4 ms·
I don't like this at all. Even if she wasn't the right person (I don't know), all the worst elements of the site are going to see this as a victory for their a
by MBCook 11y ago
I don't like this at all.
Even if she wasn't the right person (I don't know), all the worst elements of the site are going to see this as a victory for their awful behavior and it's going to get worse.
The people who attacked her with sexism and comments about her personal relationships. The people who supported FPH even though they were attacking people in real life and off Reddit, not just posting comments in their personal corner of 'discussion'.
She didn't do a good job of it, but at least she tried to stand up against some of the worst of Reddit.
I worry heavily that if the new person doesn't draw a clear line at the start things are going to get a lot worse in terms of hate/abuse/harassment.
EDIT: After posting this I saw Nilay Patel tweeted basically the same thing: https://twitter.com/reckless/status/619620964658245632 https://twitter.com/reckless/status/619620964658245632
- caractacus 11y ago> She didn't do a good job of it, but at least she tried to stand up against some of the worst of Reddit. These are two separate things. The fact that she tried to stand up against some of the idiots that inhabit the site doesn't mitigate against the fact that she did not do a good job. She should have resigned or been fired for not doing a good job regardless of how well she coped with the jerks en masse.
- MBCook 11y agoThey're not the same thing, my worry is that some Redditors (or employees) may not pay attention to the difference and avoid further cleanup.
- lingben 11y ago> but at least she tried to stand up against some of the worst of Reddit. I'm baffled at how people misunderstand Ellen's actions in shutting down a few subreddits randomly. She did not 'clean' reddit of the worst of reddit nor 'hate' subreddits. In fact, there are still dozens and dozens of really disgusting stuff on reddit like /r/gasthekikes and /r/coontown Let's please stop this false narrative that she was a champion of some kind who came in and tried to 'clean up' reddit. Not only are there plenty of reprehensible stuff on reddit still, Ellen's claim that she targeted behavior and not speech rang hollow for the majority on reddit because communities like SRS were and are getting away with the same or worse behavior.
- slg 11y agoJust because she didn't completely clean Reddit doesn't mean she didn't attempt to clean some of it or make the decision to do so a bad move. The existence of some bad communities also shouldn't be used as an excuse to keep other bad communities.
- MBCook 11y agoLet's make three categories of things on Reddit. One is innocuous (or relatively so) like /r/knitting or even /r/politics or /r/atheism. Perhaps there are big arguments but in the grand scheme of things it's not bad. Type two is /r/coontown or other hate subs. They're clearly offensive. I wouldn't let them on my site if I ran it, but they exist. The key here is they stay mostly to themselves. I wasn't aware of them before all this. Type 3 are problem subs. Things like /r/FPH. There often offensive, but on top of that they branch out to act in the real world or in other subs. They don't stay confined to their one little corner but actually make things worse for everyone. Never if your topic isn't flat out offensive doxing or causing actual harm fits here. What they did was a small hit against some of category three. It wasn't much, but it's the most I've seen in a long time on Reddit. Given the amount of stuff I've seen in the last year against various people in the games industry in other places, some of that organized on Reddit, I'm happy to see something done. There are still tons of subs in category three that they haven't done anything too. The vast majority of them. And I really don't care about category two things, I'd be fine if I didn't wanted to ban those too. By no means did she clear up Reddit. But at least I saw she tried to do something, dipping her toe into the battle. And I'm worried I'll be back sliding on that.
- pavs 11y agoThere were a lot more banned subreddits and users way before Pao was anywhere in the reddit picture. Its nothing new. The reddit anger towards her was mostly accumulation of cultural change that has been going in reddit management every since Yishan left (also ~30 employees were fired/let go in a very short period) and firing of Victoria just the tipping point. It also helps that Victoria was very well liked. I honestly dont know who is to be blamed for reddit going the shithole but at the end of the day CEO needs to take responsibility.
- ljk 11y agoHe did call redditors out in the announcement though, maybe it'll be alright https://reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cucye/an_old_team_at_reddit/ https://reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cucye/an_old_te... " As a closing note, it was sickening to see some of the things redditors wrote about Ellen. [1] The reduction in compassion that happens when we’re all behind computer screens is not good for the world. People are still people even if there is Internet between you. "
- MBCook 11y agoI hadn't read his post yet, God I'm glad to see that. I hope you're right.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- clavalle 11y agoI think it was the right move for many reasons. Should someone hesitate from making the right move if vile people happen to support that move?
- MBCook 11y agoI think they should have waited for some cool off or had a 'shadow' CEO or announced this at the same time as a big cut off of some of the worst subs. This can easily be interpreted as a repudiation of some of the things she tried to do to clean up the site, and that would be a horrible message to send.
- gjulianm 11y agoThe fact that she "stood up" against some of the worst of Reddit shows that she was not the best suited for the job. Now before I continue, let me clarify that those banned subreddits were awful, as awful as all the threats and insults she received. However, I wonder what was she thinking when she banned those subreddits, specially FPH. They were a bunch of trolls: did she think they were going to just shut up and stop harassing people? Nope, they weren't going to. Moreover, as the ban reasons were not completely clear (they were a bad behavioured sub, but the admins didn't show a clear proof of harassment with support of the mods) some redditors decided to support them, because hating corporate is always cool. A wonderful mix of a big community, with a high percentage of trolls, plus the "free speech" flag, plus the "corporate is destroying Reddit". The result is the chaos that happened in the days after the ban and the obvious damage to her reputation. That was not the better solution to the FPH problem. There were other possibilities. For example, removing them from the front page to cut their growth in the early stages. Or, in the moment the imgur thing happened, issue a clear warning to the mods and tell them that the next offense meant a ban (they could've avoided further harassment or maybe could have banned them without such community backslash, giving the rest of the users a "see? they're bad, we told you, we had no other option" explanation). But even with a bad decision on the FPH ban, she could have survived if it weren't for the /u/chooter thing. A CEO in a delicate position, with part of the community with doubts about her and another part directly hating her... firing an appreciated admin wasn't the best idea at all. I wouldn't have thought it would have created such a big outcry, but it was clear it was going to revive the Ellen Pao hating circlejerk. It was a suicidal move. And, as you say, the bad part of these suicidal moves is not only the hate and the threats she received and the fact that she had to resign, but also the fact that is going to be taken as a victory for the childish trolls of Reddit. Basically, Pao screwed up really bad, and I think she made things worse in the harassment/hate field.
- cthalupa 11y ago>comments about her personal relationships Is it not a relevant comment on her character that she has married someone who (allegedly) defrauded over a hundred million dollars worth of pension funds? That she later sued a company she was fired from over supposed sexism for the exact amount her husband needed for his legal defense fund? That she lost the case miserably due to a complete lack of evidence? (The case against her husband, on the other hand, looks like it will be quite the open and shut case with mountains of evidence) I don't care about reddit at all, but I don't understand how anyone can defend her and her husband after one of them (allegedly) ruined the pension funds of thousands of clients who trusted them, and the other tried to provide him with the funding to get off scot free for the actions. Would you defend Bernie Madoff or someone who had been complicit in trying to keep him unpunished for his crimes?
- LGBT_2000 11y ago> I don't understand how anyone can defend her and her husband after one of them (allegedly) ruined the pension funds of thousands of clients who trusted them This is 2015, I really hope you don't need someone to explain to you that women don't have to share the blame for their husbands (alleged) misdeeds. Disgusting.
- cthalupa 11y agoBased on your comment history I can't tell if you're a troll or just severely misguided. On the off chance that you do legitimately believe this, I'll go ahead and respond. Fundamentally, you misjudge my stance: I don't care Pao's a woman. If I learned that the woman I married had done that to people, I would not stay with them, because I cannot reconcile being married to someone who can do that with my own ethos. That she has speaks volumes of her character. If Pao had committed fraud, and her husband had stayed with her, I would have the same feelings about him. (From your comments, I suppose this is the part where you claim that Male White Nerds on the internet always say that, but never do it, etc.) Second: It's not even just a matter of staying with him, but she has sued a company that turned out to be innocent for sexual discrimination asking for the exact amount in damages that he needs to cover his legal fees. To me, that steps beyond just having suspect character, to outright being complicit in the attempt to prevent him from paying for his crimes. Pao is disgusting, and it has nothing to do with her gender. Only her actions.
- studentrob 11y agoIf Reddit can get back to focusing on positive things, like reddit gifts, admins with good community relations, and not firing people who have cancer, I think they'll be in good shape. If Reddit continues to focus on cracking down on the negativity that exists on the site, it will give the negative voices a bigger stage. I think they will be able to get back to doing positive, fun things, and the negativity will be drowned out.