6 ms·
The average American woman now weighs 166 pounds – as much as a 1960s man
- tim333 11y agoIt mostly seems to be the grains and fats that have gone up. Too much doughnut like food I guess.
- gnoway 11y agoThe original WaPo article[1] is better IMO. It actually mentions that people on average are an inch taller than in 1960 before starting to pound the obesity drum. [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/06/12/look-at-how-much-weight-weve-gained-since-the-1960s/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/06/12/l...
- amirmc 11y agoTo be fair, this article also mentions the increase in height.
- gnoway 11y agoThank you. I read right over it. I still think the original article (though shorter) is better.
- maccard 11y agoBut it also goes on to say that the main reason is we're eating less healthy food, more of it, and are less active, and that that inch only partially accounts for the increased weight.
- bottled_poe 11y agoUp or out, what does it matter? It seems like overconsumption either way.
- lukas099 11y agoIsn't increased height generally taken as a sign of better nutrition?
- Jtsummers 11y agoYes. See the differences in the heights of the populations of the two Koreas over the past 50 or 60 years. Malnutrition in the north has resulted in a shorter population, while an abundance of food in the south has led to a taller population.
- bottled_poe 11y agoAnd? All that shows is that they ate less and were shorter as a result. Is that the conclusion?
- Jtsummers 11y agoMalnutrition is not the same as eating less. A healthy diet includes a variety of proteins, sugars, vitamins, minerals and other things. The North Korean diet has, for several generations now, been lacking in essential nutrients. The consequence is that their population has been shrinking (malnutrition during growing years means you don't grow). You can over consume food and still be malnourished. See a friend of mine in college that subsisted off a diet largely consisting of pastas and cheese, sometimes fruit. He was incredibly unhealthy, though he obtained more than enough calories to maintain his weight (he was somewhat overweight at the time, but not extremely so). Once he improved his diet he had enough energy to actually start exercising again and resolved several ongoing medical issues he had at the time due to missing key nutrients in his diet.
- bottled_poe 11y agoI understand the malnutrition crisis in North Korea. Of course that situation is appalling. I'm just saying that malnutrition and height are not polar opposites on some spectrum of good health.
- NietTim 11y agoAn inch in length doesn't weigh 26 pounds
- opcvx 11y agoSure, what you described actually weights exactly 0 pounds. But in general the volume of a sphere grows with the cube in regards to the radius, thus gaining an inch of height could add a lot of mass. How much depends on the object shape.
- will_work4tears 11y agoFrom my less than scientific observations (past heavy experience with bodybuilding/weightlifting), at similar levels of leanness 15%, 1 inch = 5 lbs. A well known calculator kind of confirms that[0]. I could see less lean individuals being 10 lbs or greater at one inch but 26 sure does seem high. [0] - http://www.weightrainer.net/bodypred.html http://www.weightrainer.net/bodypred.html For instance, if you put in the values 69 inches tall, 7 inch wrists, 9 inch ankles and 15% BF (not super lean but not overweight), you get a maximum lean bodyweight (natural) of 210lbs (years and years of bodybuilding), but at 70 inches, with the same measurements, it shows 215lbs being the maximum lean weight. Edit: Just to clarify, I'm certain that it's more of a percentage than a number and that it happens to be 5 lbs at around my height - a 4'll" woman might only differ 2-3 lbs at a similar build from a 5'0" woman.
- JoelSutherland 11y agoAbout an inch, but actually less than an inch and even less so for women. So women are ~1% taller and 18.5% heavier. I don't think height is a factor.
- sweezyjeezy 11y agoYou're assuming increased height only leads to a stretch in the z axis. If you linearly scaled someone up from 5'3 to 5'4 in every direction, the increase in volume would be 5%. So maybe not the main factor, but definitely a factor.
- Bill_Dimm 11y agoWhile you have a point, weight doesn't go like height cubed (you don't grow equally in all directions). I read an article a while ago (can't find it now) that looked at the exponent for various species. I think it was typically about 2.5 rather than 3. I suppose you could look at a BMI chart and back out the exponent that is assumed.
- dublinben 11y agoThe actual formula for determining BMI only squares the height component.[0] Healthy humans should not even approach being cube shaped! [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index
- sweezyjeezy 11y agoThis calculation is not exactly scientific, but : if U.S. women were an inch shorter then, that would make them 63 inches tall, instead of 64 inches (5'4). This equates to a 1.6% increase in height. If we assume that they have grown proportionally in all directions, we cube it, to get roughly a 5% increase in volume (which I will assume leads to a 5% increase in weight). The increase in weight of women was a lot more than this, roughly 18%, so it seems to me this is not the important factor.
- EugeneOZ 11y agoHope soon average American Journalist will use the metric system :)
- happyscrappy 11y agoThey should make a law that you can't order a pint at the pub, it must be ordered in metric if you are a member of the EU.
- jmkni 11y agoTo save you a round-trip to Google, that's 75.3KG
- to3m 11y agoAnd also known as 11.85 stone.
- globuous 11y agoAnd 5.16 slugs
- to3m 11y agoIs this a common unit of measurement for people's weight? Stone is standard in the UK for expressing people's weight, which is why I mentioned it. I've never met anybody that weighs themselves in pounds. (I bet I'm not the only person who isn't even sure how many pounds there are in a stone.) Certainly few people seem to have a good instinctive sense for whether a given amount in pounds is about average, a bit light, or a bit heavy. Which is why I thought UK readers might like to know how many stone there are in 166 pounds, but evidently not ;) I have a couple of friends who've gone metric and weigh themselves in kg. That's as avant garde as it gets.
- ionised 11y agoI'm from the UK and have started weighing myself in kilograms. Makes more sense now that I'm used to it.
- globuous 11y agoWow, I would never have guessed British didn't use pounds as a unit when weighting themselves. I thought you were just making fun of how there are always so many units in English for the same measurements, so I went an mentioned yet another mass/weight one. I honestly only remember ever using slugs in some classes in undergrad. I doubt anyone actually ever weights themselves in slugs. Actually, slug is a unit of mass, as opposed to pounds which measure a force. So a slug is the equivalent of a kg and a pound is the equivalent of a Newton. But there is also the 'pound mass' (lbs_m) and the 'kilogram force' (kg_f) to confuse us even more. I always thought it was interesting that the SI system is based around mass, time, and length whereas the English system is based around force, time, and length. Which means that in SI, the Newton is derived from the kg whereas in the English system the slug is derived from the pound. Of course, wikipedia states that the 'stone' unit you were mentioning is both a unit of mass and weight -.- Please correct me if I'm wrong though, that's what I remember from my B.S. in the States (I was born and raised with SI units). Also, is the unit of mass 'slug' ever used in conversations in English speaking countries ? I've never encountered it outside of science problems in my 4 years of undergrad (nor did I after, but I don't live in an English speaking country anymore)
- 300bps 11y agoThe advent of limitless food in the first world has created the need for a skill to focus on healthy food and ignore the junk. Those that can't slowly poison their bodies. Now in addition to that for the first time in history we are presented with unlimited information. It will be interesting to see the negative effects that come about for those unable to focus on the right things and ignore the junk.
- smtddr 11y agoSure would be nice if that unlimited information was universally accessible and accompanied by unlimited opportunities to actually implement anything learned from said info... because it sounds to me like your comment is basically saying "It's their own fault, let's watch them fail" without offering up anyway to help correct the issue.
- zzalpha 11y agoNo, I think his point is before we had lots of food, but a lot of it was bad and because not everyone can tell the difference, we've paid a great price. Now we have lots of information, and a lot of it is bad, and a lot of people can't tell the difference. What price will we pay for that?
- NanoWar 11y agoInteresting analogy. But I was hoping that medicine and education would work against that trend.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- smanuel 11y agoThe problem with unlimited information - it's getting harder and harder to tell what's good and what's bad for you: http://www.vox.com/2015/5/13/8591837/how-science-is-broken http://www.vox.com/2015/5/13/8591837/how-science-is-broken Take a look at the chart that's titled "Everything we eat both causes and prevents cancer". A picture that's worth a thousand words. We need better science. But I don't know how that's going to happen.
- crdb 11y agoWhat happened around 2000 that the fats & oils calories jumped so fast?
- twoodfin 11y agoI don't know, but I wouldn't take anything from "CPSI" (actually, CSPI: the Center for Science in the Public Interest) at face value. They're the exemplar of the Nanny State Scold. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Science_in_the_Public_Interest http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center_for_Science_in_the_Publi...
- zzalpha 11y agoSo find flaws in the data. Attacking the messenger does nothing to further the discourse. It's mudslinging at best and only creates more confusion and uncertainty.
- twoodfin 11y agoThe "data" they link is this "Special Feature Report Card", presumably prepared for one of CSPI's newsletters or PR blasts: http://cspinet.org/new/pdf/changing_american_diet_13.pdf http://cspinet.org/new/pdf/changing_american_diet_13.pdf It has one "citation": "Source for all graphs: U.S. Department of Agriculture." Well, OK then, but I don't think this chart is well-sourced enough to criticize except by blasting the lobbying group that pawns it off as resembling research. (I hope nobody thought CSPI actually did science!)
- zzalpha 11y agoHere's an idea. Go to the USDA website. Note they do food surveys and post all of their raw data tables online (gotta love the internet!): http://www.ars.usda.gov/main/site_main.htm?modecode=80-40-05-30 http://www.ars.usda.gov/main/site_main.htm?modecode=80-40-05... Now check the data if you don't believe it.
- crdb 11y agoFound the data [1] from [2] There is indeed a 17% increase in grams of fat between 1998 and 2000. That's 25g per day - around 5 times the olive oil you'd put in a portion of salad. Amazing increase for an entire population, no? [1] http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/179795/carbs_intake_d.html http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/179795/carbs_intake_d.html [2] http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-availability-(per-capita)-data-system/summary-findings.aspx http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-availability-(per...
- twoodfin 11y agoSo little is being held constant between "average American woman in 1966" and "average American woman in 2014" that I can't see the point of such a statistic except as clickbait.
- venomsnake 11y agoHmm ... has the average american woman grew new limbs, extra appendixes, wings, gills or something like that?
- twoodfin 11y agoNo, but she might be older or younger, live in a different part of the country, be more likely single or married, have different ancestry, have a different career, live in a household with a different fractional number of children, ... Any of these things could have an impact at least as great as the raw passage of time. IMHO, much more interesting to look at comparable individuals. Parents and their children and grandchildren at the same ages, for example.
- venomsnake 11y agoA woman is still a woman. Neither of the factors you mentioned causes weight gain. Let alone 20%
- timje1 11y agoYep, age will. If the average age of an American woman has changed from, say, 30 years to 50 years (aging population, changing demographics etc.) then this could contribute to weight differences because people tend to become more overweight as they age and get less active.
- gatesphere 11y ago14.2 extra gills, actually.
- GreaterFool 11y agoInstead of simply stating weight, how about tissue composition? Muscle vs bone vs fat?
- adevine 11y agoWeight and height are easy to accurately measure - tissue composition not so much. And while tissue composition is important for individuals, at a societal level, BMI (ratio of weight to height) is good enough because it's easy to show that the vast, vast majority of the change is due to people getting fatter. It's not like half of American women became bodybuilders.
- dec0dedab0de 11y agoIt's not like half of American women became bodybuilders. No, but it has become socially acceptable for women to be visually muscular. In the 70s, a body conscious woman would not likely be lifting weights and drinking protein powders.
- adevine 11y agoThe number of "visually muscular" women contributing to the rise in the average US female body weight is essentially a rounding error.
- jacquesm 11y agoThose billions of burgers have to go somewhere. Weird how the title mentions just the women, how have the men fared?
- mullsork 11y agoIf you read the article it's right there.
- jacquesm 11y agoExactly, so why focus on the women in the title?
- adventured 11y agoMen have gone from ~166 to ~196 since 1960. Men gained 17.6%, women gained 18.5%, so pretty similar.
- de_Selby 11y ago> The average American’s total caloric intake grew from 2,109 calories in 1970 to 2,568 calories in 2010. As Pew Research put it, that’s "the equivalent of an extra steak sandwich every day." A better comparison might be a snickers and a coke: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=snickers+and+coke http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=snickers+and+coke
- kyllo 11y agoYeah, what kind of steak sandwich would only have 459 calories? I wouldn't expect any reasonably sized and palatable steak sandwich to pack less than 800!
- dragonwriter 11y agoThank you for demonstrating part of the problem, the inflation in expected portion sizes.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 11y agoAs well as the expectation that calories make something "palatable".
- will_work4tears 11y agoThe difference between a lean steak and a nicely marbled steak in both taste and calories are significant. Not that lean meat is not palatable, but it might require some sauce due to dryness at most places (if you make it yourself, you can probably do better than most fast food restaurants) - and that extra sauce might bridge that calorie gap. Most places always overcook their meat, sadly, and lean meat isn't very palatable when overcooked; or it at least has less resistance to dryness than the fattier cuts.
- DanBC 11y ago
- revelation 11y agoI guess this is a typical misuse of the average, where we have lots of American women some way below 166 pounds and an equal amount much higher. Similarly, not every American is eating an extra sandwich, just some get two.
- emodendroket 11y agoWhy is this a "misuse" of the average? Is there really proof that there are a handful of outliers distorting the average? The article says 30% of Americans are obese; that alone seems like a large number, even if the other 70% were not heavier than they used to be (which I doubt).
- revelation 11y agoI'm not saying there are outliers that are distorting the average, I'm saying that there are few people that are the average. Hence we can't make decisions based on the value of the average.
- emodendroket 11y agoThat objection doesn't make sense if everyone is moving in the same direction.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoTIL that I weigh as much as a 1960s man, too! (Or a 2015 woman, depending on how I go about looking at it.)
- afarrell 11y agoThe oral contraceptive pill is approved by the FDA in 1957. Griswold v. Connecticut, which declares state laws against it unconstitutional is decided in 1965. Since we are already having a conversation about women's bodies, the fact that (according to http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_contr_use.html http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_contr_use.html, whose veracity I know nothing about) 16% of women aged 15-44 use daily hormone pills is probably relevant to a discussion of their bodies' tendency to retain adipose tissue. To be clear against uncharitable interpretation: I think the ability to decide when/if you get pregnant and have kids is fantastic.
- mason55 11y agoAnd how does this explain the 17.5% increase in men? Or are you saying that the pill accounts for the 1% difference?
- M8 11y ago"...I think the ability to decide when/if you get pregnant and have kids is fantastic..." Typical scenario: she lies to him she is (still) on the pill, gets pregnant - he has no say on abortion, gives a birth - he has to pay or he goes to jail. Both parties should have a say on whether a child gets born.
- mrgoldenbrown 11y ago"typical"? I don't think so. If "he" is worried about this, "he" has options of his own - surgery is reversible, and physical methods are widely available at every drug store.
- dublinben 11y agoDo you think that hormonal birth control makes it impossible to maintain a healthy bodyweight? The article very clearly points to an increase in daily caloric intake.
- glenra 11y agoThose two claims aren't incompatible. If birth control pills increased appetite, people would gain weight on them VIA an increase in daily caloric intake. (A third option is that being fatter makes people hungrier, so fatter people eat more...but starting down the path of getting fatter might have any random cause at all - that people are eating more doesn't give us much insight into why.)
- jfc 11y agoAverage American woman - 166 lbs., up 18.5% Average American man - 195.5 lbs., up 17.6% The title seems bit linkbait-y. Why focus on women, when it's really all Americans?
- swalsh 11y agoThis is a great article, I find it really curious that the only submission on Reddit is the hacker news repost. Perhaps the filters on there are capturing too much?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JohnTheBard 11y agoIf you follow the link from Vox to Washingtonpost, he links to reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/39dm6v/american_females_today_weigh_as_much_as_american/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/39dm6v/ame...
- bluedino 11y agoLet's travel back in time to the late 70's, early 80's. McDonald's was incredibly popular I would guess than the Big Mac and french fries are around the same serving size and calorie count as they are now. But the soft drinks were smaller. So you had less calories. People eat out at casual dining chains far, far more often than they do now. There are so many more Applebees/Chili's/ what have you now. Serving sizes are huge there. Appetizers alone are 1,000 calories. 1,500 calorie riblet platters, 1,400 calorie fajitas. 1,200 calorie salads. Fast casual. A burrito from Chipotle with chicken, beans, rice and sour cream is over 1,000 calories. Double that of a 500+ calorie Big Mac. Starbucks craze. People don't blink at the thought of drinking a 500 calorie treat from Starbucks every day. We just eat too dang much.
- dummy7953 11y agoThe serving sizes for the french fries are larger than they used to be. People (to conserve their mental energy, I assume) order by number, and that automatically includes a large order of fries. If I remember correctly, in the 70's & 80's McDonald's had only two sized of french fries, small and large. But you know what? Screw all this quibbling about specifics. Our portions are larger, we eat more, we exercise less. Our lifestyles and communities are pretty toxic from the standpoint of metabolism. Lots of places you have to get in a car to do the simplest things. This is a ridiculous way to live. Also, I wouldn't be surprised in the least to find that people eat more because they feel more economically desperate than before and because in real terms they are making less. My pet theory is that over-eating is a kind of hatred turned inward. It's like blaming yourself when the game is rigged to begin with. Blah, I covered a lot of ground there. Sorry for the sloppy thinking, but I think some things can be salvaged from there.
- flippinburgers 11y agoJust look at photos of your parents or grandparents generations. While not scientific per say, it is hilariously obvious that people are increasingly overweight. And to see people in this thread trying to defend the increases in weight is pure gold.
- RyanMcGreal 11y agoIt needs to be pointed out that one of the reasons Americans aren't more active is that the built environment has been designed to maximize driving to the active obstruction of any other way of getting around.
- adevine 11y agoIt's not just driving. The company I work for has an office in Marseille, France. At that office, there is a beautiful staircase that spirals around the middle of an open central area. In the middle of that area is a tiny, metal elevator. Virtually everyone takes the stairs, and the elevator is basically only there for the physically impaired. At the US office, the ONLY access to higher floors (mind you, the building only has 4 floors total) from the lobby is through two large elevators. To even use the stairs you have to enter through a back alleyway, and the stairs themselves are the basic dungy "pretty much emergency use only" type stairs. I see this pattern everywhere, where basic design and access flow in the US discourages even the slightest amount of physical exertion.