5 ms·
So, I'm not american, but I visited that page, and from the comments here I was expecting to see a confederate flag. Instead I see an old C90 style audio casset
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
So, I'm not american, but I visited that page, and from the comments here I was expecting to see a confederate flag. Instead I see an old C90 style audio cassette?
Also, my grasp of American history isn't great, but the south lost this war right? And this particular battle at Gettysburg. And the Gettysburg address is fairly famous.
So, if not for the context of this being posted and then other comments here, I would assume this was a total non-event. Am I missing something? What's the supposed link between this and recent happenings with Apple store regulations and racist symbolism in the US?
edit: answering my own question, this particular cross-platform game got removed from the Apple app store as they were unwilling to edit it to remove the confederate flag from the game believing they shouldn't fall under the content ban as it was only used in historical context. It's not clear to me if it's presence is anything but a coincidence as it seems to be a well regarded game anyway.
- fenomas 11y agoThe game in the link is the same game Apple removed. So the story is that Steam is promoting the same game Apple blocked. The cassette tape seems to just be the graphic they're using for the top-page feature. The game's store page shows regular trailers screenshots.
- brudgers 11y agoConfederate flag controversies are a means of propagating the American myth that virulent American racism is a uniquely Southern trait and its primary form is based on proximate African ancestry. It's a comforting make believe that allows the American West off the hook in regard to indigenous peoples and Asian immigrants and Spanish speakers, and the states of the former Union off the hook for 100 postbellum years spent condoning Jim Crow and Federalizing its policies under the rationalization of sensitivity to well bread Southern sensibilities [not to mention the North's role in creating the events of the American West]. The current political motivation has far more to do with the shooting happening in a church [as was the case with the Birmingham bombing fifty years ago] than with some sudden realization that flying the Confederate flag represents an expression that going to war for the sake of preserving race based chattel slavery and the political advantage it afforded under the 3/5 clause of the US Constitution was a noble act. Were it nine black members of the Nation of Islam, Alabama wouldn't have pulled the Stars and Bars from the Statehouse this week...it's been flying a three wood from Dexter Avenue Baptist Church and the Southern Poverty Law Center for many years.
- surge 11y agoAll the corporations are pretending to be hyper sensitive to the church shooting tragedy, there has been a rush of some kind to blame the flag, although its a minor if any kind of factor in the issues of race in this country, especially in the south, Ferguson doesn't fly the flag anywhere and they have serious race issues. It's basically a marketing strategy under the guise of being supportive, its an old issue that many have seemed to hijacked the recent tragedy to push an old issue to the fore. There has been a giant band wagon of support behind taking down the confederate flag at the SC state capital in front of a memorial, as its still seen by some like the nazi flag, or representation of a traitorous flag, for most, it represents slavery, so there is plenty of argument why its not appropriate in front of a government building. Personally, I think there are far worse crimes the U.S. flag represents (killing and past and current treatment of Native Americans, internment of Japanese, pointless wars that left millions of innocents dead in Iraq, Laos, Vietnam, the years of slavery under the U.S. government and the Presidents who owned slaves, etc) so there is a lot of hypocrisy in pointing out the issue with that flag and the history behind it. I lived in the south long enough to realize the issues with race are prevalent everywhere and has little to do with the flag, and hiding the history of it won't fix a crazy kid shooting up a historic church that had to fight for the right to worship during its inception in this country. I do think that its inappropriate to fly it in front of a government building, but wrong to use someone's tragedy as ammunition to push a long standing personal agenda that doesn't really fix why it happened.
- sneak 11y agoYeah, what he said. Well illuminated. Have an upboat.
- coldpie 11y agoI largely agree with your comments, but > wrong to use someone's tragedy as ammunition to push a long standing personal agenda Ugh. No one is using this as "ammunition." The shooting was a symptom of a problem. Acceptability of racism and pride in racist heritage are possible contributing factors to this problem. When the symptoms present themselves, it makes sense to use that opportunity as a reminder that the problems still exist and that we should take steps to fix them.
- rayiner 11y agoThe south lost, but they didn't handle it the way say Germany did WWII (internalizing a deep sense of shame for what they did and purging their culture of anything glorifying that period). They lost, but they didn't repent. Hence why we're still seeing this conflict today.
- stevehawk 11y agoApples and oranges, isn't it? Hitler began a campaign for global domination and genocide. The South said "Fuck this, we're out" and seceded from the Union, then the North attacked it. The South's motivation wasn't particularly great, but their actions didn't exactly tear apart the world and change it's development forever.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> The South said "Fuck this, we're out" and seceded from the Union, then the North attacked it. The Confederacy (or the states that would become it) were taking over Federal military forts. The first shots fired were by Confederate troops on Fort Sumter in 1861. While the northern states (what remained of the Union) went to war, the Confederacy was not without blame in providing them with an immediate cause (Fort Sumter) to rally around.
- msandford 11y agoYeah, I'm not saying the people who caused the secession were good people. There's a lot of evidence that they're not. But choosing to secede I would suggest is a fairly mature act. If you're getting a raw deal politically then extracting yourself from said raw deal is probably a better option than starting a war to assert your dominance over those who disagree that your deal is a bad one. I think the people in the South had dishonorable motivations for what I think were ultimately honorable acts. At least up until they attacked the North first.
- th0waway 11y agoAnd then Lincoln goes and proves that the South was right to secede, by suspending parts of the Constitution in the Union as he saw fit. If you read the secession declarations, the slavery question was just the straw that broke the camels back.