11 ms·
Tesla Beats Delivery Forecast with 52% Quarterly Surge
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoGood thing they're making up the per unit losses with volume.
- greglindahl 11y agoThey make money on cars (gross margin). They lose money on R&D and expanding the production line. Any car company growing this rapidly would lose money. Any car company this small designing a new model would lose money. I know why so many financial commenters harp on and on about Tesla losing money. What mystifies me is why so many HN commenters do the same, given that most of us are startup people. Many startups lose money for the same reasons.
- damoncali 11y agoMost car companies include R&D in COGS. So it's fair to point out that Tesla does not.
- greglindahl 11y agoIndeed, Tesla does things like startups do, not like big car companies. If you have a steady-state business, including R&D in COGS makes sense. Another way that Tesla is different is that they don't announce monthly sales numbers. That means that a fair number of analysts ignore them; here's an example [1]. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/02/business/us-monthly-auto-sales-june.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/02/business/us-monthly-auto-s...
- OrwellianChild 11y agoThough, to be fair, Tesla's monthly numbers would be like 4k/month, which in the ballpark of Porsche, and you don't see them on the analyst's list either...
- greglindahl 11y agoPorche had no chance of nearly being the fastest growing car, 52% (Tesla) vs 55% (Elantra). Of course it's always up to what the financial reporter thinks is important, but I'd bet that Tesla's slightly-late release of their quarterly number vs. reliable monthly updates from existing companies played a role.
- msandford 11y agoMost car companies already have mature vehicle platforms (engines, transmissions, chassis and body experience, etc) to work off of and thus only have to charge R&D for a particular car against that car. When you're developing a new car you have to do a lot of general R&D and a lot of car-specific R&D. What gets charged against the car and what are considered general? Who gets to decide? Why would they decide in a particular way? It's not super obvious to me where you'd bill things even if they're ostensibly just for the Model S because in another year or two they might release a Model S2 with not a lot of R&D because they just stole parts from the Model S, Model X and Model 3. Not saying it will happen, but it could. Then the R&D costs would be too low on that car and they'd have to go back and adjust their gross margin back as far as they've been selling the other cars and then the whole thing is a nightmare since I'm pretty sure the SEC won't let you do that.
- damoncali 11y agoIt's not a indefensible position. But it is different, and makes direct comparisons more difficult.
- greglindahl 11y agoThe numbers released to the public include enough information to make direct comparisons. The problem is that it's really apples-to-oranges: large, not-growing-very-fast car companies are a very different beast from small, rapidly-growing, risky new entrants.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ajross 11y agoI suppose. Most car companies (i.e. all other car companies) don't have 56% year-over-year growth numbers either (per the linked article). So my money is with the "apples and oranges" crowd here. Analyzing an investment in Tesla according to the rules you use for GM or Daimler is going to lose you a lot of money. Or realistically already has -- most people whining are whining because they didn't get in on the Tesla boom and are looking for reasons to prove it's a bubble.
- hinkley 11y agoJust a data point, I became an investor just this year and I'm up 35%. If you're still whining instead of acting then nobody can help you but you.
- dang 11y ago> If you're still whining instead of acting Please don't be personally rude on HN. This comment would be fine with just the first sentence.
- a8da6b0c91d 11y ago> They make money on cars (gross margin) No they don't. Net operating cashflow has been hugely negative for their entire existence and there is no conceivable path to profitability. Tesla is a taxpayer subsidized wall street scam that is going to blow up sooner or later.
- mikeash 11y agoNet operating cashflow is negative because they're piling money into expansion. Their gross margin is about 25%. If they wanted to be profitable in the short term all they'd have to do is stop spending money on expansion and just pull in the sweet profits from current sales.
- msandford 11y ago> No they don't. Net operating cashflow has been hugely negative for their entire existence and there is no conceivable path to profitability. Sure they do. They're just always spending it elsewhere, like Amazon. Amazon doesn't sell products at a loss, their prices have become much less competitive over the years. But the lack of profitability at Amazon isn't because the various business units are all operating at a loss. It's because the older units which make a profit finance the new ones that are starting up and not profitable yet. Telsa may well be taxpayer subsidized and it may blow up. But on 2014 revenue of 3.2b the odds that they're cooking the books are vanishingly small.
- krschultz 11y agoEven if you include R&D into the COGS they make a profit on each car sold. Here is Q4 2014 - http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/financials/financials.asp?ticker=TSLA http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/financials/financia... $3.2B total revenue $2.3B COGS $0.4B R&D $0.5B gross profit including R&D Their net income for Q4 2014 was -$0.3B, so they're not nearly as far off from profitability as you make it sound.
- CamperBob2 11y agoTesla is a taxpayer subsidized wall street scam that is going to blow up sooner or later. As opposed to any car that runs on petroleum? That's not taxpayer-subsidized at all, I suppose.
- ethanbond 11y agoAnd it's missing the point: Tesla is a battery and infrastructure R&D company that's kept afloat by selling cars. It's clear that Elon is going for the long haul on this.
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> It's clear that Elon is going for the long haul on this. Doesn't he always?
- aresant 11y agoWhat a perfect PR headline. Exciting, confusing, non-specific. "Wow a 52% quarterly surge, Tesla's on fire!" I thought that meant they sold 52% more cars than Q1. But what they really are saying is "Tesla sold 52% more cars in Q2 2015 than Q2 2014" And they are still less than halfway through year end's target 2 quarters in which analysts feel certain they will not hit without the Model X release (2) With all the discussion around the Unicorns preferring to stay private how much of a factor must avoiding the colossal pain in the ass of having to engineer this kind of financial-speak every quarter on top of just trying to run your business. (1) http://www.ibtimes.com/tesla-motors-inc-tsla-likely-miss-2015-delivery-target-55000-model-s-model-x-cars-1881582 http://www.ibtimes.com/tesla-motors-inc-tsla-likely-miss-201...
- greglindahl 11y agoThe default in financial magazines is year-based comparisons. Headlines are short.
- mikeash 11y agoHow often are percentages used in a financial context that aren't year-over-year percentages? Your statement about the Model X confuses me. Of course analysts think that they need Model X shipments to meet their year-end target, because that's exactly what the company itself has said.
- shampine 11y agoAnd my back button was hijacked.
- MajorLOL 11y agoMoral of the story in this comment section; Negative comments about Tesla will be down voted upon detection.
- mikeash 11y agoI think you mean, comments which state falsehoods will be downvoted.
- cblock811 11y agoNice to hear some good news for the guy after his rocket exploded.
- NorthNeutron 11y agoEverything takes trial and error to develop.
- elwell 11y agoYou wouldn't say that if your Tesla got stuck in acceleration and the brake didn't work.
- TrevorJ 11y agoPretty hard to compare two vastly different arenas like that. In space flight even mature platforms have a 1%-10% failure rate. Because of the physics involved, rockets operate at the very edge of the capabilities of the rocket. Modern auto's don't have this issue: you can drive at highway speeds all day long without stressing the materials in your engine anywhere close to the edge of the operating envelope. In short, from an engineering perspective car's aren't hard any longer.
- Shivetya 11y agoThe model X is the bogeyman in Tesla's house. If they fail to start deliveries by September as they have indicated they will likely not make their sales goal for year. The suspect in the X delay is the gull wing doors which like the ragtop they had before, Elon's insistence on particular features again is causing production issues.
- giarc 11y agoElon's decision to keep the gull wing doors is awesome though. The concept had them and he believes that a company shouldn't show one concept with cool features, then deliver the actual car without those cool features. All the other auto companies do it and it's incredibly disappointing.
- cma 11y agoCompanies put stuff on concepts knowing they won't make it to production. If his concept had them and they just couldn't make it work out but they legitimately tried, that doesn't seem as bad.
- giarc 11y agoI guess it depends on the idea of the concept car vs show piece of future production. I think some of the concept cars that GM/Ford/Dodge sometimes display are obviously concept cars that will never see the light of day. However, Tesla isn't really at that stage. So when they show a concept, it needs to be closer to reality. Toyota had a concept Rav 4 a few years ago that I really liked and had hoped they would put into production, they never did and it was extremely disappointing. I guess what I'm saying is, if it's going to be a concept car, make it so outlandish that no one will believe it will be production.
- pbreit 11y ago"Elon's insistence" has also created a $35b company. I think anyone would happily delay a car launch to both improve the car and increase the company's long term value.
- usaphp 11y agoSo many downvoted comment, looks like nobody wants to accept the reality...
- joshuapants 11y agoOr maybe people just downvote comments that contain the infamous "gratuitous negativity" and have no real substance to temper that with.
- buckbova 11y agoWhose reality?
- sixQuarks 11y agoHaving worked in the stock-trading world and seeing some of the murky things that go on first-hand, I would not be surprised to learn that many of the negative comments we see every time Elon Musk is mentioned is due to a concerted effort by short-sellers.
- epistasis 11y agoI would think that too, except for all the comments that are so financially ignorant. Unless the shortsellers have misread the HN audience and think that they don't understand these things.
- polymatter 11y ago> so financially ignorant I agree, and specifically I think of the confusion between gross profit margin and net operating cashflow. Tesla makes money on every car sold (as they actually have a gross profit) but have been spending cash really fast (as they have a negative cashflow). All this really tells you is that Tesla is investing a lot of money, which is to be expected for a company that is trying to spearhead a paradigm shift within the entire automotive industry. Also, since one big weakness in Tesla is whether it relies on government subsidies and loans for its continued survival. Thats something I don't understand and if I had a horse in this race, I'd be weary of a company that relies on the whims of political support in order to survive.
- mikeash 11y agoSomething is pushing this "Tesla loses money" angle hard. Since I bought mine, I've discovered that a lot of people who know very little about the company "know" that they make a loss on every car sold. Regarding subsidies, the "good" news there is that at least in the US, there isn't much in the way of uncertainty, because the US federal subsidy starts to drop off at 200,000 units per manufacturer and is unlikely to be expanded. Given how quickly they're moving, they'll probably hit that within the next few years and one way or another they'll have to learn to do without. But at least they won't be waiting for politicians to drop the knife on them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jhallenworld 11y agoIt's impressive, really. This is the year that I've really started to see Teslas around here (Boston- there's a showroom in the Natick Mall). On the one hand, the car is risky: expensive battery, limited range / charging options, luxury car service cost. On the other, they found a niche: the coastal rich who are willing to use them as their daily commuting car. They are cheaper than Maseratis, which I've also been seeing a lot of lately. When looked at this way, people are willing to take the risk on the cheaper car. Even so, if car sales are a zero-sum game, I think BMW is the one being hurt by them the most.
- wishinghand 11y ago> luxury car service cost I was under the impression that they have less service costs due to fewer moving parts. Or maybe it comes out all the same since there's less to service, but when something does need servicing it's more expensive than usual.
- mikeash 11y agoTesla charges $600 for their annual service, or $450 if you prepay four years in advance. This is a bit high, especially considering that they do very little. However it's not mandatory, especially the first year. What's likely to be cheaper is long-term repair costs. No muffler replacements, no leaking head gaskets, no timing belts making an attempt at freedom.... But whether that actually works out remains to be seen.
- fossuser 11y agoThey actually do an impressive amount that they don't have to (my dad is a Tesla fan/early adopter and has a Roadster, Model S and probably will get a Model X eventually). When he took the Model S in they added that metal plate to the bottom (from that one crash that got a lot of press), swapped out all the door handles for new ones because people online complained that in rain sometimes the old ones wouldn't retreat into the car and changed a few other things I'm forgetting (at no cost). I can't really think of another car company that proactively adds a bunch of stuff to the car for free as a part of routine maintenance. Of course this is in addition to all of the over the air software updates too.
- rostov 11y agoIn my opinion, based on Tesla's maintenance cost today, it's a fancy toy for rich people. It's out of reach of general consumer and when it comes to saving planet by consuming electricity, not gas in US I am skeptical. What I want to find out is a green house effect from 1 mile per gallon of gas vs. 1 mile per kWh off produced electricity. Considering US electricity is produced by coal burning plants, which are considered primary green gas effect contributors.
- pjscott 11y agoExpensive-toy prices are just barely keeping demand down to levels they can supply. They're using that money to ramp up production and lower their future costs. The long-term plan is to sell to progressively cheaper segments of the market, as they get rolling.
- rostov 11y agoFor years Tesla refused to make public it's sales numbers, after going public it's reluctantly doing so. I have read from 2012 to 2014 it's sales numbers in tenth of thousands per year. In comparison Mercedes Benz sells its gas powered toys in hundreds of thousands per year.
- bad_user 11y agoNuclear power plants are of course more efficient and do not produce greenhouse gases. By switching to Thorium it would also be safer, cheaper and the waste would go away in 30 years.
- GutenYe 11y agoWhere can I find the figure in China, I'm very interested in it.
- chatmasta 11y agoBest stock investment I ever made! Whoop whoop!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]