4 ms·
>Apparently users of coontown say a lot of hateful but keep it to that subReddit. I think that is naive. People aren't going to segment their personality like
by slg 11y ago
>Apparently users of coontown say a lot of hateful but keep it to that subReddit.
I think that is naive. People aren't going to segment their personality like that. I subscribe to /r/baseball because I'm a baseball fan. If baseball comes up on HN or /r/dataisbeautiful, I will often chime in because I'm still a baseball fan. Is that going to be any different for someone who subscribes to /r/coontown? They likely subscribe because they are racists and enjoy reinforcing that belief. Do we expect those same racist users to suddenly keep those ideas to themselves when they stumble upon Jesse Jackson posting in /r/iama?
- DanBC 11y agoUsers of coontown are racist, yes, and that's probably detectable in their posts. But users of coontown apparently[1] don't post threads linking to other subs and then visit that other sub with thousand of votes and dozens of comments. FPH did. [1] i've never read coontown so maybe I am totally wrong. Maybe they do brigade but they're so small it doesn't matter?
- slg 11y agoCoontown makes Reddit an attractive place for racists to congregate. As the overall userbase of Reddit starts to include more racists, it will inherently lead to racist users voting and posting comments on other posts. Coontown doesn't necessarily need to promote users spreading their ideas to other subreddits, its mere existence helps to accomplish the same.
- rory096 11y agoSo you argue that reddit should exclude people, rather than content? What if a user is found being racist on another site, should they be banned from reddit?
- slg 11y agoThat is a step beyond anything I have said. I am just pointing out that we shouldn't say "Coontown is fine because they keep to themselves." The fact is that people are attracted to Reddit based on content. You don't need to ban any people if you change the content to attract (and repel) different people. Reddit is now the most popular site on the Internet for racists to congregate. I think that is a problem for the whole site. Making the site less accommodating to racists would seem to be a good first step in addressing that issue. Reddit doesn't appear willing to do that.
- leereeves 11y agoI don't know who said this, but I heard it somewhere: "If you support free speech, you can count on being accused of supporting the worst things anyone can say."
- slg 11y agoI don't think that is relevant here. We already establish that Reddit is going to be stricter than the law. Right now we are only debating how much stricter than the law it should be.
- leereeves 11y agoI'm not sure we've established that. If reddit is stricter than the law in banning cyber harassment and some non-consensual photographs, they aren't much stricter. There are laws against those things in California.
- slg 11y agoThat is only a subset of the banned content. Almost none of the below stuff is illegal and was alos listed in the post's banned list. -Spam -Publication of someone’s private and confidential information -Anything that incites harm or violence against an individual or group of people (it's ok to say "I don't like this group of people." It's not ok to say, "I'm going to kill this group of people.") -Anything that harasses, bullies, or abuses[2] an individual or group of people (these behaviors intimidate others into silence) -Sexually suggestive content featuring minors