7 ms·
Ask HN: How to deal with female name on resume?
I'm a female working in the finance/tech industry. Applying to companies, I'm worried that the gendered name on my resume might be poisoning employers' perception of me: http://whatwouldkingleonidasdo.tumblr.com/post/54989171152/how-i-discovered-gender-discrimination.
Do you believe that this kind of name-based bias is strong enough that I should somehow change my resume to show something other than my name? Also, I'm working with a recruiter, should I tell him my concern?
- ellisv 11y agoDo you want to work at a company where it matters?
- Qualman 11y agoA thousand times this. It makes me sad that you have to worry about this :(. But if there's that strong a bias against your name, you probably don't want to end up actually being present there. My advice, working at an enterprise SaaS company: stick to your guns, and be proud of your name! Good companies (like ours :) ) are actively seeking women for technical positions to correct the bias.
- erroneousfunk 11y agoWhat's the name of your company?
- jobposter1234 11y agoThe fear is that it happens at a subconscious level. Most people have subtle (latent) biases against disadvantaged groups. A perfectly awesome to work at company might be doing this out of ignorance, not because they would be a bad place for OP to work.
- harigov 11y agoI don't think any reputable company does recruitment based on names. In fact, most of the big name companies are trying to get more woman into workforce to balance any bias there might be.
- dudul 11y agoI guess you should also find a way to change your look to trick the manager during the in person interview.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoWe've hired people without ever once meeting them! Remote workers, online interviews, accepted and get to work. But we're a company that creates remote-worker tools, so we're well-placed to make that happen.
- dudul 11y agoWithout even a skype/hangout session? Without getting their actual name/gender for legal purposes?
- xrange 11y agoHere's a question. How anonymous can an employee be? For the U.S. It seems like you need to get a Social Security number for tax purposes. Is a name also required?
- Asparagirl 11y agoEmployers are required to verify that the employee is eligible to work in the U.S., meaning they're a citizen or else have the proper kind of visa, and are not in the country illegally. And most companies will also do background checks. So yeah, you'll need to give your name, and probably a Xerox of your passport or driver's license, when you sign on to a company.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI'd be concerned. If you're lucky, an androgynous name like Robin or Jo can help you. Otherwise, maybe use an initial? Once you get an interview, it becomes harder to avoid the discrimination. But at least you can get through the resume filter. Its probably too much, to ask you to change your name.
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoI have a friend whose last name triggers porn spam filters.
- jgeorge 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoHis name really is just like that.
- insomniac2 11y agoinitials instead of full name maybe? I doubt it's an issue for finance, more for tech perhaps? Depends on what role it is and what level you are at. It matters less than it used to. There's more important things on a resume to determine if you get an interview. Tailoring resumes to company and role is more important.
- pvaldes 11y agoThe common way to do this in literature is using an alias. 'Little Bobby Tables' is probably available again...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoStrangely, that one is always available in the database!
- davismwfl 11y agoI don't think this is a real common occurrence or something you should be worried about (but I am also male). And like ellisv said, in the few times it does would you really want to work at that type of place? My 2 cents, be yourself and don't hide anything. If you really feel it is hurting you though, then try using your first initial. But either way, neither would stop you from getting an interview with any company I have been apart of if you had the qualifications, and I think that's true at most any reputable company.
- fuj 11y agolol
- Someone1234 11y agoI'd argue it is more likely to help you in tech' than hurt you. Companies are falling all over themselves to bring in more women. No clue on finance however.
- qzcx 11y agoI would say it seems to depend on the company. Companies like Google and Microsoft seem to go out of their way to hire minorities (i.e. not white male), but companies which are less in the public spotlight seem to put less effort into it. At least that is my perspective based on interviewing at lots of companies for post graduation jobs.
- kat 11y agoI agree, or at least that is my perception. As a female dev I'm always more worried about a false positive, being hired for a job I'm not suitable for because of the diversity factor. I have found women sometimes get further in the interview process because they are given more second chances. My advice is use your female name.
- hackerboos 11y ago> Companies are falling all over themselves to bring in more women. In the HN echo chamber maybe. I still think hiring managers are thinking "maternity leave" especially in the US.
- Someone1234 11y agoWhich is odd as the US offers no maternity leave. A handful of states have a little but it is often UNPAID maternity leave making it all but worthless.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Which is odd as the US offers no maternity leave. A handful of states have a little but it is often UNPAID maternity leave making it all but worthless. That's a bit confused. The US requires unpaid maternity (and other) leave via FMLA; a few states also provide some degree of paid maternity leave. (In both cases, "maternity" is overly specific, but included, in what is generally described -- as in the title of FMLA -- as "family and medical leave".) [0] [0] http://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/state-family-and-medical-leave-laws.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/state-fami...
- bjourne 11y agoResearchers in the US have demonstrated that black names (many blacks have names like Tyrone and Aleisha which white people doesn't) are discriminated against (http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html). It's not far-fetched to speculate that employers would likewise value female and male names differently. I'm just guessing but it feels to me like in the software industry, there may be a bias against females for managerial and project leader positions. Otoh, there is a clear bias in favor of females for bottom-rung coder positions. It's not uncommon to see language in job ads that they would like to see female applications.
- JSeymourATL 11y ago> I'm working with a recruiter... Don't waste your energy with a some bozo recruiter. Instead focus your search on networking with senior executive level women. Most companies (even in male dominate tech) have a few well positioned women. And most get the Girl Power Network thing. Check out Women in Technology for an event near you>http://witi.meetup.com/ http://witi.meetup.com/ ; and www.womenintechnology.org Also, The 25 Most Powerful Women in Finance for some additional target ideas... http://www.americanbanker.com/women-in-banking/gallery/the-25-most-powerful-women-in-finance-2013-1062210-1.html http://www.americanbanker.com/women-in-banking/gallery/the-2...
- zer00eyz 11y agoThere are lots of firms who ONLY get decent engineers through recruiters. Techical recruiting is HARD, and honestly if your a small shop, with limited HR going outside to get talent may be your only option.
- JSeymourATL 11y agoThe typical business model for a recruiter has the company pay him a fee for placement. He does NOT work for job-seekers, but rather tries to broker a match. Most companies (especially small shops) would rather source a potential hire through their own channels, than pay a headhunter fee.
- Labyrinth 11y agoI don't think there is nothing to worry about. I mean your not me a dude with 95% looking female name. For the most part most of my interviews went well though one army research organization one was a bit weird. I think at the time they were "ok we have to ask questions, but lets not make it awkward".
- ilaksh 11y agoI say do an experiment with initials if you can't find an existing study. Try askscience on reddit for previous studies. I bet it does affect interview rates. But in general people hire for 'cultural' fit which means like them, so if you find a female who is hiring then that is bonus points, for some men it is minus points, but other things matter too like your perceived social class, what school you went to, etc. But you can't do anything about that stuff so best is to give them the benefit of the doubt in terms of being able to judge you on your merits. But I think people do want to click with their hires regardless of official policy. You might be able to bond over technical details in your field or baseball teams or whatever.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't think it's worth being concerned about (and I do believe we have a big problem with gender bias in this industry), but if you think it's a problem, it's going to be one whether or not it really is, because it'll impact your confidence. So, to ease your mind and table this issue: just use your first initial instead of your first name. Super common, people do it all the time.
- Mz 11y agoI would suggest you do further research before making a decision. It is possible it will hurt you. It is also possible that it will screen out toxic work environments where you wouldn't really want to be. Before deciding whether to go with initials or not, if it were me, I would see if I could come up with something on that angle of things. From what I have read, some women are leaving tech to get away from the horribly misogynistic work environments they have endured. There are some real horror stories out there. If this can be used as a means to screen out potentially toxic work places, it might be a more efficient use of your time to go ahead and use the female name and let them not waste your time on interviews and what not. Best of luck. (I will add that I am a woman, fwiw.)
- zer00eyz 11y agoI agree with Mz that your going to screen out the toxic places by being honest. As a guy who has done hiring in the past, if I see a woman who has 5+ years in the industry I'm automatically going to talk to her. Theres a lot of bullshit out there, and you have probably put up with a fair bit more of it than most other people/men. If your still here and still looking for a job its probably because you want to be in the industry and like what you do.
- alltakendamned 11y agoNo. Never. Be who you are and be extremely happy not to have to work for/with people that think it is OK to filter out candidates based on the name or gender. Years ago, I was in the very unique situation of helping with the recruitment of my own boss. When interviewing a woman, the CTO asked if she was planning to have more kids. Her reaction was a very quick and assertive "Would you ask me the same question if I wasn't a woman?". I was embarrassed by the question and loved the answer. She was hired and we had a great working relationship for the years after. I think it is very much OK to put people on the spot when similar questions come up.
- drakonka 11y agoI've never even thought about this when applying for jobs and didn't notice my name negatively affecting my chances (aside from a female name I also have a very foreign sounding name even though English). I figure if someone is going to discriminate against you based on your name/implied gender/whatever that company is probably not one you want to be working for anyway.
- liquidcool 11y agoThis is a tough one. What everyone assumes is that a only blatantly sexist person will dismiss your resume because of a female name. Obviously, such people will flunk you in the interview. The problem is it completely ignores people who honestly don't believe they are sexist (and may even consider themselves feminist), but suffer from an unconscious bias. These people might be fine to work for and not be biased (or blatantly so) in the rest of the hiring process. I never thought of orchestras as havens of gender bias, but they totally were: http://www.theguardian.com/women-in-leadership/2013/oct/14/blind-auditions-orchestras-gender-bias http://www.theguardian.com/women-in-leadership/2013/oct/14/b... And I'm sure the judges certainly didn't consider themselves as sexist. It's totally up to you, but an easy solution is to use initials, such as AJ instead of Allison Jane. For some reason, we almost always assume initials belong to a man. As for the recruiter, hopefully they know some stats about diversity, including if they are trying to improve it. But in general, a recruiter does not want to submit someone who won't pass the interview.