4 ms·
That's often how technological progress works: it's developed to solve either a pressing-but-not-so-noble problem and then someone adapts it so the average pers
by nostrademons 11y ago
That's often how technological progress works: it's developed to solve either a pressing-but-not-so-noble problem and then someone adapts it so the average person can benefit, or it's developed to solve a trivial and useless problem and someone improves it so it's useful to the average person.
We built radar so we could detect German bombers; we got microwave ovens from it. We built GPS so we could guide missiles and spy satellites; we got turn-by-turn navigation and Uber out of it. We built Twitter so we could send 140-character text messages; we got the Arab Spring out of it. We built the ARPANet to coordinate top-secret military projects; we got the Internet out of it. We built PCs to play games; we got Visicalc, Word, and all sorts of productivity boosts from it. We built computers to break German codes and guide artillery shells; you know where that went.
- timr 11y agoI'm so tired of the thoughtless repetition of this talking-point. Yes, some technologies developed serendipitously for luxury products. But when you take a broader view than the latter half of the 20th century, most of the technological progress that actually made our lives better were the results of targeted effort: wastewater treatment, antibiotics, essentially all medications. We didn't get to these things accidentally. Maybe those technologies were expensive at first and came down in price with adoption, but that's different than making the claim that if we just work on whatever rich people want today, we'll automatically get to places that are beneficial for society. Want to help the third-world feed itself? Perhaps you should invest your resources in that, not in a silicon valley nutri-shake startup. Hell, most of your examples are cases where the military did something to solve a known problem that was too expensive (or too speculative) to be left to private industry. How you turn that into an argument that our best-and-brightest should be working on ad-optimization eludes me. This industry, I swear: we whine about the loss of space exploration, and wonder what happened to our flying cars, but we brush off criticisms when someone invests millions of dollars in the sixty-seventh niche food-delivery service for the SF bay area. Perhaps the two things are related?
- afarrell 11y agoAn example of a startup doing work for the developing world is Wave, focusing on helping people send remittances to family in west Africa. http://www.sendwave.com/ http://www.sendwave.com/
- silverthorn 11y agoThat's great! And it's not even an exceptional case. There are lots of tech-related companies with an explicit social and developing-world focus, including many in SF---such as our company, Angaza, which makes it possible for emerging-market consumers to get much more energy for much less money through decentralized solar http://www.angazadesign.com/watch-video/ http://www.angazadesign.com/watch-video/ (obligatory: http://careers.stackoverflow.com/company/angaza/ http://careers.stackoverflow.com/company/angaza/) and many, many others, e.g. https://welldone.org/ https://welldone.org/ http://saner.gy/ http://saner.gy/ http://wecyclers.com/ http://wecyclers.com/ http://www.allpowerlabs.com/ http://www.allpowerlabs.com/ ... not to mention areas of "SF tech proper" with a direct positive impact, such as medtech or cleantech.
- timr 11y agoI'm glad to hear about these sorts of things. The world seems like a slightly less shallow place!
- jchrisa 11y agoI've been working on p2p sync since 2008 or so. Now we have a real deployed base. I feel lucky because I chose the tech for it's political possibilities. This keeps me on track on the days when it'd be hard to focus otherwise.
- simoncion 11y agoWhat's the p2p sync software that you've been working on for the past seven years? (This is a part/spare-time project, yes?)
- seanp2k2 11y agohttp://www.herecomestheairplane.co http://www.herecomestheairplane.co On a more serious note, you have services which will e.g. Wheel in your bins for you, or manage your grocery delivery and housekeeping services so you never have to see the people doing the work.