9 ms·
Denmark’s wind farms generated 140% of the country’s electricity needs yesterday
- krasin 11y agoWhile the number is slick, it does not account for the energy needed for cars. (see below for the explanation of this terse statement)
- hayksaakian 11y agothe title is pretty specific about 'electricity' as opposed to 'energy'
- higherpurpose 11y agoThat's why it says electricity. Also, when you can produce this much electricity (already), it makes it possible to fill electric cars' batteries with 100% renewable energy.
- krasin 11y agoMy (implied) point was that for every engine / machine that runs on gas / coal, there's an electric alternative. If the goal is to adopt 100% clean / renewable energy, we should count the electricity needs as the current electricity consumption + the electricity we need to run the replacement engines / machines. And that number is going to be significantly higher than wind can deliver.
- pbreit 11y agoApparently you're wrong and we haven't even gotten to other sources such as hydro and solar.
- krasin 11y agoHydro (and geo-thermal) are good, but not universally available. Nor California, nor Israel would find it as an option. In opposite, both are desalinating the water using fossil fuels, just to cover basic needs. Solar sounds much better; and its potential crop is much higher than wind. Also, I am not saying that clean/distributed energy system is impossible. I am saying that the metric used in the article is misleading.
- ekianjo 11y agoYou will need to burn a whole lot of fossil fuels to make batteries for every car on the road. Thats always ignored by proponents of electric cars who conveniently ignore the fact that batteries manufacturing processes are very dirty and use a number of toxic materials.
- lyschoening 11y agoYou also need a lot of energy to make a car, or to build a combustion engine. Yes, battery driven cars are particularly polluting to produce, but a couple tanks full of gasoline will make up for the difference. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/07/21/are-electric-cars-really-that-polluting/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/07/21/are-electr...
- mrweasel 11y agoDenmark isn't currently geared to use electricity from wind mills to recharge electric cars. Well you can fill your battery of cause, but you can't choose to do it at specific times at reduced cost or by wind only. We really do need to get a system in place that can have variable rates.
- mrweasel 11y agoThat is actually a very valid point, even if the article specifically says electricity. Denmark is frequently running 100%+ wind power, that's nothing new. We also almost always burn coal or waste at the same time. Most house (in the cities) are heated and have hot water provided by either large coal burning power plants, or smaller local gas or waste burning plants. I believe that the politicians have finally allowed excess wind power to be used to produce heat at local heating plants. Previously they needed to pay a CO2 tax for the power they would consume (even if it came from wind mills), that ruined the business case and the excess power was sold or given away to neighboring countries.
- thebmax 11y agoThis is partly the problem with renewable power. You get large swings in generation where some days it's your entire demand and you may even have to pay to export the excess power and other days it's 0 and you need to fire up the gas plants in order to avoid brownouts. Building two power plants (wind and gas) results in double the cost and less reliable grid overall. It's surprising how much people seem to discount the reliability of wind and solar when discussing them as true alternatives to fossil fuels.
- threeseed 11y agoSure that is a problem, now. But there is a lot of investment in energy storage solutions e.g. electric cars, molten sands, large scale batteries, smart grids. People are very aware of the problems with wind/solar but that doesn't mean that we should continue to use fossil fuels or blindly pursue unpopular, problematic technologies like nuclear. The status quo is simply not an option.
- rory096 11y ago> blindly pursue unpopular, problematic technologies like nuclear. Why is it blind problematic pursuit? Because it's unpopular?
- crdoconnor 11y agoI'll consider it non-problematic when the nuclear liability cap is eliminated and the private sector insures it fully. Without subsidies. If it were so incredibly safe, there wouldn't be a need to give taxpayer support. The real reason, of course, is that it isn't actually that safe, and private insurers aren't willing to take the risk without a liability cap that is pathetically low (a few hundred million). And, if you got rid of this subsidy: no more nuclear plants.
- 13thLetter 11y ago"The real reason, of course, is that it isn't actually that safe" Perhaps you'd like to go into detail on why you think it isn't actually that safe, especially when compared with the fossil fuel energy generation ecosystem it would be replacing.
- idlewords 11y agoThis article reminded me of an interesting structural problem in eastern Germany, right next door to Denmark. The many wind farms there give a net surplus of power, but there's no easy way to route it to western Germany, where most of the demand is. Maybe a fellow commenter will remember the details better than I do.
- cmarschner 11y agoThe problem is mostly discussed in Germany in context of north vs. south - the north with the coast and all its wind parks, and the energy-hungry, industry-rich south. Right niw the solution is to build new power lines, but that spawned a huge political debate (NIMBY). Power lines are about as unpopular as new freeways, and there is a risk of court cases dragging on for years, stalling the energy transition program. The compromise right now is to spend more tax money and use underground cables in densely populated or otherwise sensitive areas (e.g. nature reserves).
- PebblesHD 11y agoMeanwhile in Australia, "Coal is the future!" - Tony Abbott
- static_noise 11y agoFinancially it is, at least in the short term. Australia has a lot of coal (no need to import raw material). Australia has coal mining companies (no need to import technology). CO2 is only a global problem, the coal which Australia burns won't make a big dent in the effects and the cost is shared globally. So, financially it totally makes sense to use up the local resources first. At least in the short term until these resources get scarce. In the long term, saving resources may be the wiser option. E.g. have coal plants on standby most of the time while solar and wind supply the grid. Then you can export some of the coal or save it for future generations.
- kyberias 11y agoI think you've been down-voted due to disagreement. Here's an up-vote.
- ams6110 11y agoCoal plants don't really do "standby" well though. They are much better at providing constant output. Gas turbine plants are better at handling rapid changes in supply and demand. Possibly pulverized coal could be used in a turbine but I don't know how well that works.
- istvan__ 11y agoHe is wrong, but so everybody who thinks that wind generated energy by itself is the future. The electrical grid has some very serious limitations that most of the people are not aware of. For example you cannot recover from a blackout scenario without electricity. Only very few power plants are able to do that, the most common types are nuclear plants. Another lesser known fact is that any windmill you put in your system requires a fossil based turbine as well to be able to control the surges and dips in the power production. On the top of that, most of the windmills are not suitable for being placed for human population based on the frequency of sound they produce. I think the future is clean nuclear power and some renewable sources. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_start https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_start https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBmk7t5K35A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBmk7t5K35A http://oto2.wustl.edu/cochlea/wind.html http://oto2.wustl.edu/cochlea/wind.html
- bottled_poe 11y agoDoes anyone know how many days are required to cover the energy required to produce one turbine?
- mariopt 11y agoI don't think this is relevant honestly. ( I'm assuming you want to compare the costs with other energy sources ) This reminds the question about How much energy are we spending today to build an electric/hybrid card versus a petrol one? (By comparing the factory emissions for example) Currently petrol cars are cheaper to produce because of the decades of investment, usually no one has in consideration in the equation, but on the long run eco tech wins the race. We should also expect new discoveries in Material Engineering that would help to reduce the cost and/or improve the efficiency. I don't think it's a fair to compare the cost of producing versus the cost of petrol solutions until the planet's crust isn't a source of energy.
- ytdht 11y agoit is probably relevant if you include the maintenance costs, which are probably very low for a wind turbine.
- bottled_poe 11y agoDepending on the answer to my question, it is totally relevant. > but on the long run eco tech wins the race Fine, but if some cleaner alternative is developed over the carbon repayment period, we could in fact be better off sticking with the current technology until then.
- gonvaled 11y agoYou can not make the switch in a hurry.
- hueving 11y agoThe comparison to cars isn't relevant because cars aren't expected to produce energy. If a wind turbine couldn't cover it's own energy costs, the entire thing would have been a complete loss. It would mean they are just an inefficient way to convert fossil fuels into energy.
- wodenokoto 11y agoIt's worth noting that we sell wind energy a lot cheaper than the non-renewable we buy back to cover the times where we don't produce surplus.
- usaphp 11y agoI wonder if taking energy (sun, wind, water) from the earth make any damage in long term to it - let's say fields that not going to get sun they got used to, or clouds wont move the way they otherwise would - thus causing unpredictable climate changes. Just a thought
- nickodell 11y agoThat doesn't really seem plausible. I mean, why would a windmill create more disruption in wind patterns than a hill of equivalent size? I don't think you could cause that even if you devoted all production on earth to making windmills.
- pbh101 11y agoBut that hill, if there, could cause a variation in climate. Just because an equivalent hill could be there doesn't mean the hill's presence would have the same effect as its absence. And if we're talking hundreds of thousands of hills across the globe, there could be a larger systemic effect in aggregate.
- sd8f9iu 11y agoThis seems highly unlikely (without further evidence) to have a global effect anywhere on the level of climate change, and if it's part of the solution to that problem, I'll take it.
- gonvaled 11y agoWhatever the effect, it is (very probably) not zero. By using "renewable" energy sources, we are in fact depleting the Earth from one form of energy (wind, solar, ...), producing some work (mechanical, thermal, chemical, electrical, ...) and, usually, dissipating heat. There are some directly affected climate processes. For example, if you cover a big area with solar panels, the ground does not get heat up, which can have an effect in water reservoirs or whatever. So, this is happening when we use renewable resources. I assume we can agree on this. But there are a couple of caveats: - probably the scale at which we are currently affecting the environment with renewable energy sources is reaaally small, specially compared to the effect that non-renewable energy sources have. But anyway, exponential growth based on renewable energy sources will at some point start having a big effect on climate too. This is probably very far way, and we can probably compensate for this somehow (terraforming Earth, so to say). As long as we are using up a small fraction of the sun energy, we have room for maneuver. An even then, nuclear energy can help further, so the ultimate limit is the amount of matter we have at our disposal. - it is difficult to say how Earth adjusts to this tampering: is it able to dissipate the heat produced by human processes (not talking about CO2 here)? Is it able to absorb more sun radiation, since the "equilibrium situation" has been affected? I mean, if we "slow down the wind" with a wind-turbine, maybe there is a new complementary process which takes care of putting sun energy in the wind again.
- interfixus 11y agoAlas, as the wind soars, so do our energy costs. Danish electricity prices have only gone up, up, up, and through the roof during the last thirty years or so, concurrent with the massive, statesponsored introduction of wind turbines. Or, to be precise, the pricetag of electricity itself hasn't really changed much since the 1930s, but has been completely buried under an avalanche of taxation, which in various guises makes up nearly nine tenths of my electricity bill. A lot of this is "green" tax, earmarked for sponsoring - you guessed it - more governmentally mandated wind turbines. To the best of my knowledge, our Danish electricity is the most expensive in Europe.
- static_noise 11y agoIn Germany, the private consumer pays for all the additional cost imposed by renewables while the industry still gets the old tariffs. Naturally, because a small fraction of consumers need to cover the whole cost, normal people see a much higher bill.
- radmuzom 11y agoThese are the costs you are paying for having a better and cleaner future not only for yourselves but also the next generation. Nothing wrong with that.
- mrweasel 11y agoAbsolutely true, but it's not being promoted right. While Denmark is building wind farms, we're have also been told to save on electricity continuously for the past 10+ years. Again there's nothing wrong with that, BUT if you save on electricity every year and still see your bill go up, due to additional taxes, and tariffs, your motivation is broken. Saved 10% on your electricity and having your bill stay the same doesn't make you particular susceptible to future electricity saving campaigns. If you don't do anything, then sure you bill goes up, but at least it does feel like wasted effort. The majority of an electricity bill in Denmark isn't the power you used, that's actually fairly cheap, it's the myriad of different taxes that raise your bill. It makes it almost impossible to read you bill or reduce your cost by any significant amount. It really isn't a system that promotes energy savings.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago"Earlier today, the Chernobyl power plant has fulfilled its 5-years plan of thermal energy generation in just 150 milliseconds" Talk about mad swings.
- allendoerfer 11y agoThat is the reason why there are currently huge North-South power lines planned to go through Germany. As you would expect, from the German states to small villages everybody is fighting over where they will be build. Germany has a huge generation of fit retirees and it has become a meme that they engage in citizens initiatives to fight power lines. Then there is our special child Bavaria, for whom these lines are primarily build, who wants them to go through Hesse.
- irixusr 11y agoThe question never was can wind generate enough power - just build more windmills. The question is can it be reliably integrated into a stable electrical system? Unfortunately, largely no. At least not still. Without getting into technical details note that in jurisdictions with a legal mandate to prefer windpower (when available) and large installed windbase the price of power goes negative. That is, there are situations when power companies pay to have anyone dump their power. Otherwise they'll damage their equipment. the problem never was the turbines, but the grid!
- 7952 11y agoI agree the grid issues are a major constraint on new wind turbine. But is there actually evidence that they cannot be reliably integrated in the grid? Is Denmark's grid actually unstable? At least in the UK the grid operators simply refuses connections if their is not enough grid capacity in the locality of a proposed wind farm. It is surely a problem, but one that is well understood. And paying people to dump power is a method of maintaining the grid in unusual conditions; it is just a bit unpleasant. Excess capacity is an unintended consequence of having free fuel!
- irixusr 11y agoBefore I rant; I dunno the specifics about Denmark, but as a maritime nation they have a unique advantage for windpower. Off-shore windpower is far less stochastic than on-shore windpower (see last paragraph for why). So all the problems below are significantly mitigated. In power engineering we're not talking about switches that readers in this forum are more acquainted with (in computer architecture). Currents are in the thousands of amps, not nano, and volts are in the hundreds of thousands (or millions in one Soviet era line). Furthermore the grid is very strict with quality. The frequency must be within a certain tolerance at all times, and no more than a maximum allowed of phase shift in a period of time. The sinusoid must be quite pure, with strict maximums allowed of harmonics. The voltage has to be right. The power has to flow out, not in. Keep in mind that the grid is unforgiving with the python philosophy of asking for forgiveness. A mistake costs millions. Every time you add or remove a load/source the frequency changes, the voltages change, the flows change. To stabilize the grid you have a bulldozer (the throttle) and a little scalpel (capacitor banks). A few jurisdictions are blessed by the engineering gods and have an instrument that works in-between (hydroelectric storage). Now imagine you don't have to slowly integrate a single large and lethargic source in the middle of the night when ppl are sleeping. Instead you have thousands of stochastically generating sources being integrated and removed as the load is changing. The proof are in the prices. Wind power is expensive, but ironically the spot price sometimes drops to negative! Wind power needs a storage revolution. Then most of these problems go away. There is one cavet to all of this, off-shore wind. Since maritime flows are very constant and the relative speed at an interface is zero, offshore wind power if far more reliable and useful the on-shore.