7 ms·
A Serious Conversation about the Future in Space
- scottmwinters 11y agoWas I the only one extremely disappointed that wasn't actually much related to Musk, nor a serious conversation about the future? It was an interview of a fiction novelist, nothing more.
- weavie 11y agoPossibly. Have you read The Martian? The author has put a ton of research into what it would take to get people to Mars. I'm sure he has a lot of relevant stuff to say about Musks ambitions for Mars travel. I highly recommend reading the book.
- Shivetya 11y agothe book is highly fascinating and similar to another favorite of mine; Red Mars; involves sending and confirming arrival of support missions before manned missions are sent. other than "we did it" I am still trying to understand the value in sending man to Mars. Oh I am all for it, just how do we sell it to the public to the point politicians cannot forever turn it down by laying claim to the money better served elsewhere? So while the author thinks it has to be government, private individuals would have less restrictions spending the money and more reasons to find ways to get the costs down to minimal levels without losing sight of the safety required
- arethuza 11y agoI red the KSR Mars trilogy and then pretty much developed a love affair with Mars and the idea of colonization - I'm also very fond of "The Case for Mars": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_for_Mars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_for_Mars NB I'm clear this is an emotional thing for me (hence "love affair") but I wonder to what extent all migrations in human history have been driven by a degree of wanderlust rather than cold logic. Anyway - I'm off to watch Erik Wernquist's Wanderers again: https://vimeo.com/108650530 https://vimeo.com/108650530
- Moshe_Silnorin 11y agoThe Martian had some very odd ethics. I recall at one point of the book there was a 30% chance of failure for a mission that would save one astronauts life. Failure would result in the death of six additional astronauts. Of course the fellow who pointed out it was obviously not worth the risk was a portrayed as a coward, as I guess coherently valuing lives is a cowardly act.
- nomailing 11y ago> How do you have a spinning part and a non-spinning part? Because you're going to want your solar cells pointed at the sun. Isn't that completely wrong? The full station could just be spinning as a rigid-body, while always the same side (with solar cells) can be oriented towards the sun. It is no problem if the solar cells are rotating around an axis, if that axis would be perpendicular to the solar panel and pointing towards the sun, right? So I am doubtful that he did a lot of research into this. But I am really not an expert, so please correct me if I am wrong...
- cma 11y agoI think he was responding to the HN headline, it read "A Serious Conversation with Elon Musk about the Future in Space" before being edited (it isn't a conversation with Musk).
- stephengillie 11y agoThis is a submarine piece for the upcoming movie. Seeing this title on HN makes me sad. I don't care if that's the article's title - when a title says "A serious conversation about the Future in Space", I'm expecting a serious conversation, not an advertisement.
- outworlder 11y agoI love the fact that the explanation of what's Delta-V is linked to the Kerbal Space Program forums.
- kraftman 11y agoWhat an odd interview. The interviewer starts asking the author he's interviewing about sections of the interviewers own book?
- Bedon292 11y agoThat is definitely odd, though it does make some sense in this case. Andy Weir has done a huge amount of research about traveling to Mars, and asking for his opinion about Elon's ideas is interesting. I would definitely prefer if they did not mention the interviewer's book though.
- peter303 11y ago"E.M. want to go home!"
- Bedon292 11y agoDoes the interviewer, or anyone for that matter, actually think Elon Musk will be the first person on Mars? Seems like a weird question to ask, I guess its just for the headline. I think I remember him saying something like not wanting to risk the fate of the company just for the experience of going. I could be completely off on that though.
- kraftman 11y agoEven the interviewer seems confused between whether he's saying Elon Musk has the means to send someone to mars or the ingenuity of Mark Watney to survive there.
- bra-ket 11y agoMusk or not, our future in space is based on progress in nuclear propulsion. Luckily some labs are working on it: https://www.quora.com/Is-research-on-nuclear-propulsion-systems-for-space-being-currently-done-at-any-institute-or-laboratory https://www.quora.com/Is-research-on-nuclear-propulsion-syst...
- ryandvm 11y agoI'm incredibly optimistic about the disruption Elon Musk is bringing to the automotive and battery industries and the commercialization of space transport. Amazing guy. That said, I'm starting to think that Mars is going to be his Spruce Goose (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_H-4_Hercules https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hughes_H-4_Hercules). It's crazy, it's expensive, and at this point, it's an unnecessary moonshot that makes literal moonshots seem reasonable. While I agree with the principle that humanity needs to be a multi-planet species if we're going to make it past all the Great Filters, I honestly don't think we're ready as a species. Technologically or organizationally. We can't even get half our population to admit that the climate is warming, but somehow we're supposed to get our shit together enough to colonize an entire planet? And from a technological perspective, I'm continually amazed that the same people that fret and wring their hands about climate change seriously believe colonization of Mars is not going to be the most painful thing humanity has ever done. It will be fraught with death, expense, and replete with economic and social chaos. Ending all wars, enacting global healthcare and welfare policies, and rolling back climate change on Earth would be a cakewalk compared to building self-sufficient colonies on a planet that: * Has no breathable atmosphere * Has little usable water * Is bombarded with deadly radiation * Has no economic justification for colonization The only reason to be going to Mars is that, statistically, in the next couple dozen million years the Earth might get a flat tire. I don't know - from what I've seen so far, I'm not sure humanity deserves to be the species that settles the Milky Way...
- frank-weindel 11y agoLooks like someone has lost all hope for humanity and at that we should just accept our "inevitable" self-destruction. Even if the dream of colonizing mars is farfetched beyond fixing all of the problems we currently have on earth, it doesn't mean its not worth striving for. Goals like this drive people to do their best work and come up with creative solutions to problems that would otherwise never have been thought of. This is the exact kind of drive we need if we are to even have the chance at becoming interplanetary. Maybe we end up just getting to Mars and setting up an "antarctic" like lab that is occupied by teams for months at a time? That's fine. The innovation that got us even there would have been amazing. Maybe the goal then shifts to self-sustaining interplanetary spacecraft. Humanity isn't done yet, and not shooting for the far reaches of the galaxy is a waste of time that we cannot spare. Musk Co. isn't just focused on that interplanetary goal. There's a lot that is also being done to make this planet better and prolong its life. These are honorable and not nearly as farfetched goals. Musk's drive to solve these problems is a real inspiration to many and may be our only chance in hell to pass through the Great Filters.
- adamtj 11y agoThis is a conversation with Andy Weir about Elon Musk, among other topics.
- pzxc 11y agoThe title should be changed. Elon Musk was not interviewed. A sci-fi author was interviewed about his opinions of Elon Musk re: Mars. Title is very misleading.
- Bedon292 11y agoThe title was previously the title of the article, not sure why someone changed it.
- adventured 11y agoOP here, no idea why it was changed to that either. It's not a conversation with Elon Musk. The title needs to be changed back.