5 ms·
This is a great case (for and against) owning a home. I'd like to add this is also why HOAs are worth avoiding. Imagine owning your own home but losing the fre
by Someone1234 11y ago
This is a great case (for and against) owning a home.
I'd like to add this is also why HOAs are worth avoiding. Imagine owning your own home but losing the freedom to do whatever you want with it and now having to put up with HOA bullshit instead of landlord bullshit.
They can also take your home if you get behind on your HOA dues. And fine you for rules they can create on a whim (and take your home if you fail to pay fines).
The disturbing thing is that the number of HOAs and the % of cities they inhabit is growing rapidly. Many developers create HOAs during development to keep the area looking nice until all the properties are sold off (and as soon as that happens the HOA is run at the whim of whomever picked up the rains from the neighbourhood).
Ultimately HOAs are anti-freedom, but nobody bats an eyelid because in the US only "freedom from government" is taken seriously, while freedom from employers/companies/organisations is all but ignored as a social issue. It is disturbing.
I just hope that for anyone unfortunate enough to live in a HOA area, they have non-crazy/non-sleazy people running the HOA. I also encourage everyone to get involved in their HOA otherwise risk getting bonkers rules passed by some nutjob who moves in and wants grass within 2 cm.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoPart of the reason I walked away from my last home (a townhouse) was the HOA/TOA. I was deeply underwater, could not come up with the difference to sell, and the HOA threatened to fine me $100/day if I wanted to rent the place out. Tossed the keys back to the bank, have a nice day (disclaimer: this only works if you have enough income to weather a credit drought; don't take it lightly). Something interesting about the housing crisis was that so many people lost their homes, lending guidelines have been reduced to allow you to purchase another home after 3 years from a foreclosure date instead of the historical 7 years. Next time I purchase in 2-5 years, I would never again purchase in an HOA. I have yet to have someone provide evidence that an HOA maintains or increases a property's value.
- dragontamer 11y agoSounds more like, don't get deeply underwater with a house. HOAs are agreements between the tenants and each other. As I bought my house, I made sure that I agreed with the HOA. I've even looked at some neighborhood's HOA and decided to shop elsewhere because of it. Some HOAs are bad, some are good.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Sounds more like, don't get deeply underwater with a house. Right, I'll get right on controlling macro-economic systems. > HOAs are agreements between the tenants and each other. As I bought my house, I made sure that I agreed with the HOA. I've even looked at some neighborhood's HOA and decided to shop elsewhere because of it. Some HOAs are bad, some are good. Also, right. You have almost no control over the board of the HOA you join, and are at the mercy of others in your "community". At least with a local government, you have due process. You have none with an HOA.
- dragontamer 11y ago> Right, I'll get right on controlling macro-economic systems. Or put more than 5% down on a house. IIRC, 20% down was enough to weather the 2009 crisis for the majority of the country (aka: Not Detroit). I know that some cities (like Detroit) had a particularly bad situation. But those cases are atypical. A big problem was the sheer number of people buying homes with very little money down. Or, if you're gonna be getting a FHA loan and buying a property on _extreme_ leverage, understand the tremulous situation you're in and that you're severely at risk for being underwater should the market tank. > Also, right. You have almost no control over the board of the HOA you join, and are at the mercy of others in your "community". At least with a local government, you have due process. You have none with an HOA. HOA's are beholden to the conduct described in the HOA bylaws, which serves as the constitution / due process of the HOA.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Or put more than 5% down on a house. IIRC, 20% down was enough to weather the 2009 crisis for the majority of the country (aka: Not Detroit). I had put 30% down (~$60K), and lost all of it, plus 2 years of payments. Chicago suburbs. > HOA's are beholden to the conduct described in the HOA bylaws, which serves as the constitution / due process of the HOA. You know how I know you've never attempted to sue an HOA for violating their bylaws?
- 11y ago
- codegeek 11y agoGreat point about HOAs. I should talk about this. It seems like newer the property, bigger the HOA bullshit is. THe house I bought is still considered ok for HOA fee ($30/month) but I know some newer communities are charging $100 or more per month. I recommend buying a house that is may be in a community where HOA fees are low (hint: look for older homes in older neighborhoods)
- dragontamer 11y ago> I'd like to add this is also why HOAs are worth avoiding. Imagine owning your own home but losing the freedom to do whatever you want with it and now having to put up with HOA bullshit instead of landlord bullshit. HOA bullshit is along the lines of "Don't paint your door pink", or "Consult with HOA / Neighbors before putting up a fence". Even a hugely regulatory HOA is more free than a landlord. > Ultimately HOAs are anti-freedom, but nobody bats an eyelid because in the US only "freedom from government" is taken seriously, while freedom from employers/companies/organisations is all but ignored as a social issue. It is disturbing. HOAs are the smallest government that people are going to be potentially a part of. Maybe I prefer living in an area that cares about a somewhat consistent architecture? Maybe I like living in an area where the HOA mows the lawn for me. If you don't like HOAs, then don't get a house with an HOA. But for me, I lose "freedoms" I never really cared about (I don't want a pink door, I'm not going to lease my property short-term with AirBNB), and gain assurances (such as no Hookers / Sex Orgies next door as my dumbass neighbors screw themselves with AirBNB). Finally, and this sounds a bit classist... but HOA dues serve as a barrier to keep selfish people like you away from the neighborhood. This is definitely the case for gated communities, although it isn't a major concern for me personally. But snooty people want to live with only other snooty upper-class people within the neighborhood... and HOA dues serve as a non-trivial barrier for them and their community. There are plenty of reasons that make HOAs beneficial to the neighborhoods they serve.
- matwood 11y agoI agree with you. I'm sure there are good/bad HOAs, but I think they are much easier to change through the yearly elections/bi-anunual meetings than individually dealing with a problem neighbor.
- eclipxe 11y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, but it is a valid opinion and one I share. HOAs are excellent for some people (me included) and not excellent for others. I don't get why people have so much HATE for HOAs when they can just as easily choose not to live in them. Just because they don't work for your lifestyle doesn't mean they are a bad thing.
- runamok 11y agoThe problem is you are probably going to live in your house for 5 to 30+ years. There is not guarantee the sane governance your HOA provides today won't be insane next year. I am thinking of buying a house in the coming years and plan to avoid HOAs like the plague.
- dragontamer 11y ago> There is not guarantee the sane governance your HOA provides today won't be insane next year. Participate in your HOA elections.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoI don't think "guarantee" means what you think it means.
- ghaff 11y agoAs others have said, there are sane ones and insane ones. Sometimes you need them. Where my dad lives, for example, there's a shared private road and the maintenance/plowing of that has to be managed. One could certainly not live there, of course, but you really have no way to avoid some sort of HOA in that circumstance. (In general, it's probably also true that the more space and separation you have from your neighbors, the less need for a HOA to mitigate conflicts and standards. Tall fences make good neighbors and all that.)
- dpark 11y agoAn HOA could be structured such that it only has the power to do specific things. Need the HOA to maintain a shared road? Structure it such that maintenance of that specific road is all it can do, and all it can raise fees for. Also set it up so that changing the HOA responsibilities requires a unanimous vote. The real trick to having a good HOA is probably structuring it such that it cannot morph into a bad one.
- cookiecaper 11y agoIn some areas, HOAs are nearly universal. HOAs are often a compromise that you have to make.
- mmaunder 11y agoHOA's really aren't that evil. Here's the benefit: You know those neighborhoods where every home has a truck on bricks out front? Where you're trying to sell your home but the guy to the left and right of you have let their garden go? HOA's solve those issues. We live in an HOA and the people are super chill - we're busy working to build a nature walk through a communal area. Yeah they can get a little gossipy and there are as many horror stories as there are bad neighborhoods in the country, but in most cases they actually help, especially for lower income neighborhoods. My in-laws live in a more rural area with an HOA and while they're always complaining about the gossipy nature of it, the alternative is clear: A few blocks outside the HOA some guy has turned his front-yard into an actual motorcross track and tears it up on weekends with dirt bikes.
- bane 11y agoI had a case recently with a neighbor running a business out of their home. At one point they had 30 customer vehicles parked out in the street and around the neighborhood. In my previous HOA-free area, we had a similar problem but had no recourse except to try to convince the county zoning commission to be bothered to do something -- we eventually had to move as the local homes each had 10-20 vehicles parked out in front. In my current HOA neighborhood I sent an email and made a phone call and the problem was solved in a couple weeks.
- greedo 11y agoMy current house isn't part of the neighborhood HOA because the developer messed up the paperwork for several homes, and we're not required to be members. This only became apparent when we received a letter from the HOA asking if we wanted to join and "enjoy the benefits" of a well maintained community. We had been paying the HOA fees for 4 years before this notice arrived, be we declined to join. They've invited us two more consecutive years, but we'll continue to decline. Our city maintains the roads, parks and school, the individual homeowners maintain the sidewalks. The HOA maintains the landscaping in two locations, and that's about it. I don't want the encumbrance of having to follow some insane HOA rules about paint color, or antennas, or such, so I'll pass.
- dpark 11y agoThis sounds like the best possible scenario for you. You basically get all the benefits of the HOA and none of the drawbacks. Did they reimburse you for the 4 years of dues that you didn't actually owe?
- greedo 11y agoNo reimbursement, and though I hadn't been liable for the dues, I didn't feel it would be worth the effort to try and recover them.
- eclipxe 11y agoI would never live in a neighborhood without an HOA or CC&Rs. Yes, they are anti-freedom and for me that is a good thing. I want my neighbors to treat their property and shared spaces in a way that allows me to live in peace and keeps my investment safe. No, I don't want my neighbor to have the freedom to paint their house lime green.