5 ms·
I suspect Pao is right. Most people who use reddit won't care about this. It's very easy to get in a Silicon Valley bubble thinking this stuff matters. EDIT: D
by jgrahamc 11y ago
I suspect Pao is right. Most people who use reddit won't care about this. It's very easy to get in a Silicon Valley bubble thinking this stuff matters.
EDIT: Downvoting me as a way of saying "I disagree" is immature.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoMost likely the lurkers don't care, but if a majority of mods or content producers care it could be a serious issue. Content producers are a tiny minority of the site and mods are a tiny minority of that.
- sappapp 11y agoMy thoughts exactly. The vocal minority are those that produce content and keep the site going.
- zzleeper 11y agoTrue. But there is a large overlap between those that do care and those that create content, vote, comment, and are mods. Thus, you are alienating exactly the class of users that you don't want to.
- kumarm 11y agoI am a heavy reddit user and think Moderators acted immature. Remember just like mods have an issue with administrators, Many subreddit users have issues with moderators :). I am surprised this didn't come up.
- trynumber9 11y agoPao is right, if only because the majority of reddit users don't have an account. These people are simply annoyed by all the non and meta content. But who expects a tick to care about the health of deer?
- fizzbatter 11y agoI think it's a question of "important" users. If enough content mods and creators leave, will there be enough to fill the role immediately? If not - i imagine it will be pretty visible to people on the fence, which will only snowball more. Just as with Digg, this can happen quite fast, and i think a snowball is the only true way this would happen. With that said, i think the most important part of the equation will be another "player". If voat.co (or others) are not able to handle the immediate traffic, then i think it's much less likely to succeed. Reddit had a lot of troubles handling Diggs load, but they managed overall. Voat has been taken down multiple times due to Reddit's against-user actions - so it doesn't seem likely that Voat will be able to handle the traffic when Reddit users need/want it most. Personally i'm hoping someone can find a way to distribute this whole social content idea - but in a UX friendly, web based way. I don't think Voat, or anyone else, will be able to handle taking in the Reddit userbase without falling into the same pitfalls as Digg and Reddit. Something decentralized seems like the only solution.
- berberous 11y agoShe's right that, as a lurker, I don't really care. But it seems like all of the moderators and content contributors do, and if they leave, what does it matter what the lurkers think?
- mreiland 11y agoby content contributes you mean the people who take 30 seconds posting a link, right? Or the ones who game the system for karma? Very few people create content for reddit, they re-post shit the way they would on something like their facebook wall.
- vidarh 11y agoMost people would not have cared about the original firing, but many more do care about the way it was handled. She should also not underestimate how quickly Reddit latches on to these kind of memes even when people might not personally care so much. That she's already widely known around Reddit as Chairman Pao is not exactly a good sign.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- waterlesscloud 11y ago"EDIT: Downvoting me as a way of saying "I disagree" is immature." Downvoting for disagreement is officially sanctioned on this site. It's annoying, but that's how it is.
- madez 11y agoIf HN wanted to reserve Downvotes for something else than the opposite of an upvote, they shouldn't be graphically represented and placed and summed with upvotes like they are now.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoI've complained about the culture that results from using downvotes for disagreement a number of times. I get zero response from the mods and numerous downvotes for my troubles. I'm done fighting it. I just downvote anything I even slightly disagree with and move on. It's what the mods apparently want.
- oldmanjay 11y agoIt's interesting that you see no room for nuance in the mod system. Definitely doesn't need to work the way you're expressing it here. In particular, your petulant tone makes me think you wield downvotes vengefully. Downvotes work best with an emotionally mature community. Fortunately HN seems mature enough that discussion never really go off the rails, individuals with your attitude notwithstanding.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoDownvotes derail conversations here several times a day, your condescending tone notwithstanding. Apparently everyone is fine with that. So I see no reason not to be myself.
- DanBC 11y agoIt's something that gets frequently discussed on HN. You might want to look back over the gajillion threads about it.
- frostmatthew 11y ago> EDIT: Downvoting me as a way of saying "I disagree" is immature. Paul Graham has said he thinks it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement[1] Also, you may want to familiarize yourself with HN's guidelines, which state Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.[2] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html