4 ms·
This is a very Apple move. When I saw it, I wasn't surprised. There are Civil War games where it makes total sense for the flag to show, and there are probably
by MBCook 11y ago
This is a very Apple move.
When I saw it, I wasn't surprised. There are Civil War games where it makes total sense for the flag to show, and there are probably a few tasteless "The south will rise again" things that never should have been allowed on in the first place.
But it takes a lot of people and time to figure it out for each app on the store. And when it comes to this kind of stuff Apple doesn't like spending lots of people and time on these kind of things.
Blanket bans are so much easier to implement.
Quite disappointing, but not surprising. And they'll probably reverse parts of it within days. Or new games will slip through and people will forget about it.
- moron4hire 11y ago> But it takes a lot of people and time to figure it out for each app on the store. Right, because why would they dedicate resources and effort to the biggest feature of their biggest product?
- justizin 11y agoBecause a solution that requires a hundred people to let through 1% of submissions is a terrible way to do business.
- moron4hire 11y agoWhy? That is not obvious at all. I mean, that very concept "curation to ensure quality", is the entire justification for putting up with their walled-garden, rent-seeking, prior-restraint practices. So why shouldn't we expect them to do their fucking job?
- jasonlotito 11y ago> But it takes a lot of people and time to figure it out for each app on the store. They've already approved these apps. They already have the people to approve these apps. > And when it comes to this kind of stuff Apple doesn't like spending lots of people and time on these kind of things. Incorrect. They've already demonstrated they want to do this. After all, you had to have people find and remove these apps in the first place.
- MBCook 11y ago> They've already approved these apps. They already have the people to approve these apps. The truth is Apple approves a ton of stuff that is clearly and directly against clauses of the App Store rules. They seem to exist mostly to let Apple pull your app later and have a pre-defined reason. Enforcement is incredibly inconsistent, so it wouldn't surprise me at all if there was some pretty racist stuff that had been there before this event; despite hate apps being against policy. > Incorrect. They've already demonstrated they want to do this. After all, you had to have people find and remove these apps in the first place But they don't have to critically examine the game to understand the context, only determine if it contains a confederate flag. Hell, maybe they used a program to dissect app bundles and scan all images to see if they match the flag and probably ban those.
- jasonlotito 11y ago> The truth is... Yes, I know. That doesn't mean they get a free pass because of it. > But they don't have to critically examine the game... Yes, I know, but once again, that doesn't mean they get a free pass because of it. Listen, you are giving them excuses. Excuses that are, frankly, wrong. They are a company with massive resources. They could have done this the right way. They decided not to. It's as simple as that. They are wrong. They did wrong. End of story.