4 ms·
If you believe Piketty, debt is never meant to be repaid and no one should therefore ever invest in sovereign debt. That would solve the debt debate. No credito
by cm2187 11y ago
If you believe Piketty, debt is never meant to be repaid and no one should therefore ever invest in sovereign debt. That would solve the debt debate. No creditor = no need to worry about whether we want to pile more debt.
And he has a point. I personally don't believe that any of the US, Japanese and European sovereign debt will ever be repaid. The whole thing is a ponzi scheme. Investors hope that their investment will mature before the music stops. That's worth AAA...
- fiatjaf 11y agoIt is not a Ponzi scheme if it is not always and necessarily growing.
- cm2187 11y agoMost western countries can't even afford paying the interest of their debt. So as it is, it is kinda necessarily growing. But the ponzi scheme aspect is rather the fact that countries can only pay back debt with new borrowing. If investors stop rolling their debt, even the US would collapse within a few months.
- NhanH 11y agoI thought the whole premise of modern economics relies on the assumption that the economy has to grow. Time value of money implies that the money has to create value -- in more specific term, if bank lend out $100 and want $102 back, without the economy growing the money supply can't have the extra $2 (printing more money without the economy growing cause inflation, then the bank will want more than $2 interest and it's the same, so we can ignore that).
- haberman 11y ago> Most western countries can't even afford paying the interest of their debt. If that were true, the countries would be in default. And yet they are not.
- cm2187 11y agoFrance for instance has a primary deficit: https://sdw.ecb.europa.eu/quickview.do?SERIES_KEY=325.GFS.A.N.FR.W0.S13.S1._Z.B.B9P._Z._Z._Z.XDC._Z.S.V.N._T https://sdw.ecb.europa.eu/quickview.do?SERIES_KEY=325.GFS.A.... I.e. the state budget is in deficit even before the interest on the debt. So it borrows just to repay the interest plus that primary deficit. These countries are not in default but they are definitely broke and reliant on debt to an insane level.
- fiatjaf 11y agoI agree that almost all countries in the world are in an insane situation, but that's still not a Ponzi scheme. They can repay the debt if they want, they have other sources of income other than loans -- and these are still much larger than these loans they take every year plus interest --, namely their taxpayers pockets. I agree that this is not good, not fair, and that it should be a crime to get other people's money like that, but it is not a Ponzi scheme.
- cm2187 11y agoThey cannot repay this debt. France debt to gdp is reaching 100%. They cannot even gather the political steam to stop increasing their debt, and they have a pension wall coming their way, an ageing population, an increasingly illiterate and unemployed youth. This debt will never be repaid. And like all individuals who keep borrowing more to sustain their life style, and who use the credit card to repay the interest on their loan, it stops when creditors loose trust in them and stop bringing fresh money. And then it collapses. It is an almost identical mechanism than a ponzi scheme.
- Phil_Latio 11y agoA GDP growth of 0%, let alone "negative growth" is considered a disaster for any country.
- Tycho 11y agoWouldn't that be a pyramid scheme? A ponzi scheme is fine as long as everyone doesn't want their principal back at once.
- contingencies 11y agoThere are multiple ponzi schemes here: first and foremost the very idea of nations (victim: the individuals), then that of centrally issued money (victim: the individuals), then that of a regional zone of political unity built upon these established ponzi schemes (victim: the individual's already questionable right to self-determination through their 'nations'), and finally that of the global economy' incorporating other major examples such systems - chiefly the US and China (victim: the planet). One can scream "debt must be repaid!" while running limited liability companies that can declare bankruptcy and allow them to walk away, in countries where political will can be bought on the open market, and media is openly dominated and subtly influenced by corporate and political contributions and donations, all while the global environment suffers and we are soon to have serious issues meeting even our basic human needs like fresh air and water. One may even consider oneself to be 'right' in doing so, however, one is also ignorant of a wider truth. What we really need here are some proposals for alternatives, and some people willing to try them - such as Greece.
- adventured 11y agoIt's interesting that Piketty is advocating perpetual debt slavery for the people he pretends to champion the most: the non-rich. It's not the 0.1% that need worry about nations taking on ever increasing debt burdens, and the pressure the interest puts on budgets (including entitlement and welfare systems). It's everyone else that will be crushed by it.
- cm2187 11y agoIt might not be the 0.1% but it is certainly the 10% or 20% that should worry. Savings and pensions will be wiped out. One can find comfort in physical assets (property, gold) but the history of Europe and of the US tells us that it is easy to get expropriated (all property in the communist bloc, gold in the US, property in Germany after the war, etc...).
- parasubvert 11y agoI'm not sure we read the same interview. Piketty called for debt relief across the board in Europe. Debt jubilees are a thing throughout history. Similar to the ending of Fight Club, but voluntary and without the bombs.
- Spooky23 11y agoIt's not a Ponzi scheme. As long as investors have confidence in the faith and credit of the debtor to meet the contract, we're good. Otherwise, the debtor will just ship pallets of printed currency to the creditors.
- Mikeb85 11y ago> The whole thing is a ponzi scheme. It absolutely is. If you think of money as units of labour instead of 'wealth', it makes more sense. Every year, more people are born, the workforce grows, more things are produced, more food is eaten, etc... The money supply has to reflect that there's always more of everything. This means inflation. And it's not a bad thing.
- tomp 11y ago> The money supply has to reflect that there's always more of everything. This means inflation. And it's not a bad thing. Wait, what?! You don't understand inflation. If there was always "more of everything", the result would be deflation. More food -> food costs less. More cars -> cars cost less. More apartments -> apartments cost less. Economics 101.
- Mikeb85 11y agoYou're forgetting that, as part of more 'everything', that also means more consumers, and more money printed...
- tcbawo 11y agoHistorically, a small amount of inflation has been beneficial. Nobody likes to take a wage cut. Also, even a small amount of deflation quickly makes debt repayment unsustainable. It's hard to repay your loan when you're taking in less money. Greece will never get out of this cycle until it's economy picks up.
- tomp 11y agoThat's not a problem for as long as you can print money (and are willing to suffer from high inflation).