14 ms·
'Sin free Facebook' attracts thousands
- vrnut 11y agoThe article seems to be lacking a lot of context about several of the projects it addresses... I don't think it makes sense to namedrop TempleOS as the christian version of linux as much as a project that is very influenced by a particular mental illness.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoYeah, I can't wait for some of the more conservative Christians looking to find a "sin-free" operating system to dig around and start reading some of Terry's more... colorful writings.
- jahnu 11y agoI once worked for a company where due to a customer's religious sensitivities we had to change the name of a service from 'demon' to 'daemon' and remove an icon featuring a cartoonish devil. No big deal, just amusing.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoIsn't "daemon" the traditional spelling for those kinds of services, anyway?
- jahnu 11y agoSure. But I guess that was the joke.
- DanBC 11y agoThat's a common theme for some of the FreeBSD folks. Superstitious Users and the FreeBSD Logo: http://halfblog.net/2011/12/04/daemon-worship/ http://halfblog.net/2011/12/04/daemon-worship/ And the HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3310063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3310063
- humanrebar 11y ago> No big deal, just amusing. Interestingly, there's a passage in the book of Romans about this sort of thing. That's pretty much the right attitude. The relationship with the person is more important than bickering over whether 'demon' is a big deal or not.
- humanrebar 11y ago> I can't wait for some of the more conservative Christians looking to find a "sin-free" operating system to dig around and start reading some of Terry's more... colorful writings. Wait for what? That's more or less me and I've read some of his writings. He looks like a man who struggles with mental illness. What kind of cartoon characters are you imagining people like me behave like?
- pavel_lishin 11y agoHe tends to swear a fair amount, and go off on racist tangents. I realize that it's due to his mental illness, but I was just smiling at the disconnect between someone looking for a nice, sin-free operating system coming across a comment like "Fucken nXXXXr. I judge you, pig. I'm fucken Moses. Suck my mother fucken dick." I'm really sorry if this comes across as making fun of someone's mental illness; that's not my goal.
- humanrebar 11y ago> I'm really sorry if this comes across as making fun of someone's mental illness On the contrary, I got that point, but it seemed like you expected some sort of Hollywood caricature of how conservative Christians behave. A mature Christian would not be surprised by contradiction or hypocrisy, especially if mental illness is involved. Being a good person is not a requirement to be a Christian. In fact, the people with the most obvious problems tend to be the most eager admit their failings and work on their issues. Christ actually had the harshest things to say to the self-righteous. In other words, the Westboro fools are pretty much the opposite of how a Christian is taught to be. In fact, I'd be surprised if some of them don't have mental health issues of their own. I encourage you to read up on Christian theology a bit more, then. And maybe make friends (or a better friends) out of more evangelicals so you can understand them a bit better.
- tessierashpool 11y agoquotes from the TempleOS charter: * God said 640x480 16 color graphics is a covenant like circumcision. * God said to use a single audio voice -- a single frequency with waveforms and, maybe, amplitude envelope. (it's linked in the original, but just in case: http://www.templeos.org/Wb/Doc/Charter.html http://www.templeos.org/Wb/Doc/Charter.html seems he thinks Jesus was a Commodore 64. I'm not into judging people's religions but I will say that's definitely an unusual interpretation of the relevant texts.)
- ggchappell 11y agoAre there good reasons to think that this is supposed to be serious? It all looks very tongue-in-cheek to me.
- zxcvcxz 11y ago>Are there good reasons to thing that this is supposed to be serious? Yes. The lone author is supposedly schizophrenic. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/gods-lonely-programmer http://motherboard.vice.com/read/gods-lonely-programmer If this is all just a joke it's a very elaborate one.
- swasheck 11y agoI can't tell if that's a joke or a legitimately held belief. Reading the rest of the charter (and vaguely from memory), it seems like the developer believed God literally told him about this OS. Also, the KJV-only perspective is misguided given the textual scholarship that renders KJV as somewhat outdated.
- duaneb 11y ago> I don't think it makes sense to namedrop TempleOS as the christian version of linux as much as a project that is very influenced by a particular mental illness. Especially as a) there is at least one "Christian Linux" distro, and b) TempleOS has very, very little in common with linux. Furthermore, in intent, I think it was very much a "Temple Operating System" and not a suitable comparison to an extremely versatile computational platform.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoWhere was it namedropped as a "Christian version of Linux"? Or are you using Linux as a metonym for any free OS in general, in which case that's just wrong.
- mkr-hn 11y agoPhariseesbook > Gay material is also banned from the social media platform. I guess my gay religious friends aren't welcome there.
- bargl 11y agoThis was my first thought as well. Also, christian religions that openly accept homosexuals are banned? That seems more like this is for a subset of Christians and not all Christians.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoNo True Scotsman, etc.
- mkr-hn 11y agoI am not willing to condemn my 100% accepting religious friends because of that guy who shouts at traffic with a megaphone on the weekends.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoNor should you, my point was that any given Christian will have a pretty unique definition of what defines a Christian, who is or isn't "really" Christian, etc. My Lutheran friends have claimed that Catholics aren't Christian; my Methodist ones have made the same claim about Lutherans; and while none of them have come out and said it, I'm sure there's at least a few who believe that 'practicing' gays can't be Christian either.
- innguest 11y agoWhen is it ever about "all Christians"? The whole point of Christianity letting people read the Bible is that it became many-flavored. But you want everyone to be your kind of Christian? Well, how Christian of you. :P Forming any group based on a shared trait is now unPC? A group is defined by those it excludes along with those it includes. You are criticizing a group of people for wanting to be with like-minded people. PS. as an atheist I'm not welcome "there" either and I don't give a crap. Gay people don't give a crap either. But their flag is used by sophists to steer policy. And you are echoing those political efforts.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI don't think these alternate social networks will ever displace Facebook, but instead become the preferred niches. Facebook becomes the bland Starbucks you can find everyone at, even if there's a trendier coffee shop a block away you'd rather go to most days.
- DanAndersen 11y agoPerhaps over time communities like this will lead to a restoration of the "long tail" of online communities. I've found myself less than comforted by the homogenization of communities that can result on one-size-fits-all places like Facebook or Twitter.
- humanrebar 11y ago> I don't think these alternate social networks will ever displace Facebook I think they could. The facebook model rules out certain kinds of very common social interaction. There are certain things you only say or share when you're pretty sure of some privacy (or otherwise drunk). I would argue that there's definitely a need for a network that enables those kinds of interactions even if the demand isn't obvious yet. That being said, I'm not sure "Christian Facebook" encourages or supports those use cases. I'd like to see more discretion-oriented (end-to-end encryption, read-receipts, retracting sent messages, etc.) features on a service that aims to serve Christian use cases.
- 0624213997 11y agoAlso, there are probably many nuances and facets of socialization that have yet to be created, discovered, exaggerated, detailed, organized, etc. Just because most people limit themselves to the physical world of body language, sensory percepts, the electronic-intellectual world of thumbs up, upvotes and personalized walls of media subtypes; that doesn't mean that's the end to socialization. I think there is a lot of potential for creativity to be expressed, to come up with new ways to communicate. The surrealists did automatic drawing with one another, and some folks at Google combined vast quantities of depersonalized data and individuated constructions of layered learning, to create surrealistic like images.
- 11y ago
- paulhauggis 11y agoAt least it's honest. You know exactly what it's all about. Unlike what we have now where you are publicly shamed for your religious beliefs and the people doing the shaming not only deny it, but somehow think it's morally correct.
- lmm 11y agoSome religions are genocidal (probably most of them, if they take their holy books literally). Aren't some political positions sufficiently horrible that it is morally correct to shame people for them? That such a political position is a religious belief should not change how we treat it.
- drivingmenuts 11y agoShaming only works if you can convince the shamed that they are actually wrong instead of being persecuted. The martyr complex is alive and quite well.
- humanrebar 11y agoTo someone who believes in God you cannot choose your god anymore than you can change your race or sexual orientation. There are clear lines to draw around justice issues like violations of human rights, suffrage, freedom of speech, etc. But you're painting with a very broad brush if you think it's morally correct to persecute people for believing in a different (or no or any) God. I would even call it closed minded.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHm. Yet people change religion all the time. Claiming 'no true scotsman' isn't fair. That leaves, people choose God. And we can't call it coincidence that people of one culture mostly choose the same God. Gotta be learned, right? So I'm not buying that line at all.
- humanrebar 11y ago
- sulam 11y ago"thousands!"
- eternalslumber 11y agoI never knew about the association between Perl and Christianity, though I guess a shitty language full of holes and that generally causes arguments and a mess is pretty Christian...
- johnchoban 11y agoPerl is also the 'duct tape of the internet', just like the Church has been to modern society for a millenium.
- eternalslumber 11y agoAre you suggesting that Perl, like duct tape, leaves a horrible sticky residue that takes years to remove?
- brillenfux 11y agoI just realized I don't even shudder at the quality of BBC's "journalism" anymore.
- butterfi 11y agoPutting Perl and TempleOS together is slightly hilarious.
- louithethrid 11y agoBe fruitfull and multiply, and if civil war ensues thus, plausibel deny. Heretic 4.2
- arianvanp 11y agothere's thousands of us. thousands!
- Torgo 11y agoHow strict is their definition of Christian? Do you have to affirm the Athanasian Creed and indivisibility and coeternity of the Trinity as part of the signup process?
- herval 11y agoFor those unaware of the context, there's recently been a huge growth on fundamentalist "christian" religious churches in Brazil. They have their own parliamentary representatives and push the hate speech agenda pretty hard - mainly against other religions, gay people and "communism". In a recent episode, a 10-year old was attacked with stones for wearing typical Candomblé clothes (an afro-brazilian religion). They've also been asking the "flock" to not buy products from companies that advertise for a gay public, and communism in all its forms (some of the leaders consider the government giving money to poor people, be it through social programs or straight cash, "communist depravity"). This specific project gained a lot of steam after Facebook's pride celebration - all the rainbow pictures pushed some folks too hard... Pretty crazy Twilight Zone/Black Mirror material.
- mkr-hn 11y agoI read about this in a piece on the concurrent rise in gaybashing. It's sad to see regressions like this.
- GBond 11y agoPlease don't give the pageview for this bottom feeder level of "journalism".