3 ms·
> the court said that CloudFlare has to block every user with a domain name that contains “grooveshark,” no matter who owns the site What is the legal basis fo
by leereeves 11y ago
> the court said that CloudFlare has to block every user with a domain name that contains “grooveshark,” no matter who owns the site
What is the legal basis for this?
"Grooveshark" is long and unique, but by this principle, could King.com shut down every domain that contains the word "candy"?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoThey've gone after every game that uses the word 'saga', so they might try to.
- themartorana 11y agoAs have Zynga with "With Friends" and Scopely with "With Buddies" and Microsoft with "Windows" or MikeRoweSoft [0]... You can quickly lose a trademark if you don't actively defend it (weird, considering patents and copyrights) so companies quickly get over zealous. That said... For reasons that defy explanation, courts have been known to uphold trademark protections for common words ("Windows") even though trademark law explicitly forbids trademarks on common language words and phrases. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_vs._MikeRoweSoft https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_vs._MikeRoweSoft
- grabeh 11y agoTrade mark law does not forbid trade marks on common language words and phrases. It generally prevents people from registering 'descriptive' or 'non-distinctive' words/phrases as trade marks. "Windows" is descriptive for glazing supplies so wouldn't be registrable. "Windows" for software is distinctive and there is no public interest in it remaining free for anyone to use, unlike the case with the glazing example.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>You can quickly lose a trademark if you don't actively defend it (weird, considering patents and copyrights) so companies quickly get over zealous. // It's oft repeated but not true AFAICT. Genericisation can be a problem, but another company using something as a trademark for a distinct type of good/service won't make your mark more generic. You lose a registered trademark by not paying your renewal fee. If you wanted to codify someone else's use then you could grant them a license, you don't have to sue them or start infringement proceedings or whatever. You're free to ignore one infringement and pursue another. This is like saying you have to prosecute every person who steps on your land or you lose the right to prosecute trespassers; if you allow a right of way to be established then yes that's probably not going to help you. But you're allowed to let someone in to your garden and you're allowed not to sue people who make incidental incursions.
- michaelfeathers 11y ago> the court said that CloudFlare has to block every user with a domain name that contains “grooveshark,” no matter who owns the site > What is the legal basis for this? I wonder about that too. The court is ordering CloudFlare to disrupt the businesses of companies not party to the suit, who have likely not been notified and may have been found to be not infringing if they were in court.
- chc 11y agoThe "long and unique" aspect is important. There are many uses of "candy" that are obviously unrelated to Candy Crush, but there are essentially no uses of "GrooveShark" unrelated to GrooveShark.