3 ms·
Real life Gyro Gearloose!!! In the next video he talks about how a Klein bottle is made, and how, contrary to a bottle, it has no edge. I'm not sure I underst
by bambax 11y ago
Real life Gyro Gearloose!!!
In the next video he talks about how a Klein bottle is made, and how, contrary to a bottle, it has no edge.
I'm not sure I understand why a bottle "has to" have an edge? Surely it's possible to make a bottle with no edge? For example, if one takes a sphere and progressively turns it into a bowl (by punching into it), and then makes the bowl deeper, it still has just one surface and no edge, no?
- peterfirefly 11y ago"The Shape of Space" is a great "topology for dummies" book. Highly recommended. http://www.amazon.com/Shape-Space-Chapman-Applied-Mathematics/dp/0824707095 http://www.amazon.com/Shape-Space-Chapman-Applied-Mathematic...
- TobbenTM 11y agoIf you make this bowl, it will have two surfaces, with no way to get from one side to the other.
- bambax 11y agoWell, I'm not sure about that. The top of my bowl is the top-half of a doughnut if you will: it really does not seem to have an edge. At what point does an "edge" appear?
- peterfirefly 11y agoBut you do have two surfaces: inside and outside. The Klein bottle only has one.
- glomph 11y agoIt has an inner surface and an outer surface, the same as a sphere. They didn't say it had an edge.
- bambax 11y agoYes, in the video I'm talking about https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAsICMPwGPY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAsICMPwGPY he says that a bootle has an edge (~3'40). A sphere does not have an "inner surface", it has just one surface. So does a potato. If you go from sphere to potato to bowl, when does an edge appear and does it have to appear, is my question.
- geon 11y agoWell. A bottle is topologically equivalent to a solid sphere. It only has one surface. The inside and outside of a bottle is just by convention. Usually you would say something is inside the bottle if it is past the opening. (As he says in the video.) So your example with the bowl-shaped "sphere" is correct. There's no clear limit when a bottle has an inside and an outside.
- chii 11y agothe object that have only one surface, but no edge, is a klein bottle. A sphere (or if you will, a ball pressed into a bowl shape) has two surfaces - the outer one, and the "inner" one (where the "inner one" is the one you cannot reach from the outer one, as tho the surface is infinitely thin, and the bowl/sphere is made of hollowness.
- DanBC 11y agoRun your finger around a möbius strip. Your finger touches all parts of the surface without travelling over an "edge". You can do the same with the klein bottle. Can you do the same with your sphere/donut/bowl?
- talideon 11y agoThe rim of your bowl is the edge: it's a point where the curvature changes suddenly. But that's not the important thing: the important thing is that not only is there only no edge, but only one surface. Let's talk topology for a bit. A manifold can be thought of as essentially a flat and infinitely thin sheet. If you have a spherical manifold (and your bowl would be a spherical manifold), it has two surfaces: one on the inside and another on the outside. Deforming the manifold doesn't change this. The thing about a Klein bottle (and a Moebius strip) is that it only has one continuous surface, the difference between a Moebius strip and a Klein bottle is that the latter is a single surface with no edge whereas the former is a single surface with one edge, unlike the sphere (or your bowl), which has two surfaces and no edge. So what's important here is the number of sides it has, not really that it has no edge. The lack of an edge is really only what separates a Moebius strip from Klein bottle.
- bambax 11y agoBut with an ordinary bottle, the edge is the point (if I may), because if a bottle had no edge, couldn't it be said that has just one ordinary surface? So in fact, what I understand so far is: - a (hollow) sphere has two surfaces, one inside and one outside, and you can't connect one to the other (you can't walk from one to the other) - a potato, or a bowl also have the same properties: two distinct surfaces - a bottle is not a special kind of bowl, it's more of a broken sphere (an egg the top of which has been removed) so that both surfaces (in and out) are accessible (but disjoint) - to make a true bottle out of a bowl one needs to somehow "collapse" the inner and outer surfaces (therefore creating an edge) - if you make a bottle that has a hollow space between the inside and the outside (think Thermos), then you actually have three surfaces Is this correct?
- talideon 11y agoI think the confusion here is that you're taking what he's saying in terms other than those of topology. In topology, you deal with manifolds. Manifolds have no thickness, but they do have area. In topology, there's no such thing as a 'filled' sphere: a sphere in topology has no edges and an inside surface and an outside surface, much like a football. There are two ways you can make a 'bottle': you can deform a sphere, which gives you a 'bottle' much like a vaccuum flask; or you can deform a planar manifold (which is like a sheet of paper). The former will have two surfaces and no edge, whereas the latter will have two surfaces and one edge, that being the rim. A broken sphere would be a planar manifold. A vaccuum flask is simply a deformed sphere in topological terms, and thus only has two surfaces, the inside and the outside.
- raldi 11y agoI could paint the inside of your surface red and the outside blue (where by "inside" I mean the part you've trapped air in). That's not the case with Cliff's bottles.
- maxerickson 11y agoIf you stick a cork in the bottom, his bottles have an inside and an outside. The abstract object doesn't, the 3d manifestation of it does.
- HCIdivision17 11y agoI had to think about what that meant for a moment, as it's sort of part of the weirdness of the bottle. Really, putting a cork in it is probably closer to putting a lid on a bowl, no? It's just sealing the local minimum. (Maximum? I don't really know what the sign should be for this. Probably maximum, for enclosed volume, since I'm not sure if it's reasonable to talk about the topology having a minimum in this context...)
- maxerickson 11y agoIf I needed to close one, I'd stick a cork in the hole in the bottom. So I think that is a reasonable way to describe closing it. I don't think I can reason clearly about the 4 dimensional object, part of pointing out that a 3d manifestation does not have the same properties is me trying to do that.