4 ms·
Berkshire Hathaway is a totally diferent type of company (conglomerate ) to an advertising company. They where v popular in the 60/70's until the wheels came o
by walshemj 11y ago
Berkshire Hathaway is a totally diferent type of company (conglomerate ) to an advertising company.
They where v popular in the 60/70's until the wheels came of and corporate raiders starting breaking them up.
- nostrademons 11y agoGoogle is also a technology conglomerate. Of the big emerging business lines at Google - Android/Play, GFiber/Loon, YouTube, self-driving cars, Nest & home automation, enterprise Google Docs, and AppEngine/Cloud - YouTube is the only one where the money comes from advertising. This is a major shift from the Eric Schmidt years; Eric would always say "Our next billion dollar business is our last billion dollar business." Larry's plan is clearly to own a major portion of the technology industry going forwards, using capital from Google's first successful business (Search) to fund direct investment in new technologies, the same way that Buffett used the float from his insurance company to acquire additional cash-generating businesses. It remains to be seen how successful he is at this; tech is very different from the brick & mortar businesses that Buffett got rich at, and small startups often have strong advantages over well-funded incumbents. But "Google is an advertising company" hasn't really been true, in terms of corporate strategy, since Larry took over.
- msabalau 11y agoTo a certain extent, one could imagine a tech conglomerate would be easier to manage than a traditional brick and mortar conglomerate, and least for the digital offerings. It's a lot easier to wind down less successful initiatives, and redeploy creative, skilled people to work that is more valuable. No sunk costs in production lines, inventory or call centers.
- nostrademons 11y agoThe problem - at least in my mental model, and it's possible I'm wrong, it's often dangerous to bet against Larry - is that new technology businesses often require a closeness to individual early adopters and speed of decision making that is impossible to achieve in a big company. The factors that make new tech businesses successful are often very subtle, and they're discovered only through long periods of direct interaction with users. When you're an engineer at Google, you don't have the freedom of direct-messaging an individual user, saying "Hey, what do you think? Got any suggestions for us?" and then immediately making the change and pushing it to production. In my experience, that seems to be essential for new tech products to catch on. (With the possible exception of Apple, who seem to be able to convince the consumer that they really want an Apple product regardless of what that product does. Even that lustre seems to be fading.)
- billyhoffman 11y agoIn 2014, 89% of Google's revenue comes from advertising. Google is an advertising company with a lack of focus. I don't think I would call "use the war chest and try a bunch of stuff to move forward" a strategy. It feels like floundering, exactly like Microsoft's "Take the Windows/Office war chest and find the next big thing" doldrums of the last decade. https://investor.google.com/earnings/2014/Q4_google_earnings.html https://investor.google.com/earnings/2014/Q4_google_earnings...
- dimino 11y agoWhat else are you supposed to do when you conquer your market? Spending more money to be an even bigger Internet ad player would suffer diminishing returns, so you hunt for better investments that'll (here comes the buzzword) synergize with your current money maker (ads). At least at first, Google's "floundering" was always focused back onto advertisement -- e.g. Android to capture the mobile market.
- jimbokun 11y ago"What else are you supposed to do when you conquer your market?" Pay out massive dividends.
- nostrademons 11y agoThe assumption when you pay out massive dividends is that the stock market as a whole can invest that capital more efficiently than you can. It remains to be seen whether that's the case, but given how the average Fortune 500 company operates and the trends of technological change that are happening right now, I really doubt it.
- walshemj 11y agoNo but the company does belong to the share holders who might want to have some dividend payments.
- 11y ago
- objclxt 11y ago> Of the big emerging business lines at Google - Android/Play, GFiber/Loon, YouTube, self-driving cars, Nest & home automation, enterprise Google Docs, and AppEngine/Cloud - YouTube is the only one where the money comes from advertising. GFiber/Loon is arguably about increasing connectivity and internet access to Google services, and thus increasing ad revenue. Android also increases exposure to Google services and ad revenue. Indeed, one of the main justifications of Android and Play Services has always been that if Google can control the platform they can control where eyeballs go for ads.
- fredkbloggs 11y ago> But "Google is an advertising company" hasn't really been true, in terms of corporate strategy, since Larry took over. Strategy is aspirational; revenue and profits are reality. Google is an advertising company. Larry may aspire to be the Emperor of San Francisco and Protector of Mexico, and there's little to prevent him telling people that he already is, but that does nothing to change the fact that he's really the CEO of an advertising company in Mountain View.
- dasil003 11y agoThis is such a reductionist Wall Street perspective. Money is just what keeps the lights on, but it says nothing about the impact on the world. Google's impact is not just advertising, arguably the most notable impacts are the utility of its search, and Android as the only credible competitor to iPhone keeping Apple on its game. While it's true that none of that is sustainable without the advertising business, that only matters at the point that business is failing.
- gress 11y agoThe focus on costs indicates precisely the concern about the ongoing strength of the advertising business.
- dasil003 11y agoWait, where did I say that there were no concerns about the business? I was responding to a comment that literally said "profits are reality" as a way of dismissing all the interesting things that Google does which are not directly profitable.
- jimbokun 11y ago"Of the big emerging business lines at Google - Android/Play, GFiber/Loon, YouTube, self-driving cars, Nest & home automation, enterprise Google Docs, and AppEngine/Cloud - YouTube is the only one where the money comes from advertising." As opposed to the others, where the money doesn't come from anywhere.
- dragonwriter 11y agoAndroid and Fiber arguably exist in no small part to prevent a situation where entities with market power in the respective industries are able to extract rents from Google's online services, particularly its current primary revenue stream. So, in a sense, they are "money comes from ads" businesses, but in a less direct manner.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's even more of a holding company, it doesn't try to integrate the disparate businesses under a single management structure (if anything, it encourages owned companies to thin out their management).