10 ms·
Just a reminder about FISA's historical performance: > Between 2001 and 2012, the FISA judges approved 20,909 surveillance and property search warrants - an av
by dmix 11y ago
Just a reminder about FISA's historical performance:
> Between 2001 and 2012, the FISA judges approved 20,909 surveillance and property search warrants - an average of 33 a week. During that 12-year period, the judges denied just 10 applications. Prosecutors withdrew another 26 applications.
> From 2007 to 2012, FISA judges also approved 532 "business record" warrant applications, the category used in the order that directed Verizon to release metadata on all phone calls inside the United States. No business record warrants were rejected.
and, on the judges perception of themselves:
> Walton, the senior judge on FISA, declined to be interviewed. In a statement, he said: "The perception that the court is a rubber stamp is absolutely false. There is a rigorous review process of applications submitted by the executive branch, spearheaded initially by five judicial branch lawyers who are national security experts, and then by the judges, to ensure that the court's authorizations comport with what the applicable statutes authorize."
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/21/us-usa-security-fisa-judges-idUSBRE95K06H20130621 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/21/us-usa-security-fi...
- 3pt14159 11y agoAlso the FISA court has been called an "almost parallel supreme court" by the New York Times, and given that it only hears one side of a case, makes this all the more troubling.
- rtpg 11y agopeople have talked about only hearing one side of the case, but that's the same for all warrant proceedings. FISA court isn't about declaring people guilty, it's about declaring whether there's reasonable suspicion.
- SoftwareMaven 11y agoIt's more than just warrants, it's any information about information gathering at all. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/05/new-eff-aclu-amicus-brief-argues-court-right-order-disclosure-fisa-materials https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/05/new-eff-aclu-amicus-br...
- joshuak 11y agoWell in that case they've never had it with regard to 'all' business records of ANY kind. By definition there is no 'reasonable suspicion' in that context. In fact there is no suspicion at all, and that lack of suspicion is the crux of the whole argument is it not?
- schoen 11y agoOn the other hand, we do have expiry (by default) of the secrecy surrounding regular warrants when they're executed, plus the ability to challenge them at trial and in appellate proceedings, with the result that there's an enormous amount of regular case law about them, even though all of them were originally issued ex parte. So that is very different. The main exception that we know about in the regular criminal justice system has been cell site simulators and cell site location information, where the government tried super-hard to prevent people from knowing that this information was being collected or challenging its collection or use.
- higherpurpose 11y agoSo how does the FISA court determine that "3-hop" people (millions) are "suspicious, then? The standard for an NSA "general warrant" is FAR, and I mean FAR weaker than for a regular warrant. Literally orders of magnitudes weaker, to the point you could barely consider it a "standard". Especially when the FISA court approves for for 3 months at once (and now for 6). What kind of "warrant" is that? Does that sound reasonable to you?
- zkhalique 11y agoI hate to break it to you, but organizations and agencies are basically using humans to further their own desires, such as to continue existing and expand their powers. You can see this in organizations ranging from companies to government agencies. And Big Data is like crack cocaine to them. Do you really think you can cut off their access to something so eminently collectable? Do you think if it technology has enabled it, then organizations won't find a way to use it? If the USA spy agencies don't do it, the Chinese and Russians will. The details of some domestic law doesn't matter, they'll just find ways around it. At the end of the day, the organizations need the data. Humans can only fight organizations with other organizations... humans that try to get in the way on their own are eliminated and replaced.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoIt's about stuffing databases full of surveillance information gathered by the NSA; databases which are shared with law enforcement agencies across the country. Those agencies then use the data to mine for leads, stage fake context searches, seize peoples' property, and put people on criminal trial; all while denying collusion with the surveillance state. I'm supposed to think this is all okay because, 'hey, they're guilty, right?' except that 1. This is explicitly prohibited by the Bill of Rights and 2. They aren't always guilty.
- dflock 11y ago> comport with what the applicable statutes authorize If the statutes are extremely broad and permissive of surveillance, then he could well be telling the truth - FISA could be rigorously scrutinising every request and finding that the statutes permit almost all of them.
- dogma1138 11y agoThose numbers don't mean much without the ability to compare them to the acceptance rate of warrants in other criminal courts. I haven't found a single statistic on that seems that no one actually is keeping or publishing it, but every article I've read seems to point that denying warrants is very rare in all jurisdictions. e.g.: http://tucson.com/news/local/crime/rejection-of-search-warrant-pleas-rare/article_0453d6f4-324b-51ac-9ec7-9375e9e67aff.html http://tucson.com/news/local/crime/rejection-of-search-warra... I mean in California police officers can request a warrant and have it signed digitally, and they even got a fucking app for that. When you automate a system to a point when a police officer can get a warrant on his Ipad i some how don't think that many of them are denied.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoI can tell you from first hand experience that getting a warrant TO the FISA court from a sponsoring agency is a massive bureaucratic battle in and of itself. Reason being, the agency powers that be don't want to send something up that will be disapproved because it takes significant time and effort of general counsel and leadership of these agencies to process, implement and track to maintain compliance - even if the warrant is reasonably broad. So these numbers really don't mean anything in terms of just "blanket surveillance." The bar for even getting something to the court, in my experience, is incredibly high and you typically need very high ranking people to sign off on it. Which means your evidence, reason for doing and ensuring that it is within the boundaries of EO 12333 and a million other regulations, has to be pretty airtight.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSo, it's OK that the court is effectively a rubber-stamp, because we can trust that the agencies requesting warrants won't ask for things they don't think are reasonable? No.
- ikeboy 11y agoI believe you misunderstood him. He seems to be saying that almost no invalid requests were submitted, because there was a rigorous review before submission. The court might not be a rubber-stamp, but the agencies happened to only send reasonable requests, so they got approved.
- higherpurpose 11y agoThe NSA asks for "general warrants" and you think that's "reasonable"? NSA: Can we spy on everyone at once? FISA: Why yes of course you can - BUT, you have to fill out this form first...and do it properly or we'll never approve you! NSA: Oh..but that's such a drag! Okay, fine, we'll do it. That's kind of what seems to be happening.
- bitJericho 11y ago
- r00fus 11y ago> In a statement, he said: "The perception that the court is a rubber stamp is absolutely false." Is it me? I just hear Nixon saying "I'm not a crook"...
- coldtea 11y agoOr "Read my lips. There will be no new taxes". Given the track record, I wonder what kind of mindset it takes for people who still believe official statements of that kind.
- andreyf 11y agoYou're right, he's not very good at the rhetoric [1]. That doesn't mean anything logically. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ironic_process_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ironic_process_theory
- billions 11y agoThe FISA court is unconstitutional.
- ngoede 11y agoI don't know that this is true but I think we ought to pass a law or constitutional amendment banning secret/private courts if it is not.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoThe resistance to the Bill of Rights was based on this very notion, the fear that adding an enumeration of some rights would eventually be seen as an enumeration of all rights and that any rights not explicitly enumerated would be considered as lesser rights not protected by the Constitution. Of course, a right being clearly stated in the Constitution doesn't do much to protect it either. Consider all the limits on gun ownership that run counter to the second amendment. Even someone who is against guns should be of the view that a Constitutional amendment should be needed to allow for limits like those we currently have. For example, banning a mentally ill person from owning a gun or charging a licensing fee to own a gun. Both of these exists and are not considered to infringe on second amendment rights. Now imagine if the same logic was applied to other rights, such as a fee to vote or not allowing free speech to those deemed to have a mental illness (never mind the difficulty in determining what constitutes a mental illness).
- shadowmint 11y ago> an average of 33 a week Sounds pretty reasonable, until you read: > Every few months, the FISA judges set aside their regular, public cases, travel to Washington, and take the bench inside a secure, windowless courtroom at 333 Constitution Avenue. Oh, so what actually happens is that every few months the judges get together and do a "rigorous review process of applications" of hundreds of applications? Sounds legit to me. ... wait...
- rhino369 11y agoI believe they rotate who has the duty.
- shadowmint 11y agoA pair of judges every six months with 800 applications to review? Or a pair of judges every month with 150 applications to review? In what time period? Do they spend an hour? A whole day? A whole week? All we have to go on is one vague article. ...and that article suggests that (if we accept they rotate duty and meet monthly say) they spend, on average, (8 hours / 133 * 60 minutes) ~3.5 minutes carefully evaluating each application. If not, it's ~30 seconds per application. So are the numbers wrong? Or is the bold assertion that they 'carefully review each application' completely farcical? 30 seconds to rubber stamp an application sounds about right to me. The point remains; there is no 'fulltime' FISA court. Periodically the presiding judges get together and process a bulk of applications all at once.
- csandreasen 11y ago> A pair of judges ... Do they spend an hour? A whole day? A whole week? All we have to go on is one vague article. The FISC has its own website which happens to answer your question right on the "About" page[1]: The Court sits in Washington D.C., and is composed of eleven federal district court judges who are designated by the Chief Justice of the United States. Each judge serves for a maximum of seven years and their terms are staggered to ensure continuity on the Court. By statute, the judges must be drawn from at least seven of the United States judicial circuits, and three of the judges must reside within 20 miles of the District of Columbia. Judges typically sit for one week at a time, on a rotating basis. > ...and that article suggests that (if we accept they rotate duty and meet monthly say) they spend, on average, (8 hours / 133 * 60 minutes) ~3.5 minutes carefully evaluating each application. If not, it's ~30 seconds per application. No, the article says 33 per week. The judges aren't meeting together every few months; the sitting judge is replaced by the next every week or so. Assuming an 8 hour work day and 33 warrants per week, that (8 * 5) / 33 = 1.2 hours per warrant on average. [1] http://www.fisc.uscourts.gov/about-foreign-intelligence-surveillance-court http://www.fisc.uscourts.gov/about-foreign-intelligence-surv...