6 ms·
Well, there's a couple of reasons for it. The main reason is that there is this idea of equal pay for equal work which only works if your work is producing wid
by brightball 11y ago
Well, there's a couple of reasons for it.
The main reason is that there is this idea of equal pay for equal work which only works if your work is producing widgets per hour. That's fine on a manufacturing line, an hourly job, or a job where the variance in performance of a job isn't measurably valuable to a business.
I've got a lot of experience as a programmer/devops guy, but if somebody hired me to setup Wordpress with a template for them I'm not really adding much more value than anybody else who could do the job. From the business perspective, they just want the site to be setup and look nice.
If a company is looking to hire a developer who can both develop the application, help manage the infrastructure and identify programming decisions that are going to cause a negative impact down the line...I'm going to add a lot more value for that business.
But...if my salary at that business was public and you could clearly see on paper that I made more money that another programmer on the team who really felt like he was contributing just as much it's going to cause resentment. The only way to clear up that resentment is for somebody to sit down with said guy and say, "Look, this guy does X, Y and Z and has experience and a track record of identifying problems and preventing us from making expensive mistakes. His salary is based on the value proposition. You are focussed on an area of programming for the app and you do a great job with it."
There's no way to explain it without causing resentment, having another person constantly having to justify themselves, or backhandedly belittling the contributions of another person.
This is essentially why people don't talk about it. Because nobody thinks their work isn't as valuable or their contributions are as valuable as the most valuable people at the company...and they have no way of understanding that without actually doing those people's jobs.
There's not a PC way to say "there's no such thing as equal work" unless your job is so specific, so thoroughly defined and so repetitive that anybody can be plugged in to perform the tasks...and at that point your job doesn't have much value anyway.
- debacle 11y agoThis is completely untrue. People talk about salary in other places of the world very regularly, because it is often public. People don't talk about salary in the US because companies will fire you for it. Edit: See kasey_junk's response and my follow-up.
- kasey_junk 11y agoMost discussions about salary are federally protected in the US and backed up by court decisions in nearly every state. If you get fired for talking about salary you almost certainly can seek redress from the National Labor Relations Board.
- debacle 11y agoYou are completely correct, however I have personally seen two employee handbooks that forbid discussing salary and, living in an at-will state, I'm sure if I discussed salary I would be fired for something completely unrelated.
- kasey_junk 11y agoI have as well and have pointed out that it is probably illegal and potentially opens them to civil liability. I've also seen manager training materials that specifically tell managers not to even hint that salary is a secret topic as the liability involved is problematic. It is one thing to claim that worker protections don't exist, its another to claim that you refuse to take advantage of them.
- kenko 11y agoIt's still true that you have limited practical redress if you're fired (especially in an at-will state).
- dbingham 11y agoI've also seen an employee handbook that forbid salary discussions. When I politely pointed out to them (with references) said statement was illegal, the response I got was very cold.
- wil421 11y agoCompanies usually wouldn't fire you for talking about salary but they will find another reason to fire you for talking about salary. I've seen people get fired for being late to a meeting once. The real reason they got fired was something else but on paper and what they told the person was for being late.
- s73v3r 11y agoI honestly don't see any of that as reason other than, "Talking with people is HARD!"
- fleitz 11y ago"I've got a lot of experience as a programmer/devops guy, but if somebody hired me to setup Wordpress with a template for them I'm not really adding much more value than anybody else who could do the job. From the business perspective, they just want the site to be setup and look nice." Here's the thing you might have experience doing that, I have experience driving revenue and increased sales with websites. I suggest you stop programming, and start driving revenue. Also, I'm highly skilled at increasing employee productivity through automation performance enhancements, such as reducing build time which saves 15 minutes per programmer per day, over 10 programmers, or 912 person hours per year. I'll collect my cheque for $25K for that thank you very much :)
- brightball 11y agoAnd if you can put those numbers in front of a business owner, it's going to pretty much justify higher compensation than me. But should you feel like you have to constantly defend yourself when you know the value you add, the business owner knows the value you add but everybody else looking at the sheet says "He makes HOW much?" NOTE: I honestly don't know why you're getting voted down. I up voted you fwiw.
- fleitz 11y agoI don't know either, c'est la vie. You can't pay rent with upvotes, that's what matters to me.
- polymatter 11y agoBut keeping salaries secret leads to rumour and speculation. How is that better? Especially when you make it so taboo to talk about, it just makes it more exciting. Especially so since you can't hide the externalities. I'll give you an example. When we learnt a girl from finance owned her own horse, the gossip around the office was not how did she skrimp and save, but what she needed to do to whom to receive such an obviously large salary. I have no doubt she did just save her money well but thanks to keeping everyone's salary secret, we have vicious rumours instead of fact. If you are really hiring people who honestly believe that everyone apart from them contribute little to the company, then you are hiring incredibly arrogant people. If you are really hiring people who honestly would be surprised that some people earn more than others, then you are hiring incredibly naive people. fwiw, I earn £27,000 as a C#/Java developer in central London and I know I am extremely poor at salary negotiation so I expect I am grossly underpaid. This causes me resentment. Salary negotiations involve me having to justify myself or backhandedly belittling the contributions of my colleagues. ie. exactly the sorts of problems you believe that keeping salaries secret solves. There is only one reason for keeping salaries secret, and that is to keep wages down. That benefits employers, and it benefits those who are great at negotiating.
- e40 11y agoWhen we learnt a girl from finance owned her own horse, the gossip around the office was not how did she skrimp and save, but what she needed to do to whom to receive such an obviously large salary. I have no doubt she did just save her money well but thanks to keeping everyone's salary secret, we have vicious rumours instead of fact. I'm sorry, but that's just plain stupidity. There are many, many reasons how the woman (I assume, not an actual "girl") would have a horse. The combined income of her and her spouse might have allowed it. It might have been a gift from someone. If your coworkers are using stuff like this as the basis for gossip... you work with some horrible people.
- polymatter 11y agoYou are right I shouldn't refer to a woman in her early 20's as a girl. Its a habit when I thought "girl" meant, woman younger than me. Sorry. Horses are expensive to maintain, even if they are gifted to you for free. But people use all sorts of basis for gossip.