6 ms·
Making sexy molecules in PowerPoint
- dekhn 11y agoWhy in the world would you do this in PowerPoint. Get PyMol. render it using povray.
- theophrastus 11y agoThat's the ticket! (sez the ol' biochemist) Just peruse some of these images and compare: https://goo.gl/TpzzxB https://goo.gl/TpzzxB and consider the virtues of beamer over powerpoint.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoWe use VMD, son, but they use Pymol.
- dalke 11y agoStart up VMD and see my name in the credits. :)
- shiggerino 11y agoWhat a terrible waste of time
- Shoop 11y agoWhat a wonderful waste of time
- tokenadult 11y agoReaders interested in chemistry modeling software solutions may want to go beyond the capabilities of PowerPoint to a specialized program for chemistry modeling. The program I know best, Bitwixt,[1] has been refined over more than a decade and is a very interesting educational tool. [1] http://www.bitwixt.com/jsite/ http://www.bitwixt.com/jsite/
- oever 11y agoI'd like to recommend Avogadro which is FOSS. One can drag and drop atoms to create any molecule. With annealing the atoms the will arrange themselves in a physically realistic position. https://avogadro.cc https://avogadro.cc https://avogadro.cc/wiki/Screenshots https://avogadro.cc/wiki/Screenshots Here's a screencast of building a caffeine molecule with Avogadro: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrbahnykY6g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrbahnykY6g
- Trombone12 11y agoShould have carried #overlyhonestmethods label
- dalke 11y ago"it only takes seconds to make high-quality molecules" I have a hard time accepting that this is true for any but the simplest of molecules. Takes caffeine or Diazepam as more realistic examples. These have double bonds, which are drawn offset from the center-to-center line, and use elements besides carbon, which need either labels or CPK color assignments. Even in the case shown here, benzene should be drawn with double bonds for correct Kekule interpretation, or with one of several ways to denote aromatic bonds. However, there are fields like macromolecular structure visualization where bond type information is often omitted, so this is not critical. But drawing cyclohexane would be difficult because of the non-planar hydrogens. There are any number of tools for making eye-catching images. These include programs that will render the atoms and bonds using more complex materials, and including shading effects, fog effects, and multiple light sources. I think it would be better to leave this PP example in the "neat though very limited applicability" category.
- bane 11y agoI saw a PowerPoint slide presentation recently demonstrating how electrons form different kind of bonds in molecules, with the orbits of each electron modeled by hand in powerpoint and animated...including custom paths for the valence electrons. Among all the atoms in the molecule, there were dozens of electrons whipping around the slide in perfect loops, it was kind of breathtaking to think somebody spent likely weeks putting that slide together.
- santaclaus 11y agoI always wondered why presentation packages like PowerPoint and Keynote do not expose a scripting API to allow one to programmatically keyframe animations and such. That would make these sorts of effects almost trivial to achieve.
- jjoonathan 11y agoIt seems a bit odd to spend that much time animating individual electrons flying about. From QM we know that such classical models completely and utterly fail to reproduce almost all important bonding behavior (certainly anything covalent). Don't get me wrong, the schematic bonding formalism employed by chemists is very useful and students need to learn it even before they learn the QM behind it, but showing electrons flying around a ppt slide departs from the schematic formalism towards a conceptual destination which is plausible but incorrect and lies in the exact opposite direction from our current best model of physical reality. Of course, the instructor may have been ridiculing the model or using it as a bookkeeping mechanism for a more advanced class, but if this slide was made for an intro chem course it sounds like a complete pedagogical mess. A textbook example (hopefully not literally) of doing something only because you can and making things worse in the process :(
- SchizoDuckie 11y agoSounds to me like they would rather want to use something specialized like this. http://web.chemdoodle.com/demos/3d-editor http://web.chemdoodle.com/demos/3d-editor Please people. Don't do stuff like this in word or powerpoint.
- resoluteteeth 11y agoThe result is good, but it seems like more effort than necessary and using drawing objects in Office is always a recipe for compatibility problems if you use any other program (e.g. Libreoffice or the the web version of Office).
- pcrh 11y agoAgreed, the time invested to learn how to make objects such as shown in Powerpoint would be better spent learning to use Illustrator or Gimp. The results would be much more useable across different media as well.
- cing 11y agoThat being said, there are good uses of presentation software outside the norm, as in these motion graphics: http://www.lindadong.com/blog/keynotemotiongraphic http://www.lindadong.com/blog/keynotemotiongraphic
- pcrh 11y agoAgreed. What you linked to looks like an interesting way to generate simple animations, which indeed could be of wide interest. I haven't (yet) tried using it, but may...
- agumonkey 11y agoNot that much an improvement over PowerPoint. Pymol and other suggestions here look much much more on point. Or even a python script for blender.
- pcrh 11y agoYes, there are much better software suites than generic ones for drawing and manipulating molecules, including dynamic simulations, etc. If someone is using Powerpoint to draw molecules they're not likely a professional chemist or biochemist. So the amount of time spent learning something like Illustrator would apply to whatever else they do as well.
- greggarious 11y agoI'm surprised there isn't a latex package that can do this (that you could then use w/ Beamer.)
- leni536 11y agoI think TikZ is fairly capable in this regard, I never used it for 3D stuff though. http://www.texample.net/tikz/examples/tag/3d/ http://www.texample.net/tikz/examples/tag/3d/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tibcdev 11y ago"This is just too sexy for PowerPoint" - D. Bryne
- moonbug 11y ago"When all you have is a hammer..."
- 616c 11y agoSo no one will mention the Clasp (Lisp on LLVM developer)? He built a language to build better, albeit not visualize, better molecules. If you are on this article, you probably will love to watch this guy. I am computer nerd and this guy makes me want to go back and study chemistry. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8X69_42Mj-g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8X69_42Mj-g
- dalke 11y agoI just watched it. I heard pretty much the same aspirations since the 1980s. See https://www.fourmilab.ch/autofile/www/section2_82_2.html https://www.fourmilab.ch/autofile/www/section2_82_2.html for when AutoDesk looked at entering this field. At 15:56 the speaker says "Synthetic chemists normally they design things with plastic model sets." This just isn't true, and hasn't been for a very long time. At 17:54 he even says there's GUI-based software now to design molecules. That's what most chemists use. My experience is that it doesn't take 20 minutes to draw a molecule using the current generation of tools. In fact, you can try it now - go to http://web.chemdoodle.com/demos/sketcher http://web.chemdoodle.com/demos/sketcher or https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/edit2/index.html https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/edit2/index.html or http://scitouch.net/ketcher-demo/ketcher.html http://scitouch.net/ketcher-demo/ketcher.html and draw one yourself. (This is for small molecule chemistry. For large molecule chemistry, there are other tools and other issues to worry about.) In minute 23 he talks about computing the second derivative of the force fields, and how complex it is. Thing is, my co-worker did that manually when he wrote the original NAMD implementation. (NAMD is a molecular dynamic program.) So it's not something that's all that hard to compute. It's just tedious. (And his code is 10% slower than the hand-written code, so he knows that people do this sort of thing manually.) While it's useful to have automatic code generators if you want to add new force fields often, we just don't do it all that often, because parameterizing the force field is the hard problem, not computing the second derivative. At 31:25 he says that SciPy is only really possible because of Boost.Python. This isn't true. I just downloaded scipy-0.16.0b2 and verified that it does not use Boost.Python. ("ag -i BOOST_PYTHON_MODULE" finds no matches.) At 49:30 he talks about a technique that sounds like pharmacophore models, which have been around since at least the 1990s. There are tools that will build molecules to fit pharmacophore models. What I didn't see was anything about dealing with waters, and counter-ions, toxicity, or AMDE (absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion) issues. I didn't hear anything which required multiple years of tool building ("yak shaving") to get to what he wanted. Every technique he mentioned is something that people have been doing already, in C/C++/Python.