3 ms·
Currently, if a company disposes of all of its workers and replaces them by robots (minus a bit of left human staff for administration), the profits end up enti
by mschuster91 11y ago
Currently, if a company disposes of all of its workers and replaces them by robots (minus a bit of left human staff for administration), the profits end up entirely in the pockets of the owners instead of getting redistributed to the working population.
Therefore, I believe that companies operating this way should pay a "robot tax"; the funds gathered by this tax must be redistributed as unemployment/social benefits or, better, as guaranteed income.
Otherwise funds will accumulate in the hands of a very few and not be put into any productive use - hell, just look at Apple's cash reserves, Apple alone could bail out Greece and even profit from it. Currently, the Apple money is just lying around and doing nothing productive at all.
- maxerickson 11y agoUnless it is literally sitting in a vault (it isn't), Apple's cash is being used for stuff. Here's an article about that: http://seekingalpha.com/article/1246081-apple-does-not-have-137-billion-in-cash http://seekingalpha.com/article/1246081-apple-does-not-have-... I don't really get the idea of a robot tax, why make special rules for one particular type of productivity? Should accountants that use better software also pay higher taxes than less efficient accountants that use simple calculators and paper?
- adventured 11y agoEven if you parked $200 billion in cash in a vault, its removal from circulation for any meaningful amount of time would generate a purchasing power increase for every other dollar holder. The idea of a robot tax is not a rational one. It's based off of an emotional response to the fear of workers losing jobs and income. It will become a very loud, common argument over the next decade. It rests upon the incorrect notion that productivity gains through automation must inherently result in fewer jobs - when in fact, history has proven the exact opposite to be true (the industrial revolution being the overwhelming proof, but there were prior examples including the agriculture revolution). The most productive economies are always among the wealthiest for the median of people, and come in at the lower quarter of unemployment rankings.
- jacquesm 11y agoBy that reasoning we should have been paying a 'robot tax' for a long time (and an outsourcing tax as well).
- branchless 11y agoland value tax.
- jasode 11y ago>Therefore, I believe that companies operating this way should pay a "robot tax"; Well, we have a lot of "robots" in the house. We can listen to music via Compact Disc robots or mp3 iPod robots instead of employing human musicians to play live music. For example, composer Haydn's job was the "on call" music director for the family estate. We also run take our C++ or Java code and let our personal desktop robots of file systems submit them to compilers to parse and execute the source code. The acts of "cl helloworld.cpp" or "javac hellowold.java" puts many human punch card operators out of work. The elevator robots with automatic safety doors and algorithmic braking systems replacing elevator attendants manually closing the gates and guiding the elevator to the right floor. Robot freon compressors replacing ice delivery men. Etc, I don't think people realize the oppressive nature of all the robot taxes we'd pay unless we listed every "robot" we interact with that replaced human jobs.
- shit_parade2 11y agoFunneling more money to a corrupt and incompetent government is not a solution, it is a horror show. Ignore the ludicrous laws that conspire to hurt all but the largest corporate-fascist entities.
- gress 11y agoThis is false. The Apple money is invested in other companies.