6 ms·
Interesting. I never knew about this, and it certainly isn't true of Southwest today. These days they're the cattle-car of airlines, with their lack of assign
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Interesting. I never knew about this, and it certainly isn't true of Southwest today. These days they're the cattle-car of airlines, with their lack of assigned seating.
I found this bit particularly interesting, though:
> Today, the task of getting in and out of the gate in 10 minutes is impossible — but back then, says reporter Terry Maxon, the 10-Minute Turn saved the airline.
What makes it so impossible? Airport security has gotten far worse, but that's long before the gate. At the gate, what makes this less possible than it was back then?
- skrebbel 11y agoPure guess: they were already driving the plane to the runway while people were still getting settled, and similarly they'd take people's luggage down while navigating to the airport. These days, I assume there are regulations that disallow anybody to move until the plane is at a full standstill. I wonder why, though. Seems to me like an airplane on the ground is a lot safer to stand in than a fully packed bus in a busy city. Any ideas?
- daurnimator 11y agoThe scale difference in airplanes can be massive. see accidents like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Yx7aNdGYZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Yx7aNdGYZo
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 11y agoMy first thought: you would not want luggage blocking aisles if there's an accident on the ground. Also, aircraft (and trains) are held to a far greater safety standard. Yesterday's bus crash [1] is unlikely to have much investigation, never mind a change to driving practices, road engineering, law enforcement, or anything else. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/28/belgium-coach-crash-british-schoolchildren http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/28/belgium-coach-c...
- icc97 11y agoYou have to wonder how such a crash can happen on clear, dry open roads in good weather. Buses never travel that fast, nor will they have reckless drivers. There's a slight irony in that the coach is made by Van Hool which is a Belgian company - and make very good coaches from what I know. Belgium has a slightly mad thing that they allow buses full of people without seat belts / standing to travel at 50 mph along the motorways.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "Belgium has a slightly mad thing that they allow buses full of people without seat belts / standing to travel at 50 mph along the motorways." I don't think that's specific to Belgium. Even when I was travelling to high school in the UK 8 years ago they would account for standing room when deciding how many buses were required. So you had a bus full of kids all seated and then standing from the front to the back without room to move and the bus going as fast as 60mph. I never really thought of the safety implications but looking back it seems very stupid.
- imrehg 11y agoSame as back in Hungary, travelling between my home town and university (2h bus ride), and often people were spilling over all the way to the lower steps inside of the door (that means carrying people almost at 2x seat capacity)... Just crazy...
- mseebach 11y ago> Seems to me like an airplane on the ground is a lot safer to stand in than a fully packed bus in a busy city. Any ideas? A plane is designed to fly sitting passengers, a city bus is designed to drive standing passengers. A driving plane has very poor suspension - it's bumpy and the bumps are leveraged by the tall landing gears. Inside the plane, people won't just be standing, they will be unpacking the overhead lockers, handing around heavy luggage over people's heads. Busses don't have overhead storage for heavy items, probably for this exact reason.
- ProCynic 11y agoActually, having no assigned seats is the fastest way to board a plane. https://www.math.duke.edu/news/awards/mcm2007bbe.pdf https://www.math.duke.edu/news/awards/mcm2007bbe.pdf
- allard 11y agoI tried to engage Southwest about this algorithm and it (email) was like talking to a brick wall.
- PMan74 11y ago> with their lack of assigned seating. I'm pretty sure unassigned seating has been proven to be the fastest way to load an aircraft in practice. > what makes this less possible than it was back then? I'm not sure, I'd guess there are controls in place now that were not in place then e.g. passenger manifest reconciliation for security, ID checks, etc. Ryanair (European Southwest essentially) target 25 minutes. If there were a way to do if faster I think they'd have found it.
- jedrek 11y agoMore like: if they haven't found it, it's not for a lack of trying.
- tomarr 11y ago> I'm pretty sure unassigned seating has been proven to be the fastest way to load an aircraft in practice. I would disagree with this. My experience is of low-cost operators in Europe (Ryanair, Easyjet, Wizz etc.), and I believe their experiences have been the opposite. Whilst most of the carriers used to operate on an unassigned seating basis, with fees for reserved seating, now seating is 'randomly' assigned at online check-in (although if possible groups are sat together). You can still pay for reserved seating but the benefit is obviously a lot less now. My anecdotal evidence is that this has massively quickened the boarding process. Before, there would be delays waiting for people to sort out their seating and luggage arrangements (families especially), now it is much less of an issue and turnaround times are quicker. It's also possible that the massive increase in people taking only hand-luggage in recent years has been a factor, but I'm not sure.
- dhimes 11y agoI guess maybe the practical limits of traveler behavior trump the theoretical ideal? The mathematical solution to boarding passengers was examined a while back: http://phys.org/news/2008-02-board-plane.html http://phys.org/news/2008-02-board-plane.html
- imglorp 11y ago> although if possible groups are sat together At times they have taken this to a new low: upselling the benefit of sitting together. The seat assignment algorithm is probably optimizing profit, not retaining groups. http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2014/07/30/airlines-and-parents-play-chicken-in-unfriendly-skies/ http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2014/07/30/airlines-and-parent...
- massysett 11y agoProbably that these days the company actually complies with safety regulations. Apparently back then the flight attendants were pulling luggage from bins right after the plane hit the ground. Passengers were lined up outside before the plane even hit the ground. The plane was pushing back and starting to taxi before passengers were even seated. I doubt any of this complies with safety regulations.
- discardorama 11y ago> Probably that these days the company actually complies with safety regulations. Or maybe in those days these regulations did not exist?
- JadeNB 11y ago> Passengers were lined up outside before the plane even hit the ground. This sounds like an unpleasant experience, but I don't see how it's a safety violation. (It's certainly not at all uncommon when flying today to have the boarding lines at least partially formed before the arriving plane touches down.) What did sound unsafe to me was having passengers deplaning and boarding at the same time.
- xenophonf 11y agoThe flight line is not a safe place for civilians to stand while an airplane taxis in.
- JadeNB 11y agoSorry, I missed a key word: > Passengers were lined up outside before the plane even hit the ground. (emphasis mine). Someone else mentioned that 'modern-day' boarding is through a climate-controlled jet bridge; that's all I've known, so I didn't consider any other approach.
- angersock 11y ago...which in turn leads to the question: what did the safety regulations succeed in doing, exactly, other than slowing down these boarding times?
- zyx321 11y agoIn addition to the safety concerns: Larger planes, and "larger" passengers.
- wtbob 11y agoI too found that bit about how a 10-minute turn is now impossible to be pretty interesting. Which struggling airlines would now fail due to the (presumed) regulations which prevent a 10-minute turn? Which enterprises have failed in general due to those regulations? Has the cost in destroyed capital been made up for in lives and property saved? I'm curious, because, 'don't move around while the plane is moving' sounds like a sensible regulation, but a world without Southwest Airlines would be worse. When is the benefit worth the cost?
- bbanyc 11y agoIt's not the specific "10-minute turn" that's the key, it's having a faster turn than the competition. The regulations affect everyone equally, and if Southwest has a 25-minute turn while other airlines can only manage a 35-minute turn that's still a win. Also keep in mind that some airline regulations were much more strict in the 1970s - all routes and fares had to be approved in advance by the Civil Aeronautics Board and competition on price was nonexistent. Southwest was exempt from these regulations because they only operated within Texas.
- genericuser 11y agoNow it is entirely my personal guess, but back in the day you actually had legroom and seats that reclined on planes. Now that extra room has been taken up by more seats. It is my belief that this condition, could explain a large portion of the time increase. As more seats leads to the combination of more people needing to board the same size aircraft, them needing to squeeze into smaller spaces (get up after sitting if they sat down before someone to their inside), and less room per person for carry on luggage so they sometimes need to find a overhead bin not directly above their row. As commentators have pointed out security at the gate probably has also increased time, I think number of seats per aircraft could also be a contributing factor.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoThe gate security slowdown is irrelevant because there is inevitably a backup at the door of the plane for all but the early boarders.
- dreamcompiler 11y agoBesides the safety issues others have described, it also used to be possible to board new passengers from the back door while the previous passengers departed from the front. All it required was two sets of stairs to the tarmac. Now that almost all planes board via climate-controlled jet bridges, I presume it's too expensive to use two of them at the same time.
- stcredzero 11y agoConsidering how miserable many flights are, lots of people would jump at the chance to get out the back door and get out of the plane faster.
- sliverstorm 11y agoI always wind up in the back of the plane, and I would give a lot to not have to stand in the aisle watching person after person in front take their sweet goddamn time- talking on the phone, unpacking their luggage, having an argument, or just daydreaming- as they block the entire disembarkment.
- Symbiote 11y agoEuropean airlines often board from both doors, though they wait until the incoming passengers have left. This is more common with but not limited to budget airlines. Example: https://goo.gl/maps/FvLVB https://goo.gl/maps/FvLVB — you can see there are no jet bridges at all at the budget-airline-only LTN.
- strictnein 11y agoPlanes are bigger these days as well.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoWhen I was a kid, I don't remember anyone with anything but trivial carry-ons (purses, little bags, etc). Now, there's this fight to see how much we can stuff we can cram in for free to avoid checked luggage charges. Everyone has a bag and another bag with a laptop or somesuch. Everyone is trying to fit the biggest bag they possibly can into the overhead. This all costs time. The weird part is that Southwest accepts checked bags for free, but I still see people doing this. I imagine there's an element of habit here and also a, "Why wait for luggage, I'll just bring everything with me and then go straight to a cab." I know I've fallen for that temptation before, but only after having my luggage lost twice in one year. Now I'm one of those people who often stuffs the largest bag he can find onto the overhead. Losing luggage for just 1 or 2 days on a 3 or 4 day trip really sucks. Suddenly I have no clean clothes, whatever electronics I packed, etc. I also never understood the fast boarding time gimmick. Sure, its nice, but I usually fly out of O'Hare or Midway, where there's always a long wait after boarding anyway as we wait for an available slot to take off. Usually 20-30 minutes from after doors are sealed. All that rushing was for nothing. I imagine things are better in airports outside of Chicago, NYC, LA, or Atlanta, but for me its a lot of silliness. Especially now that there's this early boarder fee which is just a reinvention of the assigned seating ticket, but crappier because now I'm paying my ticket AND that fee just so I don't sit in the middle seat.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts kind of like prisoners' dilemma: if you don't play the luggage game, you just lose.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI tend to pack that way myself, but I also pack far less than I used to, especially for international trips. So I bring a rolling bag and a laptop bag, but the rolling bag is well within the carry-on size, and the laptop bag is only just big enough for my laptop, power supply, and a handful of essentials.
- hackuser 11y ago> What makes it so impossible? Southwest flies 737s, which hold around 100 people (says Wikipedia). I can't imagine getting 100 people off a plane and then another 100 back on, plus stowing/unstowing baggage, all in 10 minutes. Maybe that's why Southwest offers free checked baggage, to reduce the time passengers spend handling carryons.
- maccard 11y agoI fly Ryanair fairly frequently, their turnaround time from landing to takeoff can't be much more than 30 minutes.
- genericuser 11y agoAnd that was the original model and configuration which was released, since then we have seen variations of model and configuration with up to 215 seats on a 737 according to wikipedia.