5 ms·
Eh? The US has about 100 F-22's which are used primarily for national defense. The bulk of the F-35's were supposed to go to the Navy which is the defacto offen
by dogma1138 11y ago
Eh? The US has about 100 F-22's which are used primarily for national defense.
The bulk of the F-35's were supposed to go to the Navy which is the defacto offensive air force of the US armed forces which cannot fly F-22's off their carriers which means they'll actually need a fighter which is capable in CAP / A2A roles.
But we'll see what comes out in the end of that, the 1st country which will get the F-35 as early as late 2015/early 2016 is supposed to be Israel, they are getting their own version which will include a different engine and their own avionic package.
And the IAF doesn't care about BVR despite having what is arguably the best A2A BVR/WVR missile currently in service the Python-5, their doctrine is go for the gun kill and that anything else doesn't count.
That said you can find similar reservations in pilots going from Gen 2 jet fighters to Gen 3/3.5 fights like from the Mirage 3 likes to an F-16 losing quite a bit of agility in the process.
The F-16 at the time was the 1st negative stability FBW Jet and quite a few pilots took it to town complaining that it's too unresponsive too sluggish and you don't fly it but rather the computer flies you.
That same issue would've probably been sensationalized just as much as the F-35 if it would've happen today, well the Aircraft will get better and pilots will learn how to use it's flight characteristics, so how much of an improvement needs to be done to the F-35 is yet to be seen.
- anovikov 11y agoWhat does it mean 'used for national defense'? As an air defense fighter? What is the point of that? Air defense fighters don't need to dogfight: no fighter can cross the ocean. Outdated second-line fighters like rusty F-15As are best here, they are fast and have a lot of range with drop tanks, guided by ground based radar, and now also with SBIRS (which can supposedly track almost any kind of aircraft, strategic bomber for sure) it can do the job.
- dogma1138 11y agoYes the F-22 is used solely as an Air-Defense fighter. While it's true that fighters can't cross the ocean, Russia doesn't need to cross any ocean to get to the western seaboard. Open a map, look at Russia, then look how far Alaska is, the distance between the landmasses is less than 100KM apart in some areas, they can reach Alaska and Washington, and with air refueling most of the eastern sea board. The F-22 is currently deployed 4 AFB's, Langley(Virginia, basically covering DC) , Elmendorf(Alaska), Hickam(Hawaii) and Holloman(New Mexico). They move some of them some times to allied bases mainly in Japan and the Gulf to show some muscle to reassure their local allies. But for all intents and purposes the US don't have any deployment plans for the F-22 in an active war zone as an offensive fighter. The US Air force for the most part is not used for offensive roles it hasn't been done so for a long long time basically pretty much since it was split from the Army int the 1st place. It did play a small role in Korea and in the early days of the Vietnam war because the navy back then wasn't really catching up with the AF and getting into the jet age properly. With the exception of some hey look we found a use for 2bln dollar air planes the US Airforce hasn't done much for the past 20-30 years. They only run support missions since the navy doesn't run it's own tankers and well NKAWTG... The brunt of air missions conducted by US armed forces are done for the navy, USAF as stated only does support missions whether it's running tankers or CAS with it's A-10's, once in a while they'll take their B2 or B-52's for a spin :)
- anovikov 11y agoNo they can't reach anything but Alaska with fighters. And aerial refueling in Russia is a joke, not even all strategic bomber crews can do it, for any tactical aircraft only test pilots can, and not all even have aerial refueling eqipment. For all but very few special missions involving only strategic aircraft, you can forget aerial refueling. If you think F-15 can be somehow lacking for air defense role you are really stretching the reality. In any potential conflict situation i.e. looming war with China, U.S. can easily take all of F-22s and deploy to Asia and American security will not be impacted at all.
- dogma1138 11y agoI'm not saying that the F-15 is lacking in air defense role, it's probably at this point better than the F-22 since it's a more mature platform with established doctrine and plenty of pilots which had 1000's of flight hours in one. As for Russian air refueling, again it doesn't matter even if what you are saying is correct it's a question of training. The tankers the Russians use are also used by other air forces including the Indian air force which seems to be capable of refueling with it quite nicely. Russia was also supposed to purchase several tankers based on the Airbus A330 and the A400M (for helicopter / low speed refueling) but I'm not sure if it was ever delivered mostly since the Russians are building a new tanker based on the IL-78M-90. On that note the SU-37 has a combat range of over 3500KM with external tanks which puts a portion of the western seaboard and northern US in it's range. The US can take all of it's F-22 fleet and melt it into spoons without any major impact to it's security, it has over 2000 fighters including almost 1000 F-16, as well as some of the world's most advanced SAM capabilities, couple of Aegis destroyers with SM-3 missiles are probably enough to blow up any air force out of the sky at this point. The F-15 fleet it has is split between the F-15 C/D which are still classified as air superiority fighters to the F-15E which is classified as a strike fighter, the C/D versions are being phased out and are replaced with the F-22 so yes technically the F-22 is taking over the air defense role of the US and the 190 F-15's they had (excluding the strike eagle) are being replaced with the 188 F-22 they've build. But i still don't see the argument you are trying to make here.
- 11y ago