5 ms·
Why the Dutch oppose windmills
- paublyrne 11y agoI often (maybe once a month) buy the Economist in print, because it is a good read, whether or not you agree with all their opinions, and is genuinely global in its scope. I once had a print subscription but didn't have time read an issue each week. I don't have an online subscription now, which makes Hacker News submissions for Economist articles are a little problematic. I wouldn't mind knowing why the Dutch oppose windmills.
- nederdirk 11y agoBottom line (according to the article): The Netherlands is quite densely populated, so every wind turbine is bound to be in someone's backyard. Last paragraph explains that more than 70% of the population is in favor of more wind energy, but many people don't like the face of large windmill parks.
- creshal 11y agoThe area is also quite flat, so they're visible from miles away and stick out like sore thumbs. Personally I don't mind – I grew up near the Dutch border, our village was surrounded with windmills in the early 00s, can't say it ever bothered me, even though they were constantly in view (and while not in our backyard, some were quite close).
- paublyrne 11y agoThanks.
- tikumo 11y agoAs a dutch guy, i can agree with this. Lots of people complain about the flickering you get from windmills for example. Only one province is full of windmills, because it is mainly agriculture, cows and flowers, it is called Flevoland and it is the piece of land we gained from "poldering", the old South "sea" (it was named Zuiderzee) we've made into land..
- krzyk 11y agoStrange, that they call it densely populated, it's quite average for a European country. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_and_population_of_European_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_and_population_of_Europea...
- duckmysick 11y agoOn the list you linked Netherlands is ranked 8th out of 54 countries. I wouldn't call that "average". Besides, the first seven countries on that list are small. Four are microstates and the other three are British dependencies. I'd say, for it's size, Netherlands is densely populated.
- krzyk 11y agoYes, you are right. Sorry I once again mistaken Dutch people as the ones living in Denmark. Now it makes much more sense, once again sorry for confusion.
- jacquesm 11y agoIt's actually a bit different than what you'd get from that table. NL (like most countries) has varying population density. What's not obvious is that NL has a crazy distribution where we have a large chunk (the 'Randstad') that contains a very large portion of the population and a relatively much larger area that is just about empty. So depending on where you are you can travel for 150 Km and never leave the built-up areas or you can travel for 150 Km and you'll see nothing but grass, cows, the occasional farm and the highway you're on (A6/A7).
- gbtw 11y agoUnfortunately the distribution is not optimal for economic reasons. I live in a village (Zoetermeer) (123 000 people) with an density of 9000 people per square mile. Is not uncommon for these densities in the Randstad, where the avarage density over this area is around 4000 per square mile. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad
- 11y ago
- stinos 11y agoSure it is densely populated, but doesn't the major part of that density reside in cities and villages, while once you get outside of those there are vast amounts of land with only some farms?? As such, are they really always in one's backyard (if you don't consider a farmer's land far far away from the actual farm as a backyard)? Actually I think wobbleblob's reason (because they scare birds and pollute the horizon) is a more prominent reason, I find the Netherlands always quite pretty in comparision with surrounding countries so I'd understand people are reluctant to change that much. Nicer, more colourful buildings, nicer gardens, ... then again it's also a bit boring to me due to being quite flat.
- wobbleblob 11y ago> I find the Netherlands always quite pretty in comparision with surrounding countries Of course beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but this is really not something I have ever heard before. There are many things to like about living here, but what parts of it are pretty?
- stinos 11y agoI guess you're used to it :] I'm mainly comparing to Belgium, and most people I know here actually think the same; might be because we look at it from a more tourist POV and tend to ignore uglier things but still: - not a lot of ribbon development. That alone makes a huge difference. - cities of comparable size seem to have more green overall (trees, plants in front of houses, more parks etc). Typical example is something like Ravenstein. Seems to have more park than actual housing area. - nicer architecture (again, eye of the beholder, but hey we have a 'ugly belgian houses' book :]) for instance streets whith all pretty much the same houses, but every third house has a door in a different pastel color etc. Not sure that even existst here. Or apartment buildings with some color to it. Of course there also are more ugly things (e.g. there are beautiful pieces of the Waal with nice tiny isles and such, then you look more to the left and there's a rather ugly concrete factory or so; some cities have more 'ghetto-style' places but still not as bad as some parts of Brussles I think). But in general I like it more.
- dimitar 11y agoJust Google the headline, results from search engines bypass the pay-wall.
- tedks 11y agoPaywalls are often done with cookies, so right clicking and opening in private browsing mode will get past them. It worked for me.
- shiggerino 11y agoThe wind turbine scam is not that much better than the solar roadways scam. It's a huge nuisance, expense and environmental impact for very little power. The only reasonable choice is nuclear power.
- masklinn 11y agoNuclear has great power density and is a much better option than gas or coal as far as I'm concerned, but it remains a temporary patch, it is not a renewable resource. And it's not like a nuclear plant is cheap (oh boy is it not), nuisance-free (you can still use an onshore windfarm's land for e.g. pasture) or without environmental impact (ignoring seashore nukes which have their own extra risks, rivershore plants need regulation to avoid overheating downriver and they make the land they're on unusable long after their removal, and obviously because of the amount of cooling the average-sized nuclear plant requires you can't just plop them anywhere you want). SMRs might be an improvement to some of the drawbacks, but they don't currently exist and we don't have >half a century of experience with them and they're not quite maintenance free (most designs seem to plan refueling every 1 to 5 years). Also "small" is relative, though it helps that you can partially bury the assembly.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI disagree with all that. Having millennia of Thorium available is essentially renewable, at least for this civilization. The cost history of nuclear could change completely with new reactors that don't suffer from meltdown etc. Nuclear can definitely be nuisance-free- build in underground silos where they're needed, and not serviced for decades. The existing windmills were fiction a decade ago. Its all in where you put the development money.
- sjtrny 11y agoYeh they are such a nuisance. What with being located on farms or out at sea with no one around. Get a grip.
- shiggerino 11y ago
- dimitar 11y agoMy humble proposal to fix not-in-my-backyard - tax all local governments, give a tax break or even a subsidy to those who have windmills. This by the way should be the rule for the EU as a whole - some countries are naturally better at producing renewable energy, others have nuclear plants or coal. The ones producing renewable energy should just export it so the ones that cannot or won't will be able to fill their quotas.
- gbtw 11y agoI actually have 3 windmills in my back yard (the local industrial estate across the busy through-road) You never hear them and hardly ever notice them once they are placed. https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.037446,4.506723,3a,75y,90t/data=!3m8!1e2!3m6!1s96528239!2e1!3e10!6s%2F%2Fstorage.googleapis.com%2Fstatic.panoramio.com%2Fphotos%2Fsmall%2F96528239.jpg!7i2794!8i2040 https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.037446,4.506723,3a,75y,90t/da... < is one of them. Zoetermeer used to have 3 other windmills about 20 years ago, those were replaced with these. Only thing i would like is to get cheaper power, that has not happened :|
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoThe problem with renewable energy like wind is that it's not nearly as cheap or efficient as, say, coal power plants. That's the trade-off, really.
- danmaz74 11y agoFor sure wind turbines are much less efficient than coal power plants at polluting the air. Apart from that, can you explain how could they be less "efficient", when they consume a free and renewable resource (ie, wind)?
- jacquesm 11y agoI have 3 2MW+ machines a few hundred meters from my house and 10's of smaller ones (older models) a little further away. Total impact on day to day living: none. I wouldn't mind it if they placed more windmills there either, it's not a densely populated area. So, not all Dutch oppose windmills and renewables at this scale really do make an impact.
- wobbleblob 11y agoI agree, I'm quite fond of them. People who claim windmills have no place in the Dutch landscape probably don't like tulips and clogs either.
- teekert 11y agoI know someone with a windmill close by, you hear it constantly and at a certain time during the day the sun shines on the house via the rotor, when it rotates it's like a cloud goes in front of and away from of the sun, at 1-3 Hz or so. It drives them crazy.
- jacquesm 11y agoThey must be extremely close to the machine and the suns path would have to intersect the blades 'just so' for this to happen. I can see how this would be a very annoying thing to experience, do you know how many minutes per day this line-up causes the problem?
- reycharles 11y agoHere's a video I found of the flickering: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbIe0iUtelQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbIe0iUtelQ According to the video description the windmill is 1000 feet (304 m) away, and is 40 stories (132 m) tall. FWIW in Denmark windmills have to be at a distance from nearest (inhabited) building by least 4 times the height of the windmill (source: http://naturstyrelsen.dk/planlaegning/planlaegning-i-det-aabne-land/vindmoeller/afstandskort/ http://naturstyrelsen.dk/planlaegning/planlaegning-i-det-aab...). This article <http://www.windpower.org/da/energipolitik_og_planlaegning/nabo_til_en_vindmoelle/skyggekast.html> http://www.windpower.org/da/energipolitik_og_planlaegning/na... says that the windmills can cause shadows for up to 4-6 weeks a year. It is computed when this will happen and the windmills can be stopped for that period, although the law doesn't mention this. I linked the Danish sources. You might want to put it through google translate.
- mattmanser 11y agoWhy did they build them so close to houses? That's nuts.
- legulere 11y agoThere's usually regulation how often this is allowed to happen. In Germany I think it's maximum 1 or 2 days a year. This isn't that hard to achieve as the sun wanders throughout the year
- digital-rubber 11y agoWe have one nearby (dutch), and they don't place more there because on that one winter day people living a few km out, complain about strike shadow on that low winter sun day. And that… is unacceptable for them. The concept of a sunscreen is probably unknown to them. There is one already, place another 3 of 4 next to it… but no that won't happen.
- Yaa101 11y agoThe main reason of the rejection is that the dutch government is pushing that through big companies while in germany a lot of individual owners can reap benifit. Dutch governemnts, especially right winged ones are very paternalistic and dislike individual oportunism where it costs the big and powerful companies.
- wobbleblob 11y agoThe energy situation now is: - A legal requirement to cut CO2 emissions - A ban on building new nuclear plants as well as a commitment to close the remaining one - A moratorium on building windmills because they scare birds and pollute the horizon - The largest supply of natural gas in Western Europe, but an increasing limit on exploiting this because shifts in ground level are causing cracks in people's walls. - A ban on fracking - There so notoriously little sunshine that people refuse to take solar power seriously, even though it seems to be working just fine in Germany. Different groups want opposing things. The energy situation would be fine if environmentalists would allow the construction of more windmills and nuclear plants, or if the CO2 reduction target was dropped. You can't have it both ways. The people in Groningen would probably be fine with continued exploitation of the gas wells if the profits were spent there, but the money is needed by the national government to meet the EU's budget deficit requirements. Now much of it will remain in the ground while we buy Russian gas. In my opinion the very concept that a horizon is something that can be polluted is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. I think the Dutch landscape is featureless and boring, and windmills are a vast improvement. They look modern, industrious, cheerful.
- pgeorgi 11y ago> I think the Dutch landscape is featureless and boring, windmills are a vast improvement. They look modern, industrious, cheerful. I recently visited relatives in a German village where in the last few years a bunch of windmills where built. We went for a walk outside the village, and I heard a surprised "oh, those windmills are much smaller than I remember them to be". Turns out they looked imposing and scary in the beginning because they're of such a different scale than anything else in the area, but they got used to them quickly. Like the Netherlands it's a relatively flat area, so I guess the effects will be similar (windmills looking huge at first, then perceptually shrinking).
- wobbleblob 11y agoThey are gigantic, they necessarily tower over everything (otherwise they wouldn't work), but once you take your gaze off the gigantic gray rotating blades against the clouds, and direct your eyes further down, you see [1] or [2]. Then you gaze back up again and think the windmill looks grand and beautiful in comparison. [1] https://stock-foto.nationalebeeldbank.nl/nationalebeeldbank_2014-1-842411-2_kletsnatte-akker-in-polder.jpeg https://stock-foto.nationalebeeldbank.nl/nationalebeeldbank_... [2] https://stock-foto.nationalebeeldbank.nl/nationalebeeldbank_2012-11-762840-2_moderne-woningbouw.jpeg https://stock-foto.nationalebeeldbank.nl/nationalebeeldbank_...