12 ms·
While this is excellent news for my gay and lesbian friends, I see no progress on polygamy. Which, unlike same-sex marriage, is an institution with deep roots
by samatman 11y ago
While this is excellent news for my gay and lesbian friends, I see no progress on polygamy.
Which, unlike same-sex marriage, is an institution with deep roots both in America (the Mormons were forced to give up this sacrament as a condition of statehood) and in the majority of world cultures, where it ranges from condoned to celebrated.
Without getting unduly personal, let's say that I have a stake in that question being resolved. I know several triples living quietly among us; they face the same kind of problems (child custody, hospital visitation, inheritance rights) as same-sex couples faced prior to this decision.
What the polygamists of the nation lack is a powerful lobby. <shrug> One may hope that nonetheless, reason and freedom will prevail here as well.
EDIT: nation, not world. Worldwide the situation is different. America is suffering from its Christian legacy here. Most Christian countries are adamant about denying this right to their citizens.
- XorNot 11y agoAny relationship grouping that is greater then 2 requires very extensive legal changes before it becomes practical to implement. The law is incapable of addressing the possibility of a marriage which can outlast all it's original participants, for example.
- koverstreet 11y agoOne step at a time. It'll happen...
- baddox 11y ago> While this is excellent news for my gay and lesbian friends, I see no progress on polygamy. Or indeed, on the fundamental issue, which is the need to get permission from a tiny group of powerful people in order to get married.
- smackfu 11y ago...get permission from a tiny group of powerful people in order to get the government to recognize your marriage.
- baddox 11y agoThese people are part of government, so that's roughly equivalent. Different parts of government disagree about the details, but it appears they all agree that the government should get to decide who can get married.
- dublinben 11y agoPolygamy is a deeply troublesome arrangement, with a storied history of abuse. It has been steadily abandoned and outlawed as societies grant more legal rights and self-determination to women. There is simply no way to legally recognize poly* relationships under the law in a way that resembles binary marriage.
- baddox 11y ago> Polygamy is a deeply troublesome arrangement, with a storied history of abuse. As is traditional marriage, but to a much larger extent.
- _delirium 11y agoIn Europe in the modern era, the trend is more in the other direction: as society gains more respect for both men and women's choice of sexual self-determination, instead of being fixated on traditional opposite-sex, pair-courtship rituals, polyamorous relationships are becoming more accepted. They were once strongly disapproved of and even illegalized, but are now increasingly being seen as a legitimate personal choice. On the activist side, many (most?) LGBTQ organizations also include poly activists, especially the organizations which have a more left-wing flavor. I think the more likely path than legal polygamy, though, is to expand a more flexible set of legal arrangements for families, as a replacement for traditional marriage being the legal framework. The fact that a huge proportion of couples here (Denmark) no longer get married is already forcing that for another reason. Since many families which otherwise look traditional — long-term cohabitation of an opposite-sex couple, jointly raising children of which they're parents, etc. — don't get married, marriage as the organizing principle of families is becoming less relevant, so the law already has to start handling things differently.
- icebraining 11y agoSame in Portugal. People I know are already doing alternative celebrations to regular marriage, influenced in part by the cost - since marriage celebrations are expected to have certain elements (catering, dresses, etc) which these celebrations do without. "De facto unions" have existed (for both hetero and homosexual partners) for more than ten years already, and have many of the same rights as married couples, including inheritance, refusal do testify in court, etc.
- nate_meurer 11y agoPolygamy is a Christian institution. It was pointedly prescribed in the old testament. Modern anti-polygamists will argue that the old testament prescription was a matter of necessity, and that new testament language (particularly Paul's) prescribes monogamy, but to my eyes the new testament's position is pretty casual, while the old testament's is quite strong.
- ziotom78 11y ago> Polygamy is a Christian institution. It was pointedly prescribed in the old testament. Correction: "Christian" refers to Jesus Christ, which does not appear in the old testament. Catholics, Ortodoxes and many protestant churches are against polygamy.
- nate_meurer 11y agoI'm not sure how to respond to this. Have you noticed that every complete Bible contains the Old Testament, including the Pentateuch in its entirety? Old Testament law and prophesy is woven deeply in the fabric of the gospels and of Paul's letters. And while most modern churches have chosen to interpret Paul's prescription for monogomy strictly, some Christian churches and cultures continue to embrace polygamy.
- ziotom78 11y ago> Have you noticed that every complete Bible contains the Old Testament, including the Pentateuch in its entirety? Yes, I already had noticed this. > Old Testament law and prophesy is woven deeply in the fabric of the gospels and of Paul's letters. Just for curiosity, have you ever happened to actually read the Bible? There are plenty of prescriptions in the Old Testament that are not followed by Jesus. Jesus presented himself as "The Truth", and he often said he was giving "a new commandment". To rest on Saturday, to stone an adulteress, to be forced to marry your brother's widow have never been Christian commandments. And polygamy enters in this list. The fact that for a small amount of time a small minority of Mormons (a small minority in the Christian world, less than 1% of the total) have accepted polygamy does not make this practice "Christian". Otherwise, if one follows the same line of reasoning, encyclopaedias should classify deers as "omnivorous", because in extreme conditions there have been reports of deers eating frogs and small mammals... EDIT: minor edits.
- venomsnake 11y ago>Without getting unduly personal, let's say that I have a stake in that question being resolved. I know several triples living quietly among us; they face the same kind of problems (child custody, hospital visitation, inheritance rights) as same-sex couples faced prior to this decision. I made that argument to a couple of friends - that they were not fighting for equality (which will be fairly easy to set up) but for inclusion in the privileged club. They responded with "Well marriage is between couples, but defining the sex of the participants is discriminatory". One of the problems with polygamy/andry is that we could hollow out the lower social classes of mating opportunities (it happens in india and china right now due to girl infanticide and it is not pretty). Anyway - congratulations to the winners.
- samatman 11y agoWorth noting that at least one of the triples I referred to is a woman and two men. At least one is a man and two women. I'm being vague here, because bigamy is a felony. We really have quite a long way to go on this front.
- knodi123 11y ago> I'm being vague here, because bigamy is a felony. I'm sure your vagueness is really slowing down the investigative arm of law enforcement that normally goes around searching the internet for evidence of dastardly polys.
- vacri 11y ago>I'm being vague here, because bigamy is a felony. Bigamy requires being officially married whilst already being officially married. The state already has records, by definition.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>One of the problems with polygamy/andry is that we could hollow out the lower social classes of mating opportunities And this doesn't already happen? M/Dating does not require marriage.
- edko 11y agoI would bet the biggest opposer to polygamy will be the INS ... imagine the Green Card businesses that would enable!
- asanagi 11y agoSeems like you don't have any idea how marriage-based immigration works. It's not as easy as "ok, you have a marriage license? Welp, you're in!" There are multiple interviews where they pick through every piece of evidence of a bona-fide relationship to establish that you haven't married for convenience. This continues even after you get your green card. If at any time they decide you attempted to defraud an immigrations official for any reason, they can come by and party van you.
- Pinckney 11y agoI would bet the biggest opposer to divorce will be the INS ... imagine the Green Card businesses that would enable! After all, it should make little difference to INS whether people choose to have their multiple marriages in series or in parallel.
- k__ 11y agoI'm poly and I'm more for abandoning marriage-laws all together and keep this stuff to religions.
- IanDrake 11y agoI have no problem with polygamy, as long as it is a consensual relationship between all adults involved. The real problem is that government has gotten into the marriage business and it doesn't belong there. The issues you mentioned (child custody, hospital visitation, inheritance rights) really have nothing to do with marriage and should all be assignable without a government endorsed marital contract.
- ufmace 11y agoThat's much more along the lines of what I think. It's kind of the libertarian dilemma - with Gay Marriage, there's one huge, loud camp of religious homophobic bigots demanding that big daddy Government say that Gay Marriage is an illegal abomination, and another huge, loud group of homosexual-rights activists demanding that big daddy Government say that Gay Marriage is a-ok and governments everywhere are required to perform it. It was never really about marriage or anything - it's about getting the Government to bless your side of the argument with a magical scepter of rightness. Meanwhile, my/our camp of libertarians saying hey, the Government really shouldn't be in the business of deciding who can be in what sort of relationship with who else or blessing either side of a controversial argument is disappointingly small and quiet and usually ignored.
- eropple 11y agoYou're not being ignored. Lots of people agree that, in an ideal world, the government not having a role in marriage would be a decent solution. This is not an ideal world and that political position is not feasible; in the art of the possible, that is not. On the other hand, we have people being harmed by the unreasonable jank thrown at homosexuals who wish to marry. The perfect must not be made the enemy of the good out of a sense of ideological purity.
- ufmace 11y agoWell, I do know that, which is why I'm not really all that against it. I'd like to see it happen a different way, but I can't see actually opposing it in any meaningful way, especially when it would inevitably mean allying with the types of people who are actively against it now - there's a lot of hate and negativity in that camp. The thing about Government power, though - everything seems all nice and cool when it's pointed in a direction that you like, and it makes everything happen real fast and lays the smack down on your ideological opponents. But that power can turn on a dime and get pointed right back at your side, as has happened a great many times in history. Think it can't happen here? I hope it never does, but it does have a nasty tendency to happen in places and to people where they thought it couldn't, where they keep on doing the simple and efficient thing, because that couldn't possibly ever happen to us, right?
- sgnelson 11y agoOne problem I have with Polygamy is that I have never seen a 1-woman, multi-husband community. Sure, I've seen a few relationships in which this was the case, but when you look at the historic aspects in the US, it seems a very rare thing. That makes me wonder if there is a severe power imbalance in the relationships and what is truly occurring. It's well known that in some modern US polygamy situations, there is a great deal of abuse of power, both in terms of controlling the wives, as well as controlling and abusing the young men who will not be allowed to have a wife. This further increases the societal costs and leads to more abuse of power, which is not what we need. edit: I should add: It's a numbers game. Given that on average, there tends to be just slightly more women born than men, what happens with all the extra unmarried men (or women, though this is rarer)?
- adventured 11y agoThat same concern already equally applies to traditional marriage, in which some % are abusive. If you have a problem with polygamy on that basis, then you've got a drastically larger problem with the already existing system of marriage, in which millions of instances of abuse occur annually. The best solution is to bring polygamy out into the open, legalize it fully nationally. The government has no business dictating who can get married, or what the structure of marriage looks like, so long as the people in question are of sound mind and adults. If I want to form a ten person marriage, with five men and five women, whose business is it to control us and stop us? There are only bigoted 'answers' as to why that shouldn't be allowed.
- lisper 11y agoNot that I necessarily disagree with legalizing polygamy, but I think there is one non-bigoted answer: logistics. Our financial system in general, and our tax system in particular, has N=1 or N=2 hard-coded into it. There are other practical considerations as well. Suppose, for example, you have an N=5 marriage and three of them want to break away and take the kids. Resolving situations like that would be much more complicated than what we have now, and what we have now is already plenty complicated.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoSaying it has deep roots in America is disingenuous, because Mormonism is the only religion, in a well defined geographical area to do so. There's a lot more to American religious (and demographic) history than Mormons. EDIT: And hasn't been a part of Ashkenazi Judaism for a millenium at least.
- lmm 11y agoMormonism is very much a part of America. The claim wasn't "it has deep roots everywhere in America".
- nutate 11y agoPolygamy makes no sense from a power structure standpoint, it is inherently unequal. The man (generally) gets X women and each woman gets one man (the same man). If polygamy meant a web of relationships, where everyone was equally married to everyone else, that would be conceptually more fair, but as is, the power structure of polygamy as defined by the only religious sect with much influence in the US is an inherently less than equal partnership.
- Void_ 11y ago10 years from now. HN Headline: Polygamy upheld by supreme court Comment: While this is excellent news for my polygamous friends, I see no progress on [insert new deviation here]. --- So what do you all think will be the next big thing?
- gadders 11y agoIncest amongst consenting adults.
- gadders 11y agoFor future googlers - not advocating this, just a guess as to a future debate.
- giaour 11y agoIIRC, New Jersey allows this, and consenting, incestuous couple have moved there in droves. I would try to look up the reference but I don't want to do a search for "legal incest New Jersey" on my work computer.
- jaynos 11y agoNew Jersey allows marriage of first cousins [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage_law_in_the_United_States_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage_law_in_the_Uni...
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAllows this? Or recognizes it as marriage? (I'm assuming that it's closer than first cousins.)
- giaour 11y agoAllows this, though it seems that they did so through some kind of legislative error 15 years ago. (http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2015/01/incest_is_totally_offensive_likely_to_get_on_nj_le.html http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2015/01/incest_is_totally_o...)
- mchaver 11y agoLegalized polygamy could create a lot interesting legal issues, particularly marriages of convenience. It would challenge a lot of traditional legal structures that assume a union between two people. If there is no restriction on how many people you can marry at once then you can start giving out residence rights via marriage or multiple wealthy individuals can amass large estates via marriage. I am sure there is a lot more. This is not meant as an argument against legalized polygamy, rather to point out some of the obstacles it faces.
- gaymarriage 11y agoit's an argument against marriage as a metric at all. No one should have to be romantically interested in someone to consider them a life partner. This decision was awful IMHO. Government has no place in marriage. So long as they are already involved with it, I'm happy that they're at least making the mistake equally for all genders. But the real solution is to stop validating this religious rite at all.
- toast0 11y agoCalifornia passed a law allowing more than two parents, which while intended for other circumstances may help to some degree with this as well http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201320140SB274 http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?...
- pgeorgi 11y agoSince it's about the civil aspects, same sex marriage is the logistically easier topic. Take taxes: tax codes cover singles and pairs, optionally with children. Same sex marriage doesn't change much here, polygamy does. The same for lots of other provisions that are affected by civil unions (no matter what they're called). It can be done, but it's a lot more work (and as such, a lot more legal attack surface) than declaring "we don't care anymore for the sex of the pairs' members".
- vectorpush 11y agoI don't have any moral objections to poly-marriage, but I don't think it's the same thing as gay marriage. Prohibition of gay marriage is rooted in the identity of individuals, but prohibition of polygamy is based on the amount of participants in the union. No one is discriminated against in the face of poly-marraige prohibition because it has nothing to do with the traits of any individual.
- kstenerud 11y agoSure it does: The trait of whom you choose as a partner. The trait of the structure of your union. The difference between the number of participants vs the gender distribution of the participants is academic.
- yeahdude 11y agoNot when you consider the legal ramifications.
- kstenerud 11y agoThe legal ramifications are the same as well: Property rights under the union, taxation, child guardianship, visitation, protection upon dissolution, and wills.
- yeahdude 11y agoSo the child of a divorce has to move between more than 2 homes now? A wealthy man can split his income with more than 1 wife that doesn't work? It's not the same, it's qualitatively and quantitatively different. Is there a limit to the number of members? Can you join a union halfway through? Can you leave a union without dissolving it? Those questions don't come up under 2-person unions.
- kstenerud 11y agoI'm not sure why you keep harping on the specifics of the rules. Any different arrangement will always have different specifics, even if the fundamentals remain the same (which they do in this case).
- verisimilidude 11y agoHow does polygamy benefit the state? It's a serious question. With regular two-people marriage, you're roughly giving almost everyone a shot at finding a partner for marriage. This means you don't get large roaming populations of one sex or the other without any hope of finding a partner, and all the problems that can bring (see China). Those people will not be able to participate in the state-approved stability that marriage can bring. Gay marriage is actually positive for the state in these respects, since it expands the number of people who can participate in the current framework. Polygamy is much more complicated at scale, and I think you'd need to find solutions to many other potential problems before you could convince the state to accept it.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoThe majority opinion in the comments here seems to be that polygamy would be OK. So is there anywhere where you would draw the line? Incest? Underage? Anything at all? Is everything really acceptable?
- kstenerud 11y agoWhat do either of those have to do with polygamy?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoThere was a time when homosexuality was considered morally wrong by the majority of people in this country. Polygamy was also considered wrong, as was incest, marrying children, bestiality, and probably some other things that I'm forgetting. So my question is this: Given that the majority of people here seem to be so liberal-minded that they consider (consensual, non-coercive) polygamy to be fine, is there anything that anyone will still look at and say "That's actually morally wrong"?
- kstenerud 11y agoYou've answered your own question: "consensual, non-coercive"
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoFirst, don't put words in my mouth. That's not my answer. Second, that's it? Nothing more? Consensual, non-coercive between, say, a 70-year-old and a 9-year-old is fine?
- kstenerud 11y agoA 9 year old can't give consent, by law (at least in 1st world countries).
- AndrewKemendo 11y ago>While this is excellent news for my gay and lesbian friends, I see no progress on polygamy. Isn't this literally the slippery slope that conservatives "warned" against? I even just saw a politico article today saying basically the same thing: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/06/gay-marriage-decision-polygamy-119469.html#.VY4VmUbmIoJ http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/06/gay-marriage-... I'm all for polygamy but I think it's just funny to see this called for as the next step, literally the same day that gay marriage was passed.