4 ms·
Let's test the title against proposed alternative with one sentence in the article: "even though that flow is unproven in the scientific literature on psychopa
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Let's test the title against proposed alternative with one sentence in the article:
"even though that flow is unproven in the scientific literature on psychopathy"
So, a lot of speculation with no evidence to back it makes the existence of psychopaths a myth. Further, the article intentionally ignores research that supports the existence of people with their alleged traits, even neurological differences. Pop psychology and religious rhetoric are far from the only things that went into it. So, the article's claims are unbalanced, weak, and defeat themselves for now with above quote.
- eric_h 11y agoI thought the article made a good point about the general popular adoption of the ill-defined term 'psychopath', and that the reality of individuals with traits often attributed to psychopaths may not be as clear as they are portrayed in such pop culture representations as e.g. Dexter. My real complaint is that the article seems to have conflated the psychopath with the sociopath. I was under the impression that sociopaths were a superset of psychopaths, with psychopaths being more traditionally "evil" (a la jack the ripper). I do agree that the article's arguments in general are weak, and I don't really see any reasonable conclusion to be drawn from it. At the very least, though, I do find the description of this Gregory character to be interesting and to some extent representative of the small handful of people (~3) I've met in my life who I believed to be sociopaths (admittedly, I'd never heard of those particular individuals running someone over with a car with no remorse or hesitation, but I also believe that had they done such a thing, they wouldn't bring it up in conversation).
- Retra 11y agoI'm pretty sure the medical community at large considers sociopathy and psychopathy to be the same thing, if they are considered at all. 'Traditional evilness' isn't really the kind of symptom a psychiatrist can use.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat point about popular adaption was good. It's clear that what psychologists are debating and what happens on TV are different. Far as sociopath vs psychopath, psychologists tell me they're both mostly pop-psych terms with meanings that vary due to who you're talking to. The only one they mention is Anti-social Personality Disorder. I'm under the impression that they focus more on the potential psychopath's individual traits and less on the categorization itself. I've seen some interesting categorizations which seemed to be there just to have one. They treated the symptoms. He was an interesting character. He exhibited that kind of behavior. Yet, it could easily be his upbringing especially if growing up under and around hustlers. The guy might have never been taught better. So, I call that sort of thing bad character, a bit evil, but not all out psychopath in my book. This may not be everyone, but I tend to associate it with people who clearly have no conscience and seem to compulsively do these things. I've met them and they stand out from the average bad apple. Either the article or a commenter mentioned them getting back at people years later. The inability to let go without doing what they were compelled to do. Many I've met had that trait, too. That's why you figure out what pisses them off and avoid it. Assuming you can't avoid them... (sighs)
- krylon 11y agoOne point the article should have made, IMHO, is that for any kind of personality disorder, it is a continuum, not a discrete true-or-false distinction. A medical doctor can clearly and unambiguously diagnose whether or not you have, say, Type-1-diabetes or a broken leg, there is no wiggle-room, it is not open to interpretation. With personality disorders, the definition is usually a list of symptoms of which a person has to show at least a certain number (e.g. 5 out of 9) to "qualify". But a person that shows, say, 4 out of 9 symptoms of Antisocial Personality Disorder, would still be very unpleasant to be around, even if he or she is not a sociopath from a clinical point of view. (I am making the numbers up to make a point - the actual length of the list and the number of symptoms one has to show for APD is probably different, but not radically so.)
- joe_the_user 11y agoThe strongest argument the authors offer is that psychopath has never been included in the DSM. That's a pretty broad argument but it's fairly "substantial" since the DSM involves a lot of debate and includes a lot of disorders. Plus, what's your evidence the authors are "intentionally ignoring" evidence?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoFar as DSM, that is very significant. Far as evidence, most evidence I've seen were articles written talking about various studies or research in the literature. That's how I get a lot of information outside my field. They talked about case studies on them, some were different from birth, and some were neurologically different than most people in terms of how their brains processed situations. Or were my sources bad and there's nothing supporting the existence of people whose brains seem wired to act with psychopathic traits? It's possible it was misreported given I don't have journal access to most of the publications. If so, I'd also appreciate a good source that survey's the literature on the subject and shows what's learned/unknown.
- xx101010 11y agoYou did not apply the same level of research to a different field. MRI studies, of, for instance, extraordinary criminals are going to show significant differences from ordinary people. That does not mean their brains are not trained that way. And, they did provide evidence, citing at the very start of the blurbs from the book a recent study pointing out evidence that empathy parts of these "sociopath" brains did light up under certain conditions. They simply have more control over them then others. But, so do countless non-criminals who also have to forego ordinary emotions and adrenaline reactions as part of their very civil and very social jobs (like cops, surgeons, soldiers, etc). Anyway, not sure why you would want to dabble in some other fields and expect the same results without equal level of efforts. I have dual studied comp sec and psychology, and in both instances, been focused on theory, sure, but also results. (To stave insanity in one instance, and to make a living and have some fun in the other. Won't say which one is which.)
- xx101010 11y agoThe article did not tell me anything I did not know, and it is most assuredly 'pop psychology'. They did link to the recent study which pointed out even those considered "psychopaths" (anti-social personality disorder) actually are not entirely devoid of the capacity of empathy. As this is a recent study, I won't save people the time to link to it, you should figure this stuff out on your own. But, you should also already know of it, and have recognized it immediately. If you have been doing your homework in this area. If you had not already heard of that study, then you should self-assess your self: why am I looking into this area? What motivates me? Am I truly 'doing my homework', or am I just like a tumbleweed, going from article to article, looking for more which confirms my already pre-existing biases? I will give this link: the Psycopath Test, by Jon Ronson. That is, also, enough to spend two seconds to google. If you really, truly believe in the psychopathy label, then I would strongly encourage you folks who do so to challenge your beliefs" by reading that book. Ronson has a few books out there, and they are all excellent for challenging common conceptions on murky material. I am not saying the article was not generally true. Fact is, it is. But, you can know that it is a myth merely because it is not even in the DSM. As this article points out, nor is anything even like it. It does not point out many important, related matters, however. Like the general public should not even be taking such labels - even if they were in the DSM - and going about doing their own diagnosis of others. And, if they are... why* are they doing this? If you do not know why you are doing this, then isn't that a little more of a pressing mystery to solve... then playing doctor on people who are not even your patents, and whom you probably know little to nothing about? My own interest in this thread, btw, is 'why do otherwise reasonable people believe truly unreasonable things', and 'why do otherwise intelligent people who have strict standards they say they adhere to, not actually use those standards and flagrantly so'. That is very interesting, because it can tell you a lot about your own way of taking in information and help you find errors others have you, your own self, might also have.