14 ms·
Rotterdam to consider trialling plastic roads
- j_lev 11y agoWould be interesting to see how potholes look and how they are repaired.
- im3w1l 11y agoWouldn't that leak significant amounts of endocrine disruptors into the environment?
- jrapdx3 11y agoProbably not. Endocrine disruptors in the environment can result from degradation of certain polymers, releasing chemicals such as bisphenol-A (BPA), phthalates and other compounds. For example, materials made with BPA such as polycarbonates, are associated with endocrine disruption hazards, particularly for children. Generally food and beverage containers are made from polyethylene or polypropylene because these plastics are very inert. They aren't made with compounds associated with endocrine disruption. Since the proposed roadways were going to use recycled polyethylene pop bottles it shouldn't be a problem. However I'm skeptical about the idea on other grounds, I have real doubts about factors like durability and cost.
- im3w1l 11y agoThis is a review of evidence on the subject: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854718/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2854718/ The road will be exposed to heat and sunlight both of which promote leaching.
- estefan 11y agoPerhaps they'll lacquer it to prevent that.
- dang 11y agoUrl changed from http://gizmodo.com/this-company-wants-to-test-plastic-roads-that-can-be-ma-1717475902 http://gizmodo.com/this-company-wants-to-test-plastic-roads-..., which points to this.
- ekianjo 11y agoPlastic in large quantities can become very, very expensive. It's cheap when you make a bottle or any kind of thin package, but as measured in kg, plastics are not cheap at all (but have interesting properties).
- roel_v 11y agoOther articles about this made it sound like they'd use re-used, granulated plastic, like that fished out of the ocean's 'plastic soups'. I don't know anything about plastic manufacturing or chemistry, but that was supposedly one of the big selling points - that the materials are cheap and needed to be disposed of anyway, some way.
- jkot 11y agoChina buys used plastic for decent money.
- neals 11y agoGreat to see the massive amounts of plastic that I put out every 2 weeks are being put to good use.
- vacri 11y agoNote to marketing guys: find a better word than 'plastic'. You lose out because it sounds unenvironmental and is also associated with cheap, shoddy products. Go for something like 'polymer' instead.
- mulletbum 11y agoIf he did that it would diminish the clicks for people who can associate plastic with other items. I think very little people are associating polymer to their pop bottles.
- amelius 11y agoWill this make us run out of oil even faster?
- Gonzih 11y agoIt's recycled plastic, so I doubt it. Plastic recycling is very expensive process, so very small percentage of currently produced plastic is recycled one.
- emp_zealoth 11y agoAs a person that rides motorcycle avidly I'm always distressed when the most important metric of a road gets a tiny mention, when discussing those new technologies. Traction. If it's not at least as good as current best asphalt then don't bother. Cities are already turning into motorcycle deathtraps, with all the "safety" nonsense generously painted everywhere (Which is slippery as hell, even during sunny weather)
- Zuikaku 11y agoBecause motorcycles are the number one users of road? Because the enjoyment of a small proportion of users outweigh whatever environmental and economic costs of improving infrastructure?
- pvdebbe 11y agoAre you forgetting that two-wheelers are usually a very fuel-efficient way to travel distances? Besides, if the road markings are anything to go by, it would be terribly slippery for drivers too.
- masklinn 11y ago> Because motorcycles are the number one users of road? Traction issues happen on all wheeled vehicles, motorcycles are just extremely sensitive to them. A few years back I got rear-ended (at low speed) because of pretty much the issue mentioned: fully painted crosswalk in wet conditions, the car behind just slipped on it and couldn't stop, ended up in the trunk.
- mulletbum 11y agoMaybe they were just a terrible driver. I live in a cold U.S. State and have never slipped on Ice and RearEnded someone. I have never been in a situation where I slid down a hill and couldn't stop, mostly because I drive like you are supposed to in the Winter. Self driving cars will invalidate the need to worry about traction as they will force themselves to adjust to conditions instead of humans choosing to drive inappropriate for current weather conditions.
- Tharkun 11y agoWhat's wrong with asphalt? It can be easily recycled, it's an otherwise pretty useless component of crude oil of which we have plenty. It can be repaired with relative ease.
- test1235 11y ago"...recycled plastic, which it said required less maintenance than asphalt and could withstand greater extremes of temperature– between -40C and 80C. Roads could be laid in a matter of weeks rather than months and last about three times as long, it claimed." "...asphalt is responsible for 1.6m tons of CO2 emissions a year globally – 2% of all road transport emissions."
- VLM 11y agoWRT the first quote the road business in the USA is extremely corrupt along the lines of cellphone battery life always being advertised as about 3 times reality, etc, so it would be assumed the claims are outright false and the maint cost will be higher and only last 1/3 the lifetime of asphalt. Its an interesting cultural problem that the claims might actually be true in that that country! WRT the second quote, that doesn't answer the question. If you can't mix the heavy stuff from the distillation column with gravel and pave roads with it, you'll have to ... crickets ... Bonfire it? Dump it in the ocean? Pour it in a pit and leave the cleanup to someone else? Ship it far away for someone else to use it as asphalt? Damaged roads are very expensive ecologically. Saving the planet $5 on pavement is a good way to charge the planet $1000s in tie rods and suspension components, but out of sight, out of mind...
- Tharkun 11y agoI don't buy the marketing blurn. How are potholes going to be repaired? As for asphalt's CO2 footprint, that's the figure for asphalt mixed with cement. Extracting asphalt and bitumens from crude oil is literally the bottom of barrel. Pardon typos, fat sausages on moving bus.
- mulletbum 11y ago
- UserRights 11y agoThe Propaganda-Elephant in the Room: there is no such thing as "recycling plastics" - but still the word "recycling" is commonly used, even if the described process very clearly is not about recycling. Obviously, this is a downcycling process which will lead to dissolved plastic in the food chain after a few decades, so this is far away from an ecologically sustainable or clean solution, that might be acceptable for our next generations, it is plain stupid. The solution is to reglement plastic production to a set of about max. 50 different recipes for different applications that actually can be recycled. Today we have thousands of patent-protected artificial substances called "plastic" and the plastics lobby is extremely strong in suppressing any discussion that goes into that direction.
- chiph 11y agoSo these are produced in large panels, which are laid on a compacted roadbed, or perhaps on concrete supports. The problem I see is that of the joints - as cars & trucks drive over them, they'll flex the plastic, causing loud "thump thump" noises.
- NextPerception 11y agoPlastic is not a sustainable nor cost-effective material to build roads out of. I am a mechanical designer who designs with plastics daily. All plastic polymer chains break down over time and there is no getting around it. Light, thermal-variations, water-absorption, and mechanical stress can cause microscopic polymer chains to break and this weakens the plastic. If you have ever seen plastic that has become brittle with old age or sunlight you have seen a perfect example of polymer-chain damage in plastics. The rate of polymer chain breakage can be slowed down through various plastic formulations but it can't be stopped, especially in an outdoor environment where it is contending with wild temperature variations, water, oil, sunlight, and cars driving on it. So yes, lets make a road out of plastic, even though plastic is at it's absolute worst under the stresses roads undergo. I will join the "when will the road break" betting pool at 8 years and 2 months after the road is laid.
- ArekDymalski 11y ago"It’s still an idea on paper at the moment; the next stage is to build it and test it in a laboratory to make sure it’s safe in wet and slippery conditions and so on" EOT