6 ms·
The Man Who Saw America
- adventured 11y ago"In other countries you don’t feel they’re so proud of their flag" I always find it fascinating when Europeans point this out. The pride - plenty of which may now just be mimicry - didn't derive from a flag, it originally derived from the ideas the flag represented. The flag represented ideals of liberty to most Americans - that's what people had pride in, the premise that their country represented something good (and I'm not arguing here whether it did or not). The other thing I find interesting about it, in my personal experience, I rarely run across Europeans online that aren't smug about something or another they supposedly best America at. Whether it's touting Scandinavia, universal healthcare, free education, lower crime rates, et al. It's almost a cliche to see things like: I live in Sweden, and here's why we're better. I see non-stop pride, arrogance, smugness pouring out of Europe, and I fail to see how it's any different than the pride Europeans see that Americans have in their flag. Frank puts his pride on display numerous times in the article, no different than an American might: - "just amazed how well organized everything is, how perfect everything is" - "they [the Swiss] have everything they need. They don't believe in wishing wells." I mean wow, if that's not boastful pride talking I don't know what is.
- smhenderson 11y agoAnd on that note, happy Independence Day America!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- andresmanz 11y agoWell organized and perfect. I'd like to live in that Switzerland he's talking about. And I've seen enough people here who believe in wishing wells. Yes, we have everything we need and everything here is fucking expensive. And yet we're not happy and _do_ believe in wishing wells because, you know, you shouldn't just be happy and satisfied. You'll always find someone moaning here, and then you'll laugh because of the reason for that. Oh, and the pride thing... Yes, many Swiss people are very proud of being Swiss. Even if they didn't do anything for being here. If you publicly state that you're not proud of being Swiss, they'll chase you with hay forks. At least sometimes I'm getting the impression.
- veb 11y agoIn New Zealand recently, there's been a 'debate' on whether or not we should change the flag. They've spent... $26 million on this so far, and yeah the populace is discussing it and such, but the funniest thing I hear most often is: "who the fuck cares?! it's a flag!" Probably why they want to change it, to make it more "Kiwi" 'cos right now it's pretty similar to the Australian flag, and feels more "commonwealth" than an Independent blah blah boring nation. I'm still confused as to why Americans love their flag. That said, I don't think I've ever met anyone who fits the 'non-stop pride, arrogance and smugness pouring out of Europe' 'cos that sure would be awful. At least the American flag just breezes around without annoying anyone. Personally, I think it's nice that people have passion/pride for their nation.
- ams6110 11y agoI've never seen any country or people with more pride in their flag than Denmark. Go to any Danish wedding, birthday, holiday party, anything... the Danish flag is everywhere. They decorate their Christmas trees with it the way an American might use tinsel. I've never seen anything like it in America, except at Independence Day or political campaign functions.
- teddyh 11y agoI’ve heard it explained as a remnant of World War II. During the Nazi German occupation of Denmark, the Danish flag was forbidden. It became a resistance hobby to sneak in the simple red-white-red colors into anything and everything, and of course when the war and occupation ended people could celebrate easily and powerfully simply by having the previously-forbidden Danish flag draped over absolutely everything, and this is the behavior which remains – the Danish flag has, by now, become a simple traditional part of many things, and there no good reason to remove it, so it continues to be present at every conceivable occasion. Or so I have been told – I am not a Dane.
- mslot 11y agoThis talk explains the difference between a good flag and a bad flag quite nicely: https://www.ted.com/talks/roman_mars_why_city_flags_may_be_the_worst_designed_thing_you_ve_never_noticed?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/roman_mars_why_city_flags_may_be_t...
- bkjelden 11y agoI've found something a little different: Americans who berate America at every chance they get, always pointing out how Europeans have solved Problem X and we are so dumb for not adopting their simple solutions. Of course, one only needs to look at what is currently happening in the eurozone to realize Europe isn't perfect either. The reality is that problems that may look the same on the surface have nuances that make them very different in Europe and America, and there are a lot of smart people working to solve them on both sides of the Atlantic.
- teddyh 11y agoA European perspective: From about the 1950’s to the 1990’s, the USA was seen as the best place on Earth to be, bar none. It was viewed as having the biggest and best (for some definition of “best”) of everything (military, industry, products, culture), and was seen as being committed to an almost Google-like “don’t be evil” policy. Sure, there were exceptions, and individuals (and their administrations) were criticized, but they were seen as exceptions to a general good principle. The American national pride was seen as a little over the top (especially the slightly creepy “pledge of allegiance” school ritual) but not completely out of the realm of the concievable, and a bit understandable given the USA’s status. Then Bush, Iraq, and 9/11 happened, and the resulting PATRIOT act, TSA, NSA, etc. Many were of course disillusioned with the USA before this (Washington Papers, CIA, etc.), but I think this was the point at which the view of the European general public shifted. It was suddenly OK to express suspicion about the USA’s motives in public discourse, in a way which would have seemed tinfoil-hat-ish or far-left-extremist before. Now I can come to the point: The national pride of US citizens does not seem to have softened or changed. On the contrary, it seems to have hardened in the face of opposition. This, I feel, is the real emotional reason which Europeans have, to denigrate the USA at seemingly every opportunity: They feel that US citizens are far too proud of the USA when it has far too many flaws, and that Americans need to be put in their place, so to speak – taken down a notch. I confess that I personally have occasionally succumbed to this way of thinking, especially when Americans have been proud of (or at least content with) specific things which are really not very good at all compared to other nations. I do not excuse this behavior, I am merely trying to explain it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mercer 11y ago> The pride - plenty of which may now just be mimicry - didn't derive from a flag, it originally derived from the ideas the flag represented. I suspect the whole point is that a symbol has replaced the values and ideals it is supposed to represent, and that this extra step makes everything 'murkier'. Being proud of specific things like universal health care or free education makes a lot more sense than being proud of a flag that indirectly might represent these things, mainly because it's easier to discuss these specifics. That said, when it comes to actual pride I agree that many Europeans are very proud of 'Europe' and/or their country, and sometimes there's more than a little hypocrisy in the way we judge the USA.
- hudibras 11y agoI have a copy of The Americans on the table in my office. I can't count the number of times visitors have idly started flipping through it, only to get mesmerized and ask to borrow it. It's an amazing work of art that only gets better with age.
- tokenadult 11y agoThis 2009 NPR story about Robert Frank and his book of photographs The Americans is also interesting: http://www.npr.org/2009/02/13/100688154/americans-the-book-that-changed-photography http://www.npr.org/2009/02/13/100688154/americans-the-book-t... "The Americans showed a different America than the wholesome, nonconfrontational photo essays offered in some popular magazines. Frank's subjects weren't necessarily living the American dream of the 1950s: They were factory workers in Detroit, transvestites in New York, black passengers on a segregated trolley in New Orleans. Frank didn't even get much support from the art world, he recalls. "'The Museum of Modern Art wouldn't even sell the book,' Frank says. 'But the younger people caught on.'"
- djloche 11y agoA question that's been on my mind all day after I read this column: Do you think this type/quality of photography work is possible to attain such fame now? The proliferation of cameras in the time since the mid-20th century has been significant. I don't doubt that there are quality photos still being taken, however, I wonder how many significant, impactful collections like this are no longer being created because the photographer selected their 50-100 best photos from a trip or project (as best as they could tell on their 13" laptop, and then uploaded them to their facebook page, flickr, blog, or wherever, saw a few hundred likes/favs, and then moved on to their next shoot.