7 ms·
A tale of indie RPG development
- nallerooth 11y agoThanks for an interesting post. I'm impressed by the fact that the developers kept going for ten years, when their first estimate was a lot shorter.
- ido 11y agoI remember the guy already being a running joke on RPG Codex in 2008-2009. Glad to see they managed to eventually release the game!
- louhike 11y agoYes, people tend to underestimate how long it is to do a RPG. I'm currently composing music for a RPG two of my friends are doing in their sparetime. It is in development since 9 years. It is really hard to make it interesting and fun to play. We hope to release a demo this year.
- dameyawn 11y agoWhat game is it?!
- birdsbolt 11y agoThe Age of Decadence.
- dameyawn 11y agoHere you go, found it for you: http://store.steampowered.com/app/230070/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/230070/
- mattmanser 11y agoIt's interesting to read the negative reviews, most of them are so incredibly ridiculous. Several people complain there's not enough content, but each one of them had put 30 odd hours into the game. Almost everyone else is complaining about the difficulty, which the steam page makes clear is a selling point of the game. Bizarre.
- ido 11y agoI've seen steam comments (in other games) complaining about the game being boring & not having enough content made by people with 100+ hours in-game.
- talmand 11y agoIt seems these days comments and ratings are almost useless. I wish the demo would make a big comeback so I can determine whether I like a game for myself.
- danneu 11y agoSteam recently started no-questions-asked refunds which is often better than a demo. http://store.steampowered.com/steam_refunds/ http://store.steampowered.com/steam_refunds/ > You can request a refund for nearly any purchase on Steam > —for any reason. Maybe your PC doesn't meet the hardware > requirements; maybe you bought a game by mistake; maybe > you played the title for an hour and just didn't like it. Been using it successfully. Just can't have more than 2 hours played.
- talmand 11y agoYeah, I know. I'd still rather have a demo. I don't like the idea of using my credit card as a means to demo a game I might be interested in. If a game I wanted doesn't meet my expectations after purchase, then that's a different matter.
- thenomad 11y agoOne of the big things they clearly did right, which when I was in the middle of a half-decade project I did very wrong: they kept communicating. I went dark - stopped blogging, stopped Tweeting - because I figured it was better to spend time on making my thing (the film Death Knight Love Story) than communicating with no deadline in sight. That was a major mistake - "out of sight, out of mind". I'm digging myself out of that hole now, and it's tough. If your project's ETA starts running faster than you can catch it, DO NOT make my mistake :)
- Udo 11y agoThat's an important point. I was immediately reminded of Limit Theory ( http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2015/04/08/mia-limit-theorys-josh-parnell-has-gone-quiet/ http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2015/04/08/mia-limit-theorys... ), where the creator went dark suddenly early this year. I think this might be a psychological hole creators can fall into. Maybe it starts out with them not wanting to communicate, one more time, that the project will take a while. Meanwhile ongoing development has hit rock bottom in term of perceived (or actual) speed. Then former fans start getting anxious, or upset, or leave - and this actually raises the bar you need to pull yourself over in order to start communicating again.
- thenomad 11y agoIt's not just about communicating with your crew, but also your public. If you don't have a fanbase waiting for your work to come out, it'll be much, much, MUCH harder to achieve a successful launch. I'm very good at launches, and even so, I found that the years of silence really eroded the splash I was able to make with my project when I launched it. That's why these days I'm making a point to keep on Twittering, blogging, HNing, and so on, even when stuff is months away from release.
- IronTowerStudio 11y agoI'd say it's nearly impossible. One of the biggest mistakes aspiring indie developers make is that they keep their cards close to their chest. They don't want to spoil the storyline, they don't want to share their ideas because someone might steal them, etc. Well, if you run out of steam because you don't have any support, there will be nothing left to steal and nothing to spoil. You have to share everything. If you tell people that you're making an RPG, nobody would care. If you show everything you have, discuss all your ideas, then people will get interested and will stay with you and support you by giving a fuck - the best kind of support there is.
- DanBC 11y agoWould it have been easier to include modding tools and then releasing earlier?
- erikb 11y agoIf you don't have anything to catch people's interest for some time there's not much reason to add modding support. Modding support is another area of X things you need to add, change, debug, test, adapt to feedback. And without a game in the first place nobody will even look at your modding tools.
- torgoguys 11y agoGreat read. Awesome to read about a decade long resolve to see it through. Instead of Iron Tower Studio, they should have named their company Iron Will Studio.
- erikb 11y agoI'm not so sure. I think it should be possible to get something done with 2-3 people in 3 years, not 10. But before I start a serious attempt I'd certainly want to learn basic things first, like how to make a fighting system. These things are only hard and time consuming when you figure them out the first time. The second or third time you are much faster. One example I have from own experience is that one topic like that for the program I wrote in my thesis: Took me 3-6 months depending on how you count start and end date. But last week I had to do the same thing for another project and it only took me half a day. I didn't need to google anything, I didn't need to compare different variations. I knew what worked, what were the disadvantages of the most common options, choose one in 5 seconds and got it implemented. I didn't run into any of the things that took days to debug in the first attempt, because I knew where the problem areas were. Therefore I would assume that while the first attempt of an RPG for a group of noobs might take a year or three for a prototype, a small team of experienced developers can put together a basic prototype in a few weeks.
- louhike 11y agoThe problem is that a prototype is not equivalent to a real fighting system you will put in a game. You will need a lot of testing so the game is challenging is fun. And it must be challenging and fun during all the game (30+ hours). EDIT: To give an example, see a website. A small website to show some prototype will be quite quick to do. But when you need to do a website used by hundreds to thousands persons with a lot of use case, it gets far more complex.
- erikb 11y agoI'd still disagree but I can see your point. It's not just the basics. A real system needs some things you can't learn from a book.
- gjig 11y agoI agree with your general assessment re: experience, but I wish people would stop talking about these sorts of things in years and months. I understand why it's difficult to express it in hours, but even a very rough estimate of total hours spent is a far, far more useful metric than "years". My personal experience with studying Japanese has been that there's roughly two camps of people: those who become fluent-ish in 1-2 years, and those who know ~100 kanji after 3 years (1-2k for fluency). The primary difference between these two camps is that the former studies 6-8 hours a day, and the latter has Japanese classes thrice a week, that's it. Speaking in hundreds, thousands or tens of thousands of hours gives you a much better idea of what's actually necessary to make the magic happen, and makes it easier to judge how well you're doing: is making barely any progress in 1 week a bad thing, or a really bad thing? That depends on whether a week translates to 3 hours or 50 hours.
- georgeecollins 11y agoAs a professional game developer I have so much respect for people who do things like this out of passion and achieve the miracle of actually shipping. Finishing any game under these circumstances is an accomplishment. This is a huge accomplishment and I hope they are very proud.