7 ms·
Are EV certificates worth it? A technical guide to SSL validation
- nailer 11y agoEDIT: here's an answer for Zokier's excellent question (I'm rate limited right now): > Does the EV certification process put any requirements on the CA, such as mandatory independent audits or some other overwatch mechanism? The EV Requirements themselves do not. However Google required since Jan 1 2015 that ALL EV certificates have certificate transparency enabled. See the links in the article - I've tweaked it a little to directly address your point too. Certificate Transparency makes it much harder for a CA to issue a certificate for someone else's keypair in your name. ------------ Original response below: Hi there, author here. I hope you don't mind the foul language but I couldn't convey the general feeling towards CAs at EdgeConf much better. This is by no means a replacement for reading the EV requirements (and baseline requirements) but does capture the typical validation process for all the (around 30) EV certificates we've been involved in so far.
- jon-wood 11y agoI'd be really curious to see some numbers on not the technical side, but the human side. In the past I've chosen not to buy EV certs not because the process is more involved, but because it just doesn't seem worth the extra cost - I've never heard of someone choosing not to do business because a site had the wrong kind of SSL certificate. Most people would probably put their credit card details into a completely unencrypted website given half a chance.
- nailer 11y agonod what you really want is someone like usertesting.com to do this, ie, interested in conversion rates, not selling certificates. This hasn't happened with EV yet, but it did happen with 'site seals' - those images (or in Symantec's case Flash objects) that promote a particular certificate brand in a web page. CertSimple sells certs that come with a DigiCert 'site seals' but I'll happily tell you that usertesting tested CRO with site seals a little while ago and found out that, in one case, removing 'site seals' completely was better for conversion - apparently reminding people they're not being hacked doesn't inspire confidence. Let me know and I'll dig up the event recording. I feel EV is a different situation - it's the only chrome displayed by the actual browser concerning identity of a website (which as we know is not the same ting as the origin). But I don't have numbers to say and I shouldn't be the one to conduct the research since I'm clearly biased.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoThis might be an unfair question: Do you see the cost of EV certificates coming down in the future, or is that level of cost actually required due to how involved validation is? For a lot of SMBs and individuals it is hard to justify additional $150 a EV certificate costs. Plus the loss of convenience that wildcard DV certificates provide (and EV certificates cannot). I like the concept of EV, but unless I was running a large company with deep pockets or was in a sector where EV is helping (e.g. finance/payments/etc) then I'd just skip it. I'm not even sure it helps mitigate phishing.
- nailer 11y agoEssentially the cost of EV is the cost of validation. As time goes on, and as there are more CAs, I suspect the competition will increase and the price of EV will go down. However, the current per-year price of EV is less than a half day's work by an average programmer. I'm not necessary sure that's out of the question for most businesses.
- andygambles 11y agoWe went 100% SSL years ago and EV. Conversions increased over 30%. However we do sell Certs so that probably helped. What did reduce was the "are you legit questions".
- ademarre 11y agoI tend to think that if EV had a measurably positive impact on conversion, the CAs would have provided reliable data to back it up by now.
- blibble 11y agosummary of article: no... assuming you've got £15 to set up a company (such as the pirate one in the article), and £149 for a cert, anyone can have one
- nailer 11y agoThat's not an accurate summary. The certificate is that you're at that company: only someone with sufficient authority in that specific company can acquire a certificate saying you're that company. As the article mentions, that not to say there isn't flaws in the process. But most attacks against EV have come in the form of DV downgrades rather than falsely issued EV certificates. Actually, if you have info on any falsely issued EV certificates I'd be really interested.
- blibble 11y agoright, so if I have £15, I can pay £15 to Companies House to start a company, and then I can authorise anything. EV offers nothing over normal certs, other than the company name and the green bar, and I can control the company name if I have another £15...
- nailer 11y agoYou can authorise a certificate only for the company you just created, which is most definitely not 'anything'
- sbierwagen 11y agoWhat stops a Russian EV cert vendor for authorizing a EV cert for impostor company Example LLC, when the real corp is Example Inc?
- nailer 11y ago> What stops a Russian EV cert vendor for authorizing a EV cert for impostor company Example LLC, when the real corp is Example Inc? - The Registry of Companies & Intellectual Property in Russia must accept Example LLC as a valid business name which may be difficult if Example Inc was well known. - The issuing CA must manually inspect all requested domain names in the EV cert and ensure there is no phishing attempt. A certificate request for the hostname 'example.com.example.ru' would be rejected. Depending on how well known Example Inc is - eg, say they were Bank of America - even 'example.ru' may be rejected. - If for some reason this failed and a certificate for the identically named Russian company was issued, it would read 'Example LLC [RU]' in the address bar rather than 'Example Inc [US]'
- finnn 11y agoObligatory comment pointing out that SSL certificates are a racket and it's appalling that we have to pay for an SSL certificate.
- brobinson 11y agoIf you're okay with not having "authenticated pulls" (i.e., the request from the CF edge to your server being unencrypted), Cloudflare gives you SSL for free. Their SSL config gets an A+ on SSLLabs tester, too. Far from a solution to the SSL problem, but an interesting and free option for a lot of sites that otherwise would not bother with SSL.
- 0x0 11y agoBut then you end up visibly sharing a certificate with "nigerian-prince.com" - http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2015/03/23/ted_cruz_presidential_campaign_weird_tech_moments.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2015/03/23/ted_cruz_...
- brobinson 11y agoThis is great. I guess that is indeed a con of the CF approach!
- MichaelGG 11y agoI wonder why Cloudflare doesn't sign certs for their users to be used just for CF connecting to them. Seems like an obvious step to take.
- brobinson 11y agoThat would go against their "setup only takes five minutes!" mantra. It's an interesting idea, though.
- jlgaddis 11y agoThey do. It's a part of their "Universal SSL" [0] called "Strict Mode". [0]: https://blog.cloudflare.com/universal-ssl-encryption-all-the-way-to-the-origin-for-free/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/universal-ssl-encryption-all-the...
- finnn 11y agoAny info on how the /companies API collects data? eg https://certsimple.com/companies?legal-name=testing&country-code=US https://certsimple.com/companies?legal-name=testing&country-...
- zokier 11y agoThat sounds all great and fancy, but one quite critical piece is missing: the ability to trust CA's. I'm frankly somewhat impressed at the level of diligence described in the article, if it is really what happens for each and every EV cert from every CA. But the cynic in me finds it it difficult to trust that that would be the case. Does the EV certification process put any requirements on the CA, such as mandatory independent audits or some other overwatch mechanism?
- jamiesonbecker 11y agoEV is simply a signal that the website is backed by a real company. Even if you can't trust the CA's to always do a good job (there are too many instances of CA's really doing the opposite), they still don't give them away for free. To get one, you have to be prepared to spend hundreds of dollars on top of the typical incorporation and startup costs, so at least you can trust that someone actually ponied up for the certificate cost itself, incorporated, and maintains that incorporation in good standing. We bought EV for https://Userify.com https://Userify.com even though we're a startup, because it demonstrates our level of commitment to security and that we're serious in the marketplace. We also use a wildcard TLS certificate for customer-specific logins. EV-TLS also fights phishing attacks. It's somewhat shocking that AWS doesn't use EV-TLS for the console login, especially when they're so good about other things (like searching for customer keys on Github, watching for phishing exploits, etc.)
- twistedpair 11y agoAmazon is known to pinch pennies. Anything Jeff can do to save a few grand.
- huxley 11y agoIn case anyone was confused and thought you had a Wildcard EV certificate for subdomains/customer-specific logins, that (still) isn't possible, what you probably meant was that you have a regular wildcard certificate for the subdomains in addition to the EV certificate for your primary domain.
- 11y ago
- itengelhardt 11y agoSuggestion to the author: I could really benefit from a short sentence that explains to me what DV means. I get from the context that EV likely means "Extended Validation". Then again, all I ever did was set up SSL on Heroku and a bit of openssl magic to get Github running - so maybe not the target for the article? Edit for clarification: There is a short description of DV & EV, but it doesn't mention what DV/EV stands for. I'd love to know that (without Googling, because lazy).
- perfTerm 11y agoI think it's Domain Validation.
- jlgaddis 11y agoAs perfTerm noted, DV stands for Domain Validation. DV is where, basically, you prove ("validate") that you own the domain you're requesting a certificate for, typically by being able to receive an e-mail sent to one of the contacts listed in WHOIS for the domain. This is similar to Google requiring you to create a file in the root directory of a web site or creating a TXT RR (with a specific value) in the DNS zone for a domain for Google Analytics (if you've ever done that).
- jamiesonbecker 11y agoEV-SSL is a browser signal and is not usually visible on mobile, so it will probably have decreasing importance over time.
- iLoch 11y agoWhen EV is used, iOS ONLY shows the EV information - not the URL - in the address bar.
- jamiesonbecker 11y agoGood to know. Android shows green URL, not EV.
- hackuser 11y ago> When EV is used, iOS ONLY shows the EV information - not the URL - in the address bar. I expect only a tiny portion of users understands this.
- nadams 11y agoFrom the average user's POV: no They won't know the difference between a lock and a green bar. I would bet a percentage of users don't even notice if they are browsing an site using SSL or even understand why HTTP without SSL is bad. This was proven with tools like Firesheep where people are more than happy to browse facebook on an open wifi connection without using SSL. I know I saw a discussion with the Chrome team talking about showing an error-like page for all non HTTPS traffic. This is not the solution - the solution is to show some sort of message to the user that is non-blocking that says "hey your information is sent in the clear". Also - change the self-signed SSL to not look like an error page. Using self-signed SSL is more secure than not using SSL at all - even if the certificate isn't verified your data over the wire is encrypted.
- netheril96 11y agoI am a Chinese and here most websites don't even use TLS to encrypt the login page, let alone the whole websites. No one bats an eye. Every time I raise the issue it was just met with indifference. At least browsing Facebook in open wifi (several years ago) leaked only the cookies not the password.
- hackuser 11y ago> They won't know the difference between a lock and a green bar. I would bet a percentage of users don't even notice if they are browsing an site using SSL or even understand why HTTP without SSL is bad. I would bet this percentage is much higher than many people here think. Most people have no idea what "http" means, or even what a protocol is or why they would need one, much less URLs, HTTPS, SSL certs, encryption, identity, validation, etc. Many users whom I observe don't understand the URL field. If they want to load http://cnn.com http://cnn.com, they type "cnn" into the Google search field and click the first link -- for sites they regularly visit, every time, multiple times per day! Many don't know what a web browser is. [1] The idea that they will grasp EV certs, and all knowledge required for that it (certs, issuers, identity, encryption, what does encryption have to do with identity, etc etc etc) seems very unlikely. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4MwTvtyrUQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4MwTvtyrUQ
- 11y ago
- samgranieri 11y agoTechnically I'd say no. I had to apply for one when I was the lead software developer at a healthcare startup two years ago, and it was more involved. My boss had to submit a bunch of paperwork.
- raesene9 11y agoHere's the thing, the reason EV SSL certificates aren't a good purchase is nothing to do with the technicalities of the matter. It has to do with "will users trust my site more if they see an EV cert" And the answer to that (IMHO) is, no, definitely not. Most users don't even notice when a site goes from HTTPS to HTTP, the chances that they will notice the difference between the display of an EV cert. and a DV cert. is negligable. Ask yourself this, can you list the sites that you visit that use EV certs? If you can't, what's the chances your users will....
- te_chris 11y agoProve that they don't.
- marcosdumay 11y agoWell, my bank uses an EV cert. That's one of the few that matter. Of the last few sites where I brought something, most use a DV cert. I always check that, but I don't mind them not having an EV (I only mind plain text and bad crypto). Of course, I don't want to imply that my behavior is typical, because it's not. I'm just answering your question...