7 ms·
When a Company Is Put Up for Sale, in Many Cases, Your Personal Data Is, Too
- globuous 11y agoI was talking about this with a friend of mine no earlier than yesterday. We were discussing about how Facebook Messenger doesn't need an account anymore, but only your phone number. For years I tried to not give my phone number to Facebook (for various reasons, but I knew I'd someday "need" to give them my number). Well turns out they've had my phone number associated with my name ever since they bought Whatsapp. Along with all the conversations I've had on this service probably. This article definitely points something that should be kept in mind when uploading personal info online, althout this isn't anything too new.
- dunkelheit 11y agoWell the case of phone number information is even more devilish - it is in the phonebooks of your (not so privacy-savvy) friends so you have almost no control over it.
- robmcm 11y agoThis is the worst part about your contact details, just think about the number of times you get those spam emails when one of their accounts gets hacked, not to mention address books mobile APIs. Now think about how they often contain your home address, birthday, spouces, photos etc...
- castell 11y agoI was about to join Whatsapp but heard rumors that FB is about to buy it, back then. I am still on FB and never gave FB my number, and never joined Whatsapp. Though FB has my number (hidden from me on), as many of my friends uploaded or sync their address book (FB app and Whatsapp). [FB is just an example]
- austenallred 11y agoIs this a surprise? If a company buys yours, does anyone expect them to buy everything expect for the information on their customers? That gets nasty if a company is selling only the data, but the legalese that allows companies to sell data to whomever may be buying the company shouldn't come as a surprise.
- QuantumRoar 11y agoIt's not about it being a surprise that this happens as long as it is allowed. It's a surprise that there are no laws in place to protect consumers. Especially in times when most "tech savvy" people advice the use of cloud services for backups, syncing, sharing and communication, a sale of a company becomes a privacy nightmare for those who listened and tried out these services. There should be more people that spell out that it is not safe to upload your data to someone else's computer. Would you upload a backup of your data to my computer? Of course not. Would you do it if I made an over-designed one page website and offered an iOS/Android app? There are a lot who do that every day. Once the deed is done, I shouldn't be allowed to do whatever the hell I want with your data. Selling or sharing data with third parties should be strictly opt-in, no matter the circumstances. Imagine your Dropbox, Password manager or backups being sold to the highest bidder. A company which you previously trusted becomes greedy and sells you out. There's nothing you can do about it because "you should have read the small print 10 years ago, when you started using the service." It's not surprising that there are people who'd sell you out. What is surprising is that it is allowed.
- rodgerd 11y ago> Is this a surprise? According to studies cited in the last week on HN, yes. People underestimate the sociopathy of the corporate world. Or perhaps expect more European norms to apply. > If a company buys yours, does anyone expect them to buy everything expect for the information on their customers? Pretty much everyone in the western world that isn't the United States expects that because it's enforced by law. Although US companies are trying to get their proxies in the US government to have that stripped away as a "trade barrier".
- dunkelheit 11y agoI wonder how much of the price of the big acquisitions of recent years (e.g. instagram, whatsapp) is justified by the value of personal data.
- LoSboccacc 11y agowell, outdated, but personal data and its quality has indeed a value: http://www.statista.com/statistics/289505/social-networks-value-per-active-user/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/289505/social-networks-va... also user generates revenue by themselves http://www.technologyreview.com/article/424650/how-much-is-a-user-worth/ http://www.technologyreview.com/article/424650/how-much-is-a... edit: updated link to more recent stats
- beagle3 11y agoYes. Which is why you should never trust a company with info you wouldn't trust their competitor (or any other company for that matter), regardless of how kitten-loving and un-evil they are today.
- RyanZAG 11y agoIt hardly even matters if the company is put up for sale. Assume a kitten-loving company that will rather die than let your data be abused. They take VC funding, hit a bad turn, take more VC funding. Now the board is controlled by VCs. You're now trusting the VCs with your data and not the company itself. Assume a second kitten-loving company that will rather die than let your data be abused, and is run by only two co-founders. You give them all your data. The two co-founders end up in a plane crash. Their company is transferred to... who knows really? Your data is now sold off in liquidation to.. who knows really?
- mcv 11y agoThis is why we need data protection laws. No matter how trustworthy a company is, you can never really trust them.
- tempodox 11y agoThe most important point here is that the company that originally collected the data isn't that relevant. If other laws don't support privacy protection, you must assume your data may end up just about anywhere & everywhere.
- icebraining 11y agoWe do have laws that support privacy protection around here, and I still assume it may end up just about anywhere. Data is just too easy to copy around. What these laws give me is the power to tell those companies to delete it, and to get our National Commission for Data Protection to fine them if I ever get evidence that they didn't. But I would never assume the data is actually protected.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Assume a second kitten-loving company that will rather die than let your data be abused, and is run by only two co-founders. You give them all your data. The two co-founders end up in a plane crash. Their company is transferred to... who knows really? Your data is now sold off in liquidation to.. who knows really? At least in theory, that's possible to avoid. If you accepted the data only under a specific set of terms, and ensured either that the original terms under which data was obtained are those that apply, or that specific privacy and usage terms were required to survive into any successor agreement, then in doing so you'd bind any future owner of the company by the same terms. You can't sell (or liquidate) something you don't have the rights to yourself.
- bearwithclaws 11y agoThis is one of the reasons I didn't put Hacker Monthly up for sale when I've decided to shut it down. Our subscribers (a little over 10k) trusted us enough to provide us their contact information (and mailing address for print delivery). Turning them over to 3rd party (even after due diligence) just didn't seem right.
- bearwithclaws 11y agoThis is one of the reasons I didn't put Hacker Monthly up for sale when I've decided to shut it down. Our subscribers (a little over 10k) trusted us enough to provide us their contact information (and mailing address for print delivery). Turning them over to 3rd party (even after due diligence) just didn't seem right.
- digital-rubber 11y agoReally? People are honestly surprised by this? This isn't anything new.
- jensen123 11y agoIf I want to buy ebooks, games, music, movies etc. online, it's extremely difficult to find a company that actually respects my privacy (as opposed to just saying they respect my privacy - plenty of those). I wonder, if I bought myself one of those Visa giftcards, and just made up a fake name and address, would that be any problem? Would I be breaking any laws or anything?
- __z 11y agoI've tried a few times to pay for stuff online using gift cards and the transaction was always declined (n=3)
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's actually a good case. When a company goes bust your personal data could end up anywhere.
- amelius 11y agoI sure hope Google never goes up for sale.
- rayiner 11y agoThe bigger issue is bankruptcy. Creditors will look to sell any assets that can be monetized, and given the nature of the proceeding, the court will have a lot of discretion in allowing them to do so, much more so than a private purchaser.
- DevPad 11y agoSome time ago I participated in some Startup Accelerator. Was part of Startup with really fast growing user base, but small amount of sales. What some investors really suggested to do with our database - is to sell it! So companies can sell personal data (and they do it) not only when put up for sale, but at any time.
- rwhitman 11y agoIf you submit personal information to any business you're putting yourself at risk. Social media companies have a lot of data, yes, but most of it is pretty benign. The world should be far more concerned about the PII that gets transmitted around less tech-savvy smaller businesses and non-profits. Particularly for-profit education companies. Education companies have gobs of very sensitive info like social security numbers, previous addresses, family relationships with full contact info, medical history etc and many of them are clueless when it comes to privacy and data security. Not only are they at high risk for data breaches but their lists can also get acquired and traded when the business changes hands.
- nocarrier 11y agoI'm guessing everyone who works at a big company and used Secret was hoping that said big company didn't acquire Secret's assets when they folded. It does always make me think twice before committing to using a startup's product, you never know who is going to fail and sell assets to the highest bidder, or who is going to get acquired by a big company whose ideals you don't like. The problem is that oftentimes, the data is one of a company's most valuable assets, so you can't just make it off-limits since that would erase a lot of the value. I just wish there was a better legal framework to handle these kinds of situations.
- VOYD 11y agoConsidering so many companies whole business model is based on personal data, this not a surprise. Seriously, how could Uber be valued so high without every customers personal info being sold off to the highest bidder.