8 ms·
We wouldn't need money for most benefits any more (pensions, income support, etc) so that's about £120bn of the £240bn found immediately. You mention the NHS -
by onion2k 11y ago
We wouldn't need money for most benefits any more (pensions, income support, etc) so that's about £120bn of the £240bn found immediately. You mention the NHS - we'd be able to spend a lot less on that if people didn't have poverty-induced health problems, so there's another £35bn (assuming a 30% reduction of the £110bn). It's not unreasonable to assume that the difference of £85bn would essentially pay for itself by increasing the tax revenue from people spending their basic income. over time the country's GDP and tax revenue would increase due to people being better off (they go hand-in-hand).
This could well be cost neutral for the UK.
- anticon 11y agoYeah I'm sure you could find that missing £85bn down the back of a sofa in whitehall. Sorry, but the whole idea is laughable. Not to mention the fact that it's another incentive to have more children and bigger families because the state will give you more money.
- zimpenfish 11y ago> it's another incentive to have more children and bigger families Should be easy to back that wild claim up with statistics. Can you?
- jackweirdy 11y agoMy inner pessimist is expecting to see a "there was this Daily Mail article one time". Everywhere I look, I see the opposite. Families with a comfortable amount of disposable income have the 2.4 kids, but those in poverty (and particularly the working poor) have 3, or upwards. Anecdotal, but I'm yet to see evidence to the contrary
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThere's evidence on a national scale that birthrate is anticorrelated with wealth. The better off people are on average, the less kids they have.
- Retric 11y agoThis is not true; on average richer men have more children. If you try and slice it by family you find that the 'traditional' family makes up a fairly small percentage of the population.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThis TED talk focuses on the anticorrelation I wrote about: http://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_shows_the_best_stats_you_ve_ever_seen?language=en http://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_shows_the_best_stats_y....
- Retric 11y agoRicher countries have lower birth rates. Richer men in the same country have more kids. PS: I think I just misread your comment. By "national scale" I thought you meant in the same country.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoOk, I think I should have written "international scale", I apologize for the confusion. I don't know of any study on national level, i.e. of families in a single country. The only thing I know of are anecdotes and stories about very poor families having 5+ children.
- Retric 11y agoI have seen this stat from a few studies. EX: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/kids_are_normal.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/kids_are_normal.... Higher income > more kids, Higher education > fewer children. This seems fairly obvious as people are less likely to have children and stay in school. But, as I understand it the effect is larger than that.
- MSM 11y ago
- exch 11y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dymPP9RhPjw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dymPP9RhPjw A talk by Hans Rosling[1] on the subject. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Rosling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Rosling
- zo1 11y agoStatistics have nothing to do with it. Either the incentive exists, or it doesn't. Ask for a citation/study/logical-argument on that, not statistics. But bear in mind: Statistics could indicate the extent that the incentive is having on the incentivized population group, if at all.
- cmdkeen 11y agoWhy would poverty related health problems disappear unless the basic income is significantly higher than the current unemployment or disability benefits as you're saying those are being replaced. A basic income doesn't remove the potential for poverty.
- bmelton 11y ago> It's not unreasonable to assume that the difference of £85bn would essentially pay for itself by increasing the tax revenue from people spending their basic income. If the idea is to give everybody money so that you can tax it more, you're engaging in economic waste. Without being able to increase productivity in other areas to cover the lost value, you will, hopefully slowly, but eventually trend towards zero, and a failure of the system overall. Encouraging economic productivity in an environment in which nobody has to be productive may or may not be possible, I honestly haven't any idea, but its certainty doesn't seem terribly obvious to me.
- Haegin 11y agoIt's also worth remembering that at the moment everyone in the UK gets a tax free allowance of £10,600 and an NI free allowance of about £8000 (in 2015/16). The basic income is expected to replace that as well, which means if everyone continues to earn the same amounts that's an extra £2000 per person earning more than £10k (roughly, assuming it's now taxed at 20% in the first tax bracket). NI would be less, and is probably more complex as employers pay some of that, but just assuming that only the employees contributions are now paid on what was previously NI free you're still looking at another £1k each. It's not much individually, but when you take out the costs of administering all of that it'll add up.