3 ms·
"Creativity is doing something new and interesting" Uh, I don't doubt that this kind of sentiment arises when one has worked with robots for a while and done s
by joe_the_user 11y ago
"Creativity is doing something new and interesting"
Uh, I don't doubt that this kind of sentiment arises when one has worked with robots for a while and done some impressive stuff but had them consistently fail to inspire a feeling of interestingness in one.
But the statement itself is, ironically, neither new nor interesting since beyond interestingness being something people sense, the statement gives one not a clue what the criteria is for determining its presence. And a remarkable number of critiques of AI by very insightful people come down to a kind of vitalism - come down to a long, round-about way of saying "robots just don't that special something".
And, of course, humans so far have failed in producing a wide range of human-like behaviors in robots and programs. There is something of a psychological tendency to take everything a computer can do and deprecate relative to everything a computer can't do - playing chess was once something people imagined would involve "intelligence" but now no longer do, etc.
All that said, I'd like to shout-out for Douglas Hofstadters' Fluid Analogies [1] approach, which actually makes an effort to describe and define some aspects of creativity.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_Concepts_and_Creative_Analogies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_Concepts_and_Creative_An...
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoAlso, this isn't comparing like for like - because you're comparing the most exceptional and gifted individuals out of a human population of billions with a single robot or piece of software. The vast majority of humans aren't particularly creative either. People who can do (e.g.) music a bit are maybe 25% of the population. Of those, most are imitators with enough technique and expression to successfully reproduce familiar tropes, but not to be inventive. Innovators are maybe 0.1% of the population - and that number is a complete guess, because so far as I know there's been absolutely no research into creativity in populations. So "that special something" is rare already. The problem with computational creativity is that success is partly social and psychological - new tropes have to capture the imagination in some way, and it's very difficult for a machine with no model of human emotional and psychological responses to calibrate its output to meet that goal.
- svantana 11y agoNot only that, but the specialness is totally in the eye of the beholder - one man's trash is another man's fine art. And if told that trash was painted by a certain Mr Picasso, perceptions might change rather quickly. There's a reason the scientific method is so important -- it's the best way we know not to fool ourselves all the time.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoPicasso didn't produce trash because he couldn't paint. He could paint and draw incredibly well. But he got very bored by painting incredibly well before he hit 20. Everything after that was one attempt after another to invent new visual languages for painting. The cultural value of those attempts is completely different to the resale auction value of a Picasso, which is driven entirely by market speculation and the fact that highly rated artworks are treated as a convenient store of value - rather like gold, but more compact and lighter. Cultural value is probably best measured by influence. On that basis Picasso scores very high, as one of the creators of abstracted figurative art. That trope remains mysterious to people who believe painting should be about photo-accurate or easy-to-read figurative work, but it's been a huge driver of fine art and all kinds of commercial illustration.