners wanted to keep them secret. Also, you will find out about entire secret societies being formed just to keep knowledge secret (e.g., the Masons). For example considering the kind of buildings the masons built in medieval times, they must have had some pretty good knowledge of rudimentary physics and mathematics. But all this knowledge was carefully kept secret to ensure their monopoly. Thus, nothing was published and nothing could be used by the scientists of the era to develop overall scientific theories. edit : full disclosure, I am a patent lawyer. Further edited for spelling and grammar.
- blasdel 17y ago
- grellas 17y agoThis article takes much broader aim than merely at the patent system (which I leave for others to argue) - it takes aim at the entire system of affording special protections for intellectual property generally. The authors nowhere attempt any form of coherent articulation of this broader position and merely take swipes at the protections they oppose, but I think this broader position either undermines their credibility or indicates a serious sloppiness on their part. In essence, the authors assert that there is a major difference between having society (and its laws) protect tangible forms of property, on the one hand, and intangible forms, on the other. Thus, we understand how our home should belong to us exclusively, for instance, but it is somehow different when the issue comes, for example, to copyright protections. I realize that I am perhaps flying right into the teeth of some firmly-held opinions at this site in delving into this, but I will do so anyway. Statements stating or implying that protection of tangible forms of property are fundamentally legally distinguishable from protection of intangible forms are based in ignorance. Legally, in a system of private property, the law recognizes "bundles of rights" that attach to all forms of property. We can own property, we can possess it, we can alienate (sell or transfer) it, we can bequeath it, we can improve or modify it, and on and on. These legal attributes that attach to property are there for the owner's protection and for society's betterment. Is it outrageous that the law allows a property owner to deal with this bundle of rights largely as he sees fit? Not at all. In fact, this is how we can truly enjoy our forms of property to the fullest extent. I may own my property but I can take one specific attribute among the bundle of rights that define my ownership, e.g., my right to exclusive possession, and I can transfer that right while still retaining overall ownership. This is how the law recognizes and enforces a lease. Would our society be better off in abolishing all leases just because some landlords become slumlords and exploit their tenants? Of course not. That would be absurd. That sort of remedy, while perhaps having superficial appeal as a means of eliminating abuses, clearly would defeat the many valuable things that a society derives from allowing leases to be recognized and enforced. Why should this bundle of rights be any different for intangible property rights (so-called intellectual property)? Authors in the eighteenth century, even if they had obtained copyright protection in their own countries, would often suffer scandalous losses as their works were ripped off and reprinted without any form of compensation given to them. Is it wrong that, today, such rights are protected? Silicon Valley over the past several decades has thrived and grown as the fruits of the labor of countless individuals were given legal protection in the form of copyright, trade secret, and, yes, even patent. Do we now want to take all creative efforts and allow those who poured their blood and sweat into devising new and improved algorithms, designs, inventions, etc. to be stripped of all protections as, for example, happens to their works in countries where intellectual property is not protected (e.g., mainland China)? How many startup businesses depend on licensing the products of their creative efforts to others? Abolish IP protections and suddenly there is nothing left to license (a license being the counterpart of the lease discussed above, representing a subdivision of a bundle of rights belonging to the owner of the intangible property involved). Even software as a service could be ripped off with impunity. Any employee of the organization offering the software-based service could walk away with any code he wanted and freely use it for a competing site. Without IP protection being recognized by society or its laws, there would be nothing to stop this. If everything that is intangible is simply held in common, the fruits of any individual's creative efforts would not be protected and there would no longer be any special economic rewards associated with doing a creative work. Of course, one could argue that society "benefits" from having a more widely available use of those works but who will be motivated to pour blood and sweat into creating them? And who will want to put risk capital into a company whose charter is to develop such creative works when such investors will bear 100% of the loss if the venture fails while they will get no special reward (or at least a much diminished reward than they would have gotten if their company had legally protectible rights to its IP) if it succeeds? Of course, very few if any persons would want to put their money into a "heads I win, tails you lose" situation. Thus, the claim of these authors that protection of IP should be abrogated is worse than wrong - in a system of private property, anyway, it is absurd. Any such abolition would undercut the basic foundation upon which the vast majority of startups (and much of enterprise generally) are based. Again, I leave the patent discussion to others, but any such discussion needs to be based on a carefully considered analysis and not on a facile and superficial strewing about of random points that strike an author's fancy. Just for starters, when I hear "abolish patents," I wonder how this would be any more beneficial to society than, for example, abolishing leases - is it a good answer in dealing with existing abuses to throw out an entire system that may and very likely does serve many good purposes in society? I am skeptical (at the same time, I acknowledge and do not defend the current abuses in this system, which are numerous - at a minimum, the system clearly needs fixing).
- richardburton 17y agoJames Dyson made 5,167 prototypes before he came up with the winning formula for the Dyson cleaner. I doubt that he could have become a successful billionaire without the right to fight off the companies who tried to make a quick buck out all his hard work. http://bobsutton.typepad.com/my_weblog/2009/02/5127-failed-prototypes-james-dyson-and-his-vacuum-cleaner.html http://bobsutton.typepad.com/my_weblog/2009/02/5127-failed-p...
- coffeeaddicted 17y agoMaking sure inventors get rich is not the aim of the patent-system. Most people work hard every day and there isn't a system in place to make sure they will all profit from that real big one day. So yes - there are people which profit from the patent-system, as there are always people which profit from a monopoly. And exceptionally one of those people profiting from it is even the one who put most work in it. So it might be a slightly better system than a pure lottery. Except that I'm not forced to play lottery, while I'm forced to partake in the patent-system. I would prefer not doing so. Make it an open-choice and I'm fine with it, because then I will avoid taking part in the patent-lottery as much as I avoid taking part in any other lottery. And don't worry, that won't stop me from inventing, actually it will make working for me on new stuff a lot easier.
- mattmaroon 17y agoThis article keeps mentioning "empirical evidence" yet gives nothing but opinion. Then it mentions some instances where the bathwater is cold and suggests we throw out the baby. Save your 3 minutes.
- jsz0 17y agoWhatever happened to patents needing to be "non-obvious" and patent grants being utilized within a certain time period? It seems those two provisions would solve a huge number of frivolous patent lawsuits. Both provisions existed at some point in the last 100 years. What the hell happened and when exactly did it happen? It seems like our patent laws were fairly reasonable not all that long ago.
- vaporstun 17y agoThe author ignores the main reason patents exist by pulling in emotional things. Sure, in a magical happy world it would be great to offer children in Africa free AIDS medicine, but the fact of the matter is that millions of dollars go into getting a drug like that to market. It takes millions of dollars of research, millions of dollars to go through clinical trials, millions of dollars to go through FDA approvals, etc. And ultimately most drugs are very simple chemical compounds that could be easily synthesized in retrospect with the most basic of equipment. While it's certainly bad for companies to exploit the patent system and try to extort profit out of sick and dying people, that does not justify throwing out the protection altogether. If we threw out the patent system, none of the drug companies would spend the millions of dollars required to create things like a cure for AIDS as they would not make that money back because the next guy would just do some simple chromatography and have the same chemical compound synthesized for a fraction of the cost. What company is going to go tens of millions of dollars in debt with no hope of making that money back? When the incentive to do research is gone, we have no AIDS cure at all and in my opinion a world with no AIDS cure is worse than a world with an AIDS cure that's a bit expensive. There are many things that are broken with the patent system for sure, but throwing it out completely would cause many things to fall apart and cause catastrophic damage.
- rfreytag 17y agoPricing is hard and getting the right time-period for a monopoly on an idea is no different. And then the Patent Office profits by awarding patents putting the negative externality burden on those in the field of the patent to "fix" mistakes. For a man of his historical importance Jefferson had a lot of questionable ideas (owning slaves, blaming banks for his debt, monopolies on ideas, and I don't care much for the speeches I've read of his either). Louisiana Purchase turned out all right though.