4 ms·
There's no correlation between having a lot of parties and a sound, well functioning political system. See: Italy, and a dozen other examples from Europe over
by adventured 11y ago
There's no correlation between having a lot of parties and a sound, well functioning political system.
See: Italy, and a dozen other examples from Europe over the last 70 years
If your culture is rotten, your politics will be rotten, regardless of whether you have 2, 5, 27 parties.
- mcv 11y agoA multi-party system does not guarantee that there will be no political problems (particularly not if it polarizes into what's effectively a two-party system), but a two-party system is practically guaranteed to not represent minority opinions, and very likely to degenerate into a "vote for the lesser evil".
- soylentcola 11y agoNot to mention the issues of access you run into when money and influence are able to build up behind one or two campaigns. Two insanely massive parties are basically like competition between two massive marketing budgets. Trying to compete against the Republican or Democratic parties is like trying to start a new cellular carrier from scratch to compete with Verizon and AT&T. Sure, if you managed to get enough "viral" support and maybe some wealthy investor you could mount a campaign big enough to get into a debate but the frameworks that have grown around the two-party system make it very difficult to take advantage of any popularity boost. Trying to compete with the two established parties in a "winner takes all" system would require working against the entire political system which is overwhelmingly made up of people in those two parties.
- paulhauggis 11y ago"but a two-party system is practically guaranteed to not represent minority opinions," It's designed this way. Many minority opinions are minority because they are bad and should never be implemented.
- mcv 11y agoSo you think the US political system is doing fine? Disenfranchising minorities is a bad way to run a democracy.
- mrweasel 11y ago>There's no correlation between having a lot of parties and a sound, well functioning political system. Absolutely true, but it is remarkable that the Danes had 10 parties to choose from at our election for parliament last week and the US is supposed to be able feel represented by only two parties. Denmark is pretty much as homogeneous a society as it is possible to be in a modern world and yet we have 10 parties, granted many have very similar policies. It's completely unrealistic that a country of 320million people should feel that their views should represented by two large parties, when 5.5million people in a small Scandinavian country need 10 parties (9 of which managed to get seats in parliament)
- 1_player 11y ago> Denmark is pretty much as heterogeneously a society I think you mean homogeneous.
- mrweasel 11y agoOoh, yeah of cause, thanks.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoThe US does have more than two parties. Most ballots have anywhere from 3 to 6. It's just that nobody votes for them unless they happen to nominate someone from the big two.
- happyscrappy 11y agoWhen the Green party gets a lot of votes those votes come from the Democrats and the Republicans win. Conversely with libertarians.
- mrweasel 11y agoI do understand that there's more than two parties, I should have made that clear. The US system is more or less a "winner takes all" system, leaving small parties little or no change for representation, even if they do represent a large percentage of the population. It is pretty much the same "problem" the UK has. If the Americans are happy with the system, then then there's no issue, but if a large population group feels unrepresented then I don't think it's a fair system. There's a valid point to be made in terms of the size and diversity in the US might pose a problem for a parliamentary style of government, in as so fare as a plethora of parties could gridlock legislation.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago"a sound, well functioning political system" is not the goal, or we'd all adopt the single party run like a corporation model from Singapore. The goal is to represent all the citizens' wishes as best as possible when taking decisions about issues of common interest. And the more power is concentrated in unaccountable parties, the less chances we have at doing that. Italy may have more than 2 parties, but they are already moving towards a less democratic system where only 2 of them matter. They are already at the point where the only way to access significant positions is through a party. Independents are heavily penalized and mostly eliminated from the picture. Then there's the lack of internal democracy in those structures supposed to democratically represent the people. Party members are forced to respect party lines instead of what they personally believe, and in some cases the party line is dictated by a single person - the founder/CEO/father-figure of the corporate party (Berlusconi, Grillo, etc.).
- MrDosu 11y agoHow is this answer even related? I never mentioned multi party systems lead to a well functioning political system. You are arguing against a point no one made.