7 ms·
Uber should be suspended in California and fined $7.3M, judge says
- Systemic33 11y agoConsidering the massive backlash Uber has received around the world, i'm quite impressed how they can keep the show going, and investors keep funding them. Doesn't this seem like a lost cause for VC's? Edit: I get that the service they provide is hugely beneficial to the customers, but if that is only possible from breaking the law, then it's doomed to fail. E.g. If an airline company provided extremely cheap flights, by having people who just received a license to fly be the captain, then you are asking for trouble, legal and illegal. Truth be told, if Uber pivoted to instead of cutting out the taxi companies, instead delivered the app as a service for the taxi companies, then they could probably optimize their respective companies to be able to provide taxi services cheaper and with better service.
- Kranar 11y agoEverywhere I've been people/customers love Uber. I live in Toronto and I think it's safe to say the people much prefer Uber over taxis. The only significant entities who dislike Uber seem to be taxi companies and governments.
- justizin 11y ago.. and the victims of accidents who find that the drivers are not properly insured, and the drivers who find that their insurance company drops them and they are liable .. and people who think that you should be able to get a fucking cab in the rain for less than $400. ;)
- smeyer 11y agoI can't speak to the insurance side, but I know that in Boston, the sort of times when a surge goes over 2x are the same sort of times that it's very difficult to hail a cab, let alone expect dispatch to send one if you call. If the weather is bad enough to be at a 2.5x surge, I'd never expect to be able to get a hackney cab here. Other cities may not have this problem.
- justizin 11y agoVC's aren't trying to make public opinion, and uber makes money. Frankly, it probably wouldn't hurt their business as much as their ego to stop operating in CA forever, even, since they launched here years ago and duplicated the model around the world. They would probably move their offices to NYC eventually. Anyway, we'll see if this is anything more than posturing.
- aetherson 11y agoUber doesn't make money.
- justizin 11y agoThey sure as hell do, they just aren't giving any back to their investors, yet, because money is pouring into their laps and they're happy to spend it. There's a difference between not being profitable and not making money, and when you're displacing an entire existing industry, you can afford to lose money while you're doing it. That's one of the hidden stories with Uber, of course, that taxi drivers give up their taxis and move to uber and that door kind of closes behind them, and the taxi companies lose share and it'll all shake out in the end is their hope. I think they're insane, but it's silly to pretend that VCs care about anything but the valuation, IMO.
- aetherson 11y ago"Buying $20 bills for $21" does not constitute making money, no matter how many $20 bills you end up with. So, to be clear, I think our disagreement is fairly narrow. You suggest that the VCs care about the valuation. I agree! But: 1. Uber isn't making money. Its investors no doubt hope that it will make money at some point. But investors are not infallible, and it is entirely possible that Uber will never be profitable, or (more likely) will at some point but profitable, but not profitable enough to justify its lofty valuation. 2. That said, investors don't directly care about whether or not Uber makes money -- they care about its valuation. If Uber starts making money hand over fist, certainly that's one way for its valuation to increase, but there are others. Maybe it will go public and its current investors will cash out and then it will be revealed that robo cars kill Uber and it will crash and burn -- but still be a good investment for current investors. I don't think that's the most likely scenario, but it's possible. Anyhow, the point is, it is not now "making money," and whether it will ever "make money" in very large scales is currently unknown.
- HappyTypist 11y agoUber is not receiving 'massive backlash' from users. It's receiving backlash from authorities and regulators. Personally, the more authorities want to ban uber the more I want to use it.
- mattwad 11y agoMaybe it's not a win or lose situation. I wish Uber would just play by the rules and make their drivers real employees. They have so much money that sure, they won't make as MUCH profit, but it will probably still be a service worth using and will still help break the medallion monopoly. It won't happen until the governments force their hand, but hopefully it's just a matter of time.
- onewaystreet 11y agoUber loses battles from time to time, but they are winning the war.
- ianstallings 11y agoI'd hate to see losing.
- onewaystreet 11y agoLosing would be getting banned and staying banned. Many places have banned Uber in the past (SF, NYC, etc.) but they ended up getting unbanned. Portland is recent example: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-06-23/this-is-how-uber-takes-over-a-city http://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2015-06-23/this-is-ho...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWait until the IRS deems Uber has illegally classified workers across the country as independent contractors and requires missed tax payments and penalties to be paid. It should be noted, corporate officers are personally liable for those expenses if the corporation defaults or folds.
- ianstallings 11y agoAnd notable politicians are talking about squashing the "gig" economy (e.g. Hillary Clinton). If I was an investor I'd be a little worried. The US government has made clear in the past that it frowns on using contractors over full time employees, if past law suits against enterprises that use them are any indication.
- msellout 11y agoNo. It's likely that companies like Uber will cause a shift in the legal treatment of employees vs contractors. I hope that the difference will be eliminated. It's such a fine line already, very difficult to know whether someone is a contractor or an employee. Technology and market forces are eliminating the difference, the law needs to catch up. Universal health care and disability insurance would eliminate much of the difference between those labels.
- dikaiosune 11y agoThrow in better retirement options than 401k's, and a few other things, and I think that might be possible.
- moistgorilla 11y agoUber receives massive backlash from taxi drivers, local governments receiving political funds from taxi companies and journalists with agendas. The average consumer loves Uber
- Vadoff 11y agoThe law is created by people. If enough people support it, the laws will eventually become overturned.
- HappyTypist 11y agoI question the value of CPUC wanting detailed historical operational data. It seems like an attempt by an outdated regulatory organization to shoehorn itself by flexing its authority, creating nothing but more bureaucratic inefficiency. What purpose does it serve? How will it make California more safe? How are the legal costs, the administrative costs, and the overhead costs justified? I think these questions should be asked more often, instead of blindly respecting that authority is good, and regulation is a net positive.
- greenyoda 11y agoThis issue is not that CPUC wants this data, it's that state law requires operators to provide the data to CPUC. The article says: "Uber's parent company has refused to provide data on operational data that is required under the 2013 law that legalized ride-hailing firms, the California Public Utilities Commission judge said in a decision issued Wednesday afternoon."
- HappyTypist 11y agoThat is a separate issue. While an unjust law is still law, it does not mean I will look down on a service that ignores unjust laws.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mrkmcknz 11y agoI think Uber is a great company and I love the product. However, I can't remember a startup that received billions in funding and having such disregard for local laws around the globe. I just don't get it. They literally don't comply with any law in any country and give zero shits about the consequences.
- danieltillett 11y agoWell as long as you can cash out before the law catches up it is not a bad strategy.
- themagician 11y agoThis is not unique to Uber. It's a trend. Step 1: Find a regulated industry (taxi, hotel, liquor, etc.) Step 2: Create an app and label yourself as being part of the "sharing economy" that is disrupting the industry Step 3: Completely ignore all regulation Step 4: Profit — largely because you don't have to pay for licensing, insurance, etc. while everyone else in the industry you are trying to disrupt does
- HappyTypist 11y agoThat's not true. Uber is paying for insurance for all drivers while in a ride. Furthermore, why is licensing needed? You know a $40 billion company wouldn't be a scam. I see companies like Uber disrupting the industry by removing inefficiency. Licensing, medallions, appeasing public bureaucrats, etc are inefficiencies. That's not to say that regulation is inherently bad, but we need to let new industries grow and see its challenges first -- instead of applying outdated concepts (like medallions, licensing) to new technology. For example: USPS, by law, has a monopoly on mail delivery. Just imagine if USPS banned all e-mail providers and forced you to use your @usps.com inbox. Is this a net benefit? Is the taxi industry banning all ridesharing apps and forcing you to use taxis a net benefit?
- Anechoic 11y agoYou know a $40 billion company wouldn't be a scam. Bernie Madoff's investors would disagree.
- Lucratert 11y agoUber isn't complying with a law that they supported. "California has always been on the cutting edge. The CPUC agreement further demonstrates how the Golden State welcomes and supports not only technological advancement, but a better future for drivers, riders, and our cities." http://newsroom.uber.com/la/2013/01/california-clears-uber-to-continue-and-expand-operations/ http://newsroom.uber.com/la/2013/01/california-clears-uber-t...
- Tycho 11y agoThe people of California can surely now breathe a sigh of relief that the government was able to protect them from this predatory company and the services it offered.
- dikaiosune 11y agoThe rule of law is something that every US business relies on. Further, I doubt that Uber relies on vigilante justice to settle their disputes -- they (just like everyone else) rely on the law and the courts to get what's legally entitled to them.
- Tycho 11y agoLegitimate businesses rely mostly on the enforcement of contracts and protection of property. Immoral businesses rely on government force to prevent other citizens freely engaging in otherwise harmless transactions for mutual benefit.
- arielm 11y agoAlthough I dislike the term "disruptive", this is a great case of just that. Uber aggressively disrupted the taxi industry without regard to rules or regulations and is now seeing the side of the law that appreciates those. I personally think uber is a great service. The company's aggressive growth strategies can be questioned but given the offended industry is one that hasn't changed in ages, is controlled by a small few, and has lots of issues on its own, I think über is fine. Another byproduct of their aggressive growth is the amount of money they've raised, which they have been and will continue to put to use on lawyer fees ;)
- leereeves 11y agoDetails from http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/wireStory/uber-fined-7m-keeping-info-california-regulators-32479254 http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/wireStory/uber-fined-7m-kee... > The judge agreed with utility commission staff who said Uber has not filed all required reports, specifically about how often it provided disabled-accessible vehicles when requested, places where drivers tend to turn down ride requests, and the causes of accidents.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe CPUC has kowtowed to incumbent providers for decades. The wrinkle in this case is that the "incumbents" are taxi companies rather than VZN and ATT.
- SilasX 11y agoThis reminds me of Yishan Wong's comment about the law being "lazily evaluated" [1]. Whatever the legal merit of the ruling, the plain political reality is that Uber has establish an immense base of satisfied users and will therefore receive significant pushback on this. I personally can't imagine Uber shutting down in CA at this point: so many people are past the the "can't imagine how I did it before..." threshold. While Uber's strategy was in a gray (if not black) area at the time of inception, by the time the law gets around to "evaluating" whether to act against Uber, the sands have shifted, vindicating Wong's point. [1] https://www.quora.com/Why-has-Airbnb-not-been-sued-or-regulated-out-of-existence/answer/Yishan-Wong?share=1 https://www.quora.com/Why-has-Airbnb-not-been-sued-or-regula...
- ranman 11y agoI love uber and use it daily. I live in NYC where taxis have been getting worse and worse over the past few years. I am very concerned about how much their "contractors" make though. Some of the drivers I speak to claim they can make 100k a year driving just Friday and Saturday nights... others say they aren't making much profit after insurance, TLC, and leasing costs.
- carterehsmith 11y agoHonestly, what would be nice to see, is the breakdown: who is making money, and how much, when one rides the taxicab, i.e. Uber vs Yellow Cab vs whatever-cab. Also, whether the price is sustainable, or is it just price-dumping. I want to give more money to the cabbie driver, and then less and less to the broker (Yellow Cab or Uber) (10% finders fee is what is common in other businesses), medallion owner (0% - provides no value), car owner (investor - 10% a year would be great investment), licensing board (fixed fee, say $300), insurance ($thousands per year for sure), and whoever else is trying to make money on this.
- superuser2 11y agoThis ruling is a (proposed) penalty for failing to hand over private customer data including GPS logs of trips. HN would normally love to see a company stand up to such an order.