2 ms·
> They could see my order at BATS, race me to the next exchange, and cancel all their sell orders and buy whatever is left, buy everything up, then turn around
by kasey_junk 11y ago
> They could see my order at BATS, race me to the next exchange, and cancel all their sell orders and buy whatever is left, buy everything up, then turn around and try and sell stock back to me at a higher price. So that was the game.
This is the heart of the problem with IEX's explanation of the markets, and why I think most people view HFT as unfair. But its not how cross exchange market making actually works. The HFTs are not rushing to buy up existing inventory from others who are selling it, in an attempt to screw others. They are the ones who are originally offering to sell it in the first place. They aren't rushing to buy, they are rushing to change the price of their inventory.
The metaphor I like to use is that of a chain of gas stations running down a highway, owned by the same people. If a tanker truck pulls up at the first two and buys up all their gasoline, it would be perfectly reasonable for those first 2 to call ahead to the rest down the highway and tell them to raise their prices, as they clearly were being used to supply someone else's industry at lower prices than they should.
That phone call is what IEX prevents, so that their customers (guys with big tanker trucks) can buy gas without impacting the price of gasoline.
- bloateddevtards 11y agoWhatever the realities of the market, people have an expectation of "fairness", and are generally against the idea of a party or parties being able to insert themselves into a situation where they can essentially get a speed jump over the rest of the market by virtue of buying a place that enables this (microwave links, colo in the exchange etc.)
- digikata 11y agoWhy would a HFT maintain a huge inventory of stocks? If you make money on the ability to execute trades faster than others on the movement of stocks, you're losing money by holding them. It feels akin to a car maker holding an overlarge inventory of parts - it's just tied up capital that's not making you money. In HFT, don't you maximize the profit by holding as few stocks for a little is possible?
- kasey_junk 11y agoThe short answer is that they have to. Resting orders from yesterday are always faster than microsecond orders from right now. So a market maker that was super fast but didn't rest orders, would be competing with one that is as fast as them and willing to rest orders. So, the resting order ones win and drive out the non-resting order ones.
- joesmo 11y agoWhether or not HFTs are rushing to buy the stocks or they have the stocks already, doesn't change the fact that proximity to the data center allows HFTs an unfair advantage. It's unfair either way.
- kasey_junk 11y agoSomeone always has and always will have closer proximity to an exchange. You'll notice IEX is hosted in a large exchange centric data center and allows colocation as well. This proximity is actually cheaper, more standardized and easier to access now than it's ever been.
- joesmo 11y agoThat also doesn't change the fact that it's an unfair advantage.
- kasey_junk 11y agoWhy not? Anyone can pay for colocation & it's cheaper than ever. Do you really mean it's not free?