6 ms·
From what I can tell as a non-expert, kids cannot learn certain things very well until they reach a certain age or maturity, but after that age it's very easy.
by lordnacho 11y ago
From what I can tell as a non-expert, kids cannot learn certain things very well until they reach a certain age or maturity, but after that age it's very easy.
My gripe with the education system is that early on, there's too much focus on learning things that people are going to learn regardless. If your kid learns the alphabet at 4 or at 8, what's the difference? Can anyone not learn how to read a newspaper by the time they leave school?
Later on, when the kids get to the teenage years, they are able to learn a great deal of stuff. But then nobody is really teaching them when they can learn. There's a whole load of scientific stuff that's quite interesting that ends up getting crammed into a few years of high school, and crammed in a way that turns kids off. And culture classes (literature, history) are so horrific some people never pick up another book.
There's also not enough emphasis on motivation. The emphasis is on passing tests. If you're motivated, you can learn anything. You'll even spend your own time and money learning. My guess is the home schoolers have figured this out and that's why they're not that far behind ordinary schools.
- macspoofing 11y ago>There's also not enough emphasis on motivation. The emphasis is on passing tests. If you're motivated, you can learn anything. My problem with education is that there is no 'one-size-fits-all' policy. Some kids fail hard in a structured system that puts emphasis on passing tests, other thrive in it but fail in a less structured 'find-your-own-motivation' system. Like a pendulum we just keep swinging back and forth and realize we keep missing a portion of the kids. I don't know how you fix it because it's expensive to tailor education to a kid. I guess it's all up to the parents.
- codingdave 11y agoYour last sentence is exactly how you fix it - as parents, you are responsible for each child's education. We have, at times, homeschooled each child, and also sent each of them to school, exactly because of the issues you and the other comment raised. They went to kindergarten to learn how to listen to people other than their parents and make friends. My social daughter came home for 6 months, then went right back to public school. My introverted and shy son came home for 2 years, and is going back to school this coming year because we're not doing well at teaching him... we see our failures there, and don't want to exaggerate them any more. Plus, he wants more friends, too. We expect they will probably all skip jr. high, as they will be old enough to learn on their own, and the social scene is just painful at the age, and then I'll leave it to them if they want to do the high school experience, or just get a GED and move on to other adventures in their teens. There also are online teacher-led schools in most states now. Both private and public There are home schooling groups that meet together so each parent can teach a groups of kids in their areas of expertise. There are online curriculum you can purchase, and hard copy curriculum. On short, there are choices. Many, many choices. As parents, we need to help our children find the path that is right for each one of them, and it is a more complex decision than a one-time choice to either home school or attend the public schools. As in most things, a middle ground is often a better, if more complex, answer.
- zanny 11y ago> I'll leave it to them if they want to do the high school experience This is incredibly valuable, I think. The option to leave a toxic environment. My best years in public education were the year I broke my knees and was deemed unfit to attend class for the second half of the year - necessitating a three day a week visit from my science teacher to give me an hour of tutelage. Not being around my insanely hostile 8th grade peers got me a semester of straight As and I got the highest score in the class on the algebra one final without even being there. The other best year was 12th grade, when I took 4 AP courses and study halls. I'd be with good instructors, small class sizes, and peers who were as motivated to succeed as I was. Even honors programs are the domains of parents shoving their kids into the classes through brute force of aggravation with the principal - they just don't want to hear that their kids do not want that, they need their kids to be in honors classes. And they end up ruining those classes for any teacher that gives a damn and for the kids who are there of their own will. The only important thing to take away is that even an 18 year old is making incredibly short sighted mistakes. If I ever have kids, they would need to consistently want to either reenter school or leave it to make such a switch of their own volition. It has to be a decision not only made over the long term but its ramifications need to be absorbed over such a term. I would almost certainly never throw them through the public school imagination crusher, unless I had incredible faith in the school. I'd rather go bankrupt hiring private tutors and getting them peer exposure at recreation centers and extracurriculars.
- jessaustin 11y agoI guess it's all up to the parents. It would be no panacea if most children's education were up to their parents, but it would be a marked improvement on the current USA public schools model, which is, "We teach one way and if your kid can't learn that's her or his problem." Always vote for more school choice.
- macspoofing 11y agoIt doesn't have to be an either-or. Even in a crappy school district, parental involvement will play a huge difference!!
- skolor 11y agoThere's quite a bit of research to support this[1]. Basically, regardless of any other factors, increased parental involvement consistently shows better performance. [1] https://www.nea.org/tools/17360.htm https://www.nea.org/tools/17360.htm
- SiVal 11y agoHomeschooling in the US works out much better now than it did in the time the article describes, because the government did something out of character: it actually returned some liberty to parents that it had taken from them. When parents were once again allowed to homeschool their own children legally, a diverse free market in educational resources re-emerged--one that had flourished in the early days of the country. Now that there is no longer a reason to operate secretly, homeschooling parents can seek out other parents with similar homeschooling objectives and cooperate. Among the first to do this were religious parents, but every year the percentage of homeschoolers who do it for religious reasons declines. More and more parents are doing it for reasons such as wanting to give their bright kids more advanced classes than the schools are willing or able to provide (that's my own incentive), or to more effectively deal with a child's specific educational needs, or to allow a child to have a "career" (e.g., acting or sports) while still a minor. Even those of us sending our kids to public schools benefit from this market in homeschooling options. We would be able to benefit a lot more if the "progressive" politicians employed by the teachers unions to keep the decision-making power and money they have wrested from the people from ever reverting back to parents weren't so numerous and well-funded. Many of us, for example, would love to switch to a partial public / partial private arrangement where our kids could sign up for some of the school classes without being forced to take all or none (while paying full price either way). For example, we might choose PE, sports, and drama (for social), science (for lab facilities), and math (parents might not know it well enough) from school, but choose to do English at home, programming online, art at a local art school, and Chinese from a parents' collective. (And I would be willing to continue paying full fare for the public school while using only part of its program if the remainder were rebated, not to me, but to low-income families in the form of educational vouchers they could use outside school.) We can do many of those things after school, but the problem is how late "after school" is each day, and how much time after school has to be wasted on useless school homework, because of the requirement that if our kids want any of the benefits the school offers, they are forced to take it all (as part of the political strategy to make opting out of any of the government-controlled system as painful and impractical as possible.) My kids' desire for the social experience of school and my desire that they get excellent educations result in a very long day for them, and I would cut out more than half of their school classes (and even more of the homework) if I were free to do so and give it to my kids as play time. Full socialization from partial school, higher-quality education from the free market, plus more play time? Still illegal in most states.
- shiro 11y agoYup, it doesn't mean much to teach alphabets to 4yr old, but I also observe that kids don't just become a competent reader spontaneously. Some kids do---just provide them access to books and they naturally pick them up---but some don't. I thought immersing them with literature and stimulating their curiosity were enough, but I was wrong.
- lostlogin 11y agoI went a Steiner school - much of what you describe sounds like the positive stuff of Steiners. I'm guessing you already know this?
- icc97 11y agoI'm very interested in the approach to teaching science at Stiener schools. From what I read the various studies [1] showed that there was no little difference in the results for kids. But I consistently get the feeling the the type of parents who send their children to Steiner schools aren't very interested in science so it isn't a focus for the school. Did you ever try comparing the way you were taught science with friends at non-steiner schools? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Studies_of_Waldorf_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Studies_of_Waldorf_education
- lostlogin 11y agoWe definitely had less science taught to us, particularly physics. I'm a bit more informed about stained glass window making, bee keeping etc. My thought would be that an ideal combo would be a Steiner school until age 10-12 ish. After that I have no idea. The state system just seems to run continual exams, tests and assessments. To put this in perspective, I had sat probably 2 real exams before finishing school.
- icc97 11y agoThank you that's very helpful. I really like the Steiner architecture, the buildings at the school I'm going to send my daughter too looked wierd at first but you feel much more relaxed around them (and the beehives :)) rather than the concrete blocks that seem to make up the rest of the schools
- lostlogin 11y agoWait until you see the artwork/more practical course work. Lead light windows, sculpture, metalwork, woodwork etc. The difference between the work that comes out of the (New Zealand) state system and the Steiner system is vastly different and (imho) Steiner students are more artistically developed. The absence of a formulaic approach is quite striking. My view is rather skewed however! The flip side is that I'm sitting here wishing I knew how to work logarithms properly.
- Udo 11y ago> If your kid learns the alphabet at 4 or at 8, what's the difference? It might make a big difference to the individual kid. One of my earliest memories is seeing how adults read words and numbers, I must have been between 4 and 5 years old. I asked my parents to show me how to do that and they replied "no, you'll learn this when you're older, this is not for you." Later in first grade, learning to read and write was no fun at all (I blame the teacher), and guess what: a good number of kids could already do it. Where would the harm have been in taking a few hours to teach me that stuff a couple of years earlier, when I first wanted to? This anecdote is about learning things early, but overall I agree with you that learning stuff gets massively easier at a later age. I never really understood math and physics until I was in my twenties and had the opportunity to explore the subjects on my own terms.
- celticninja 11y agoI think the point here is to teach when the student is ready and homeschooling allows the parents to do that. The issue was that your parents didn't teach you when you were ready. The original poster meant that if a child was not ready to learn to read until age 8 that would be OK, not to force them to delay learning until a specific age.
- Udo 11y agoYes, I thought I addressed that as well, sorry if I wasn't clear enough. I agree that the lesson here is that it goes both ways as far as timing and learning are concerned.
- xanderstrike 11y ago> teach when the student is ready What if the student is never "ready" though? As part of a project for a small Christian liberal arts college, I had access to anonymized data on admissions and class schedules. They accepted a great deal of homeschooled students. Can you guess what how many of them placed in remedial math classes? Many times more than their traditionally educated counterparts. The school was not big, these catch-up classes were full of kids home schooled by well meaning parents who never thought their kids were "ready" for basic mathematics. This is a colossal failure, when you get to college without knowing basic math, entire departments are simply closed to you. Interestingly, they often placed in line with their peers in language, with many placing highly in foreign languages as well. Maybe that says something about the priorities of the average parent of a homeschooler?
- lmm 11y ago> Can anyone not learn how to read a newspaper by the time they leave school? Yes, plenty of them. During WWII when they tested recruits something like 1/3 of them lacked basic literacy. It's probably better these days, but don't assume just everyone figures it out.
- kabdib 11y agoMy mom was an English teacher at several state colleges. She initially taught "remedial English" and it was pretty grim; in the 70s, athletic scholarship admissions were common, and she was teaching many 18 and 19 year olds at roughly the 8th grade level.
- jfoutz 11y agoEh, those kids grew up in the great depression. I'd bet at least some of them skipped school to work, if school was even available. No school bus, no weather radar, not necessarily even enough food. The school lunch program was founded (partly) because so many of those WWII recruits were malnourished. I think that stat is more of a testament to how far the U.S. has come.
- skolor 11y agoI don't have any good introspection into what this number means, but according to this (http://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reading_math_2013/#/state-performance http://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reading_math_2013/#/state-p...) 18% of 8th graders were found to be "Below basic" reading.
- zo1 11y agoI've had some rather unfortunate experiences with the local tertiary institution I attended here. The level of basic English literacy was appalling (in my small-sample of students I had to partner with for projects). You don't notice it when talking with someone. But as soon as you start asking them to write their thoughts down on paper (or file), garbage comes out. I have no other way to describe the type of language I saw. Everything from no punctuation, incorrect grammar, run-on sentences, slang. Sentences that just seem to be stuck together, whether due to missing punctuation or something else I don't know. Oh, and that was when their point was valid/related. These individuals got degrees.
- nationcrafting 11y ago>If your kid learns the alphabet at 4 or at 8, what's the difference? It's a huge difference. As soon as a kid can read, they can learn in a way that isn't just you telling them stuff. They can self-direct their learning, read books about stuff, go online and devour Wikipedia, etc. It's not just "hey, can anyone not read a newspaper by the time they leave school?", it's "how soon does this kid have the tool to satisfy their natural curiosity about things that require more than someone telling them about it?" which establishes their relationship with learning itself, with knowing how to learn.
- lordnacho 11y agoBut they can learn to read before they know the alphabet by heart. Learning the alphabet is just a weird thing we do that has no intrinsic value. Similarly, there's a lot of math that you can touch before you are entirely certain of the lower level stuff.
- jacalata 11y agoHow can you read without knowing all the letters?
- zo1 11y agoI think they're referring to reciting the alphabet. And reading is much more than just "knowing all the letters". It's context, shapes of words themselves, etc. I'm not an expert on any of these things, mind you. Just that I learnt to speak and read my home-tongue without ever being able to memorize its alphabet. Now that I think about it, I still can't recite it, yet I speak/write the language fluently.
- schoen 11y agoThere is a theory that we can read by recognizing the entire shape of a word without processing individual letters within it ("gestalt recognition"). If I understand correctly, this is the same as or similar to the "lexical route" of perceiving words without sounding them out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-route_hypothesis_to_reading_aloud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-route_hypothesis_to_readi... I'm pretty sure I learned to read mostly this way, with a big assist from having adults read aloud to me and so memorizing particular stories and then recognizing the appearance of the written words within those stories. Learning about all the letters might have come afterward, and helped me to understand why words are spelled as they are, and also to acquire the "non-lexical route" of systematically sounding out words I didn't know. Reading acquisition is a pretty complicated process, and I think if we're not teachers or psychologists we might forget that there are so many sub-parts in this process, and that they might also happen in a different order for different children.