15 ms·
One of the first pieces of advice I had when my company landed its investment was to pay ourselves a decent (not extravagant) wage so that my time went on worry
by onion2k 11y ago
One of the first pieces of advice I had when my company landed its investment was to pay ourselves a decent (not extravagant) wage so that my time went on worrying about the company rather than how I was going to afford to do things in my personal life. The same is true for employees - if they're paid a good living they will spend more time on thinking about problems in their job instead.
If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off - people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford their rent.
- hueving 11y ago>people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life Some people will. I have met many plenty of people though that don't care about other people regardless of their income.
- TisButMe 11y agoBut those people will always be a net negative for society, basic income or not. Empowering those who would make a positive difference if they had enough time/money sounds like a good idea to me.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoI think those who are against a basic wage feel the current net negative portion of society would be a greater net negative because not only would they be receiving a wage, but they'd spend it on crap and society would still have to take care of them (hospital bills, food, etc).
- thuuuomas 11y ago> but they'd spend it on crap Sounds like a good deal for the crap vendors. Also, maybe the instant-gratification app scene...
- Merovius 11y agoI never understood, why this is a problem. We live in a society of abundance. Tying coverage of living expenses to work done, just leads to people doing pointless work. This is at least the reality in Germany: There aren't enough jobs for everyone, people live under the illusion that it is wrong to just subsidize people living, thus the government rather subsidizes jobs, that are not profitable to be done by people (my mother crimped cables from home for a living, something that can be done by a machine for a fraction of the price in orders of magnitude less time). Apart from that, it is called "basic income", not "luxurious income". Ask these people if they still wouldn't work if the alternative is not being able to afford a smartphone, Game console, plasma TV or car.
- mcv 11y agoWe need to get rid of the myth that everybody needs to work. Better would be to automate all the work so nobody has to work anymore.
- brobinson 11y agoWho owns the machines in that system? The government?
- mcv 11y agoI don't care who owns them, as long as the value they produce is at least partially shared.
- Noelkd 11y agoIf you haven't read this[1] I think you might enjoy it. It covers the ideas you are talking about. I think it was featured on HN some time back. [1] http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm http://marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm
- brobinson 11y agoThis is awesome. Thanks for linking it. I've had dreams of doing this to an In-n-Out location. Every one I've been to has had all the employees doing every job like a scatterbrained beehive, and it takes 15-20 minutes to get your food.
- wozniacki 11y agoIf a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off - people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford their rent The incredulity of this is plainly galling. How does one draw a broad conclusion like that? Plenty of European examples abound where despite generous - some would argue very generous - state dispensed benefits certain sections of the society just do not respond positively in measures of improvement of their own station in life much less "working on things to improve everyone's else (lives)". A good - and I admit quite controversial - account of this kind of malaise is recounted in the British Channel 4 documentary, Benefits Street [1] [2] [1] Benefits Street Season 01 Episode 01 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlrLp-R4g_M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlrLp-R4g_M [2] Benefits Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefits_Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefits_Street
- naz 11y agoYou're woefully misinformed about exactly how generous benefits in the UK are. People who do manage to live off benefits here can't expect a quality of life that even begins to approach comfortable. You shouldn't let some opportunistic reality TV show be the basis for your world views.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wozniacki 11y agoYou shouldn't let some opportunistic reality TV show be the basis for your world views. Well if Western societies didn't function in a miasma of political correctness highly sensitive to even the least prickly of criticisms perhaps Channel 4 or any other outlet for that matter wouldn't have seen a need to reach for an alarmist tone in the way they fashioned their programming in matters such as this, that one could argue have influenced the most recent UK national parliamentary election. The opinion polls suggested quite the opposite outcome [1] which goes to prove that many of the voters were quite concerned about the issues such as these and general direction in which UK as a sovereign nation was headed, but rather stopped short of voicing them openly, lest they be branded prejudicial or worse. [1] Election 2015: How the opinion polls got it wrong http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-32751993 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-32751993
- tluyben2 11y agoWhat round of investment was that? And yes that is sound; in later rounds even a number which makes you never (at least the coming 10 years) having to worry about money so you can focus on your company 100%. If you do not do that you will not be able concentrate even when something trivial like having too little money for your family occurs for some reason. Which is bad for investors and everyone else involved in the company.
- anticon 11y agoPeople starting companies are driven, determined people who want to create things. The vast majority of people are not. You're vastly over-estimating the general population. The majority are lazy, and if given money, will sit watching reality TV and stuffing their face with ice cream. (Step outside the startup bubble for a while). Most people are also selfish. The idea that they'll all start doing things to benefit others is a bit far fetched. Communism (Which is what this is), has failed. Why this generation seems determined to try it again is beyond me. This is about stealing money from the successful, and giving it to everyone, regardless of merit. It's a fantastic way to reward failure and penalise success, and society will suffer because of it. The numbers are also staggering - it just doesn't work mathematically unless you can magic up billions from somewhere each year. Also be under no illusion - if a basic income was implemented, the chances are (Assuming you're better off than the average person) you would have to reduce your quality of life substantially to pay for it.
- msvalkon 11y agoIt seems to me you are not entirely objective on this. The studies (also mentioned in this article) seem to contradict your view.
- Sir_Substance 11y ago>The vast majority of people are not. You're vastly over-estimating the general population. The majority are lazy, and if given money, will sit watching reality TV and stuffing their face with ice cream. I've always felt that this argument against basic minimum income said more about the arguer than society at large. In my experience, everyone has a personal project that gets sidelined for their work.
- anticon 11y agoSeriously? Do you not think you're in a bubble of 1%ers? Most people aren't itching to start a company you know... Most want to watch American Idol and do nothing.
- 11y ago
- Fuxy 11y agoI would wager there will be people who will take advantage of the system and use it as a opportunity to not work and laze around all day however those people will be the one who are not particularly productive in their work anyway. They might find something else to do they might not but that's OK it is an acceptable loss. On the other end companies which used to take advantage of the job market and the fact that everybody needs a job to survive will have a hard time to find employees since now people can afford to be selective. When survival is off the table nothing is more important than enjoying your job since you spend a great deal of the day doing it. Another possibility is part-time work being more sought after since some people may want to work but wouldn't like to spend 8 hours every day doing it. Overall i believe it will have a positive effect on society if you don't get hung up on the fact that some people will take advantage of it which most politicians tend to do even with the benefit system in the UK.
- anticon 11y agoYou don't mention the fact it's completely unworkable mathematically. In the UK I believe it'd cost £240 billion a year. Where the hell would anyone be able to find that money from? (Tackling tax avoidance from Starbucks isn't a credible answer). Just to put it in context, that's twice the entire NHS's budget, or 5 times our defence spending.
- 314 11y agoChecking the latest figures for 2016: 155B for pensions and welfare 56B. I assume the point is to replace both of those completely with the basic income so the net cost is not 240B, it is 29B. Not cheap, but not pie in the sky either. Sell a bank or two :)
- just_had_tea 11y agoCut defense wastage. Uh, sorry, I meant defense spending.
- s_kilk 11y ago
- DanielBMarkham 11y ago"If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off - people will spend their time working on things to improve everyone's life rather than worrying about how to afford their rent." Looking at populations of people who have gone from being very poor to being very rich overnight does not support that statement. Most of the time the money is more of a curse than anything else. I believe the same goes for people who go from very poor to receiving an annuity from things like legal settlements, but I am only guessing at that. (I'm not arguing against it, I think it's an experiment worth having) I think there is are a few hidden premises here that need to be called out: the premise that having more money is better for everybody than having less, the premise that not struggling at all in life -- whether for personal goals or paying the rent -- is better than struggling, the premise that everybody will respond in a positive way to the same external stimulus, and so on. I find many of these premises dubious, but I cannot deny the fact that I personally feel better the more folks in the world that go to bed without being hungry or sick. The trick is separating my personal desire to feel good from what actually may be happening with various policies I would support. That's why we need more data here. It's very easy to grandstand something like this either way. There's a lot of smoke but very little light.
- notahacker 11y agoThe most galling implicit premise of all is that every proposal for basic income I've ever seen accepts that BI isn't practically feasible with open borders, and therefore nothing changes at all for the class of people who work the longest hours in the worst conditions (indeed their wage slavery becomes even more essential to ensuring future riders of the purple wage can still buy consumer goods) An argument for implementing BI in the foreseeable future isn't really a "nobody should be forced to work" argument, as desirable as that might ultimately be. An argument for implementing BI in ones own developed country in the near term is a "nobody with the right passport should be forced to look for work" argument. I think social security - essentially insuring people from a risk of unemployment caused at least in part by policies enacted by an elected government - is a good idea, but I categorically don't agree that my fellow Brits should have an automatic right to receive more than the world average purchasing power adjusted income without even thinking about doing anything for it.
- ajuc 11y ago> If a government were to do that for everyone Inflation would eat it up.
- rorykoehler 11y agoHow? Competition would increase and prices would come down. We are currently fighting to avoid deflation anyways and all indicators point towards this continuing. If anything UBI will stop people hoarding cash as is happening now and re-introduce some cash-flow into the macro economy. A little inflation is healthy.
- ajuc 11y agoWhy would competition increase?
- rorykoehler 11y agoFor basic goods there would be more demand (people who can't afford even basics would enter the market making the total market larger) in turn making it more attractive to compete there. People always go where there is opportunity. We are also on a long term trend of prices coming down in any case.
- ajuc 11y agoSo you say demand will increase and production will have to catch up. I think prices will go up, not down in such case.
- rorykoehler 11y agoHow did you come to that conclusion? We can easily increase production to meet demand. In fact supply is a largely solved problem. The new problem is lack of demand.
- s73v3r 11y agoDepends on how elastic the demand for the good is. Not everything can handle a large price hike like that. McDonald's, for instance, wouldn't be able to jack up their prices a whole lot, because then people simply wouldn't go there.
- dharmach 11y agoA company will hire and keep only those who are able and willing to worry about company's issues. For such employees it makes sense to pay them decent wage so they are free to worry about company. How should government fire citizen who are not performing well?
- s73v3r 11y agoWhy should they bother?
- wooyi 11y agoThis assumes everyone is motivated, wants to improve their lives and do well in their jobs or in society.
- frogpelt 11y agoAccording to Thomas Sowell, this assumption is at the heart of the difference between liberals and conservatives. Liberals assume "everyone is motivated, wants to improve their lives and do well in their jobs or in society" given the right system. Conservatives basically assume the opposite. I'll let him explain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5KHdhrNhh88&feature=youtu.be&t=166 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5KHdhrNhh88&feature=youtu.be...
- ancap 11y agoI'm all for this (and any other form of welfare), provided the funding of such a program is done on a purely voluntary basis.
- shostack 11y agoIf the net result is lower cost than funding existing forms of welfare and ends up improving other areas of the city, would you care as much about the voluntary nature of it?
- macspoofing 11y ago>provided the funding of such a program is done on a purely voluntary basis. Like taxes right?
- ancap 11y agoIf you live in Greece
- macspoofing 11y ago>If a government were to do that for everyone it seems pretty obvious that society will be better off I don't think it's obvious hence the necessity of actually testing it in a real-world setting.
- branchless 11y agoAfter swinging your hammer several times you hit the nail on the head with the final word. We should have land value tax which will eliminate land hoarding, reduce rents and replace income tax. More incentive to work, less incentive to speculate. You'll never get this in the UK/US as the last thing the elite want is a level playing field where you get to keep most of what you contribute.