31 ms·
SP: Two-thirds of the way into your novel, Seveneves – in fact, on page 569 – you do something kind of crazy. The story suddenly skips ahead 5,000 y
by aaronbrethorst 11y ago
SP: Two-thirds of the way into your novel,
Seveneves – in fact, on page 569 – you do
something kind of crazy. The story suddenly
skips ahead 5,000 years. What’s the idea here?
It took me maybe a week to read the first 2/3's of the book, and about three weeks to read the last 1/3. In many ways, these two parts feel like completely different books, one of which is significantly better than the other.
Also, I was occasionally distracted at the beginning when snippets of dialog from Anathem were reused in the form of exposition in Seveneves.
But, that said, I think the book is worth reading, especially the first 2/3's.
My personal, quick, rough ranking of Stephenson's bibliography:
* Anathem
* Snow Crash
* The Diamond Age
* Seveneves
* Cryptonomicon
* The Baroque Cycle
* Zodiac
* Reamde
* The Interface
* The Big U
Haven't Read
* The Cobweb
* The Mongoliad
- EdwardCoffin 11y agoCould you cite any of these bits of reused Anathem dialogue? I've read Anathem countless times, and didn't notice anything other than "plane-change maneuvers are expensive" or something to that effect, which I think is more of a truism than reused dialogue.
- aaronbrethorst 11y ago"Plane change maneuvers are expensive" is the one I remember off the top of my head, but I do distinctly recall another line elsewhere in the book. Sorry I can't be more specific.
- nitrogen 11y agoI noticed a lot of parallels between Snow Crash and Anathem. Both had dialogues meant to educate the reader, and there is a little overlap in the concepts explored in both books.
- db48x 11y agoPlane change maneuvers _are_ expensive; reusing that sentence can't possibly detract from a book.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoRephrasing such a sentence undoubtedly requires far less energy than the delta v necessary to accomplish the actual maneuver.
- rosser 11y agoComing up with different phrasings of the exact same concept per book is potentially more expensive in terms of suspension of disbelief. "Why is she taking a whole paragraph to say, 'Plane change maneuvers are expensive'?"
- mikeash 11y agoWhy bother? It's not like Stephenson invented that sentence. It's a fact, stated in the simplest possible way. If you google that literal sentence, you'll find quite a few uses unrelated to his books.
- EdwardCoffin 11y agoWant to take a swing at that yourself? I did do some google searches for the phrase in question, and other people have used it online (though I admit all the citations I found in my cursory search date to after Anathem, though that is no guarantee that they are aping it.)
- e12e 11y agoNo comment on re-use or what-not, but: https://www.google.no/search?q=Plane+change+maneuvers+are+expensive&num=50&safe=off&source=lnt&tbs=cdr:1,cd_min:1970,cd_max:1980&tbm= https://www.google.no/search?q=Plane+change+maneuvers+are+ex...
- rosser 11y agoI enjoyed the second part of Seveneves quite a bit, myself, though I definitely feel like it could easily have been expanded a bit, and become a second volume. I will say, however, that the sharp divides between the "races" felt a bit artificial to me, much like the ways the alien species in something like Star Trek are monocultures, for no obvious reason beyond author/plot convenience. I'm trying to break through the initial wall in Anathem presently. I think part of what's impeding me is that I bought it in mass-market paperback format, and the binding on my copy is egregiously bad; it's shedding leaves like a Minnesota maple in September.
- Uhhrrr 11y agoI think he was going for a take on mitochondrial Eve, and what could happen given current/future technology. But I agree, the racial purity hopes and dreams of the seven Eves would have been obliterated about two minutes after the second space baby hit puberty. Anathem does take a little while to get into thanks to the language, but it's great!
- pavedwalden 11y agoIn one of his recent interviews, Stephenson said that he was intentionally playing off the silly trope of Star Trek type aliens that are basically just caricatures of humans with this-or-that trait emphasized. Not that he was trashing Star Trek, just that he was having a little fun trying to make up a backstory about why humans and vulcans can interbreed.
- protonfish 11y agoI assumed all of his books read like this. Stephenson is great at building a world and characters but once the story needs to stumble into some kind of ending, it all gets contrived and uninteresting. (Right now I am stalled at 75% of Snow Crash.)
- ionwake 11y agoSnowCrash had an awesome ending! Man if only he had picked me to build a game with him maybe stuff would have gone better
- protonfish 11y agoThanks! That will help me get motivated to finish it. I really enjoyed most of it so far.
- obstinate 11y agoSnow Crash is a much better book if you skim all the stuff about the ancient Mesopotamians. He gets a little off into the weeds with that stuff, and apparently the editor failed to cut things back properly.
- EdwardCoffin 11y agoStephenson had an Authors @Google talk in 2008 [1], which was mostly about his book Anathem. In it he actually addressed what he calls the "Stephenson can't write endings" meme, as he calls it, at 10:54 going on for about three minutes [2]. I think his endings are just fine, myself, and also think that this whole idea that he can't write endings is just a self-perpetuating meme. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnq-2BJwatE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnq-2BJwatE [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnq-2BJwatE&t=10m54s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnq-2BJwatE&t=10m54s
- CodeMage 11y agoI haven't read Reamde, yet. I've read lots of complaints about it on Goodreads, so I'm kind of on the fence about getting it. In your opinion, how was Reamde compared to works like Anathem, Snow Crash, Diamond Age and Cryptonomicon? I'm asking because I like your ranking :)
- devindotcom 11y agoReamde was just bad. Not even on the charts. It's extremely tedious and narratively preposterous. http://coldewey.cc/post/26464791525/reamde-neal-stephenson-2011 http://coldewey.cc/post/26464791525/reamde-neal-stephenson-2... I'm going to read a few reviews of Seveneves before I read it, Reamde burned me so bad. Although now that I know this huge plot point (spoiler warning!?!?).... I don't know which way that tips the scales.
- rosser 11y agoI genuinely don't understand it when people talk about their experience of a work as if their opinions are somehow objective facts. "It was bad" vs. "I didn't like it", for example. That just doesn't make sense to me. I'm sorry you didn't like it, but that has no bearing whatsoever on the material, itself, or anyone else's experiences of it.
- ibash 11y agoI think that is just a quirk of the English language... For what it's worth, I also didn't like it - I thought the characters were dry and cliche. Multiple times I caught myself thinking "that makes no sense"...
- CamperBob2 11y agoHe cites a few specific issues, like random animal attacks that appear just in time to steer the plot, that are arguably grounds for calling it "bad." Well-written review IMHO.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoI'm disappointed that I haven't seen your review of Reamde until just now. I think it's spot on, with the exception that They pull the gun out from the holster, chamber a round, flip the safety off, line up the sights... understates the stultifying minutiae of the Makarov holster that Stephenson explores. edit: Ah, never mind. Just hadn't read far enough into your review.
- mcphilip 11y agoHave you tried Mother Earth Mother Board? http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html It's a ~40,000 word article from 1996 he did for Wired about the laying of undersea fiber-optic cables. I'd say it ranks as one of his best writings, just behind the Baroque Cycle and Cryptonomicon
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoYep, back in 1996 and thought it was great. I re-read it a couple years ago when his collection of essays, Some Remarks, came out.
- ryanmarsh 11y agoOh God, Mother Earth Motherboard was so great. Im really upset I lost my copy of that issue. That was a real treasure to 16 year old me. I'd love to read it again, in print.
- geuis 11y agoI agree with your list mostly except for two points. Reamde should be near the top and Seveneves closer to the bottom. I found parts of SE to be interesting, but in the first part it just becomes a series of characters making more and more unrealistic choices in a survival situation. I was really into the story until the President shows up. Then for no reason with clearly defined motivations, she starts making divisions that other well trained and selected people start following for no clear reason. It was like Neal knew where he wanted to be in 5000 years, but once he got everyone into space and Earth destroyed he didn't know how to tie them together. So he introduces Julian as a mcguffin to kill the swarm and whittle the survivors to 8 people. And don't get me started on the mermen.
- Uhhrrr 11y agoMaybe you've had the fortune to not have met any really manipulative people. Julia seemed pretty plausible to me.
- pavedwalden 11y agoI think you're bending the term 'McGuffin' slightly past its limit. Originally it meant "interchangeable object of pursuit that drives the plot" - a secret document, a special microchip, a stolen diamond etc. Recently I've seen people using it to mean "contrived shift in the plot", but even then it seems wrong to apply that label to a person. Villain or antagonist maybe?
- bostonpete 11y agoGrrr.... being 1/2 through that book right now, I really wish I hadn't opened this comment thread with this comment at the top. Spoiler alert???